Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

All-Risk Does Not Mean Everything Is Covered: Read the Exclusions and the Lease First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron. One point of lane discipline first: I am a real estate broker, not a licensed insurance broker, and which insurer or limit to buy is not my call. What I can do is help you understand the structure of the policy and the lease, so the questions you take to an insurance broker are the ones that matter.

The plain conclusion: the difference between all-risk and named perils is not just how much is covered. It is who has to prove what after a loss, and where the real boundary of the policy is written. Named perils pays only for listed risks, and you must show your loss is on the list. All-risk pays for risks that are not excluded, and the insurer must show your loss falls inside an exclusion. The words on the cover are never the coverage itself.

First: two structures, and the burden of proof runs in opposite directions

The Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) describes two basic forms of business property insurance. A named perils policy covers only loss or damage caused by perils listed in the policy, subject to exclusions. An all risk policy covers loss or damage caused by any peril, unless specifically excluded.

That sounds like a small definitional point. At claim time it is not. Take an invented example: a buried pipe bursts suddenly and floods the ground floor. Under a named perils policy, you start by finding the event on the list and matching the wording; if it is not there, the discussion ends. Under an all-risk policy, the starting point is that the loss is covered, unless the insurer can place it inside an exclusion — for instance, by arguing it was gradual leakage rather than a sudden event. The same flood, negotiated from opposite ends.

Price follows structure. Named perils is usually cheaper because the covered field is narrower. All-risk usually costs more because both scope and proof favour the insured. Cheaper is not automatically wrong and dearer is not automatically right. What matters is whether the losses this particular building actually fears are inside the coverage.

Second: the real content of an all-risk policy is in its exclusions

All-risk is defined by subtraction: coverage equals every risk, minus the exclusions. So the first pages to read in an all-risk policy are not the cover — they are the exclusion list. Which risks are commonly carved out and handled by endorsement or a separate policy varies by insurer; flood and surface water, earthquake, sewer backup, gradual damage and wear and tear, mechanical or electrical breakdown of equipment itself, and pollution are common directions. How far each exclusion reaches must be checked line by line in your own policy, never from memory.

Two figures matter more to the cheque you eventually receive than the name of the form. One is the valuation basis: actual cash value deducts depreciation, while replacement cost puts back an item of like kind and use. The same fire can produce very different settlements under the two. The other is a co-insurance type requirement: if the amount insured falls well below the proportion the policy requires, a payment can be reduced proportionally — insure the building short, and even a partial loss is not paid in full. Both live in the policy, not in the brochure.

Property insurance pays for physical damage to the building. It does not automatically replace the rent you stop collecting while you rebuild. On the landlord's side that gap is loss of rental income coverage; on the business side IBC calls it business interruption, covering loss of profits and continuing fixed expenses when an insured event prevents normal operations. Ask how long the indemnity period runs. Rebuilding runs through adjustment, design, permits and construction — none of which you control — and if the period is short, you carry the back half of the rent loss yourself.

Third: who insures what must match the lease — and the lease can decide who pays

A building usually holds two policies. The landlord's covers the building itself, structure, common areas, the landlord's own liability and usually loss of rental income. The tenant's covers its stock, equipment, business interruption and commercial general liability. The danger zone is in between: leasehold improvements the tenant paid for are physically attached to the landlord's building. Who insures them is not an insurance truism — it is whatever the lease says. When each side assumes the other insured them, the usual result is that nobody did.

Lease wording can go further and decide who bears a loss after it happens. In Royal Host GP Inc. v. 1842259 Ontario Ltd., 2018 ONCA 467, a fire that started in the tenant's kitchen damaged the building, the landlord's insurer paid, and then pursued the tenant. The tenant relied on the Supreme Court of Canada's earlier trilogy of cases and argued that, having contributed to the premiums, it should not be pursued. The Court of Appeal did not accept that as a blanket rule. It went back to the lease text: the lease contained clear notwithstanding language stating that, even though the landlord covenanted to insure and the tenant contributed to the cost, the tenant remained liable for its own negligence. On that wording, the subrogated claim was allowed to proceed.

The lesson for buyers and sellers is direct: contributing to premiums is not automatic immunity, and a landlord's policy is not the end of the analysis. Additional insured status, waivers of subrogation, and which party insures which part of the risk — as actually written in the lease — are how the loss is allocated on the day something burns or floods. When you buy a building, read the leases' insurance clauses against the policies in force, side by side.

Document Three things that must line up
Policy Form, exclusion list, valuation basis and insured proportion
Lease Who insures what, who insures improvements, negligence and subrogation wording
Income cover Rental income or business interruption scope and indemnity period

Common misunderstandings

1. "All-risk means everything is covered." No. It covers what is not excluded. The exclusion list is the policy's real boundary.

2. "Named perils is always worse than all-risk." Not necessarily. It is narrower and usually cheaper; the question is whether the risks you fear are on its list. The two forms can also be used for different property within one arrangement.

3. "The tenant helped pay the premiums, so it can never be pursued." The Royal Host decision shows the lease text governs. Premium contribution is not an automatic shield.

4. "Insure the building and the rent is automatically covered." Property cover and income cover are different things. Rental income protection needs its own scope and its own period, confirmed separately.

If you hold a commercial property, I suggest this order

  1. Confirm the form of each policy — named perils or all-risk — and read the full exclusion list.
  2. Check valuation and amount: replacement cost or actual cash value, whether the limit keeps pace with today's rebuilding cost, and whether a shortfall reduces payments proportionally.
  3. Confirm rental income or business interruption cover separately, and ask about the indemnity period, not just the limit.
  4. Lay the leases' insurance clauses beside the policies: who insures the building, who insures stock and equipment, who insures tenant improvements, and whether subrogation is waived.
  5. Before a purchase or a renewal of a lease, have an insurance broker review the placement against the building's actual use, and a lawyer review the liability and subrogation wording in the leases.
  6. Repeat step two at every renewal. Rebuilding costs move; a limit that does not move with them opens a gap quietly.

I am Ming Ren. I do not sell insurance — but whether the policy, the leases and the numbers line up with each other is something we can check together, line by line.


This article is general information, not insurance or legal advice. Coverage is governed by the actual policy wording. Consult a licensed insurance broker for placement and claims questions, and an Ontario lawyer for lease liability questions.

Primary sources: Insurance Bureau of Canada, Types of Business Insurance Coverage; Royal Host GP Inc. v. 1842259 Ontario Ltd., 2018 ONCA 467 (CanLII), consulted November 2026. The water-loss scenario is illustrative, not a real claim.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation