I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: a billboard lease looks like small rent, but owners routinely underrate their negotiating position. A lawfully existing third party sign — one advertising something unrelated to the business on the property — is hard to replicate under today's municipal rules. Move it next door and it would likely never be approved. What an operator fears losing on renewal is the location itself. Before signing, separate the three layers of rights, then check how much of that location's value the lease quietly gives away.
1. Structure, permit and lease belong to different parties
At least three layers sit on one billboard, usually with different owners. The structure — steel, sign face, lighting and access walkways — is normally built and owned by the sign operator as its trade equipment, not as part of your building. The municipal permit: in Toronto, signs are governed by Chapter 694 of the Municipal Code, the Sign By-law; a third party sign permit is issued to the sign owner, the operator, and the application requires the property owner's consent — no consent, no permit on your land. The lease is the layer you hold: the contract that rents the operator the patch of land or wall the whole arrangement stands on.
Once separated, the negotiation is clear. The operator holds the permit and the equipment; you hold the only location where that permit can live. Toronto also levies a third party sign tax under Chapter 771, charged to the sign owner by sign type and size. That is a line in the operator's cost ledger, not owner income — do not let the two be blended in a rent discussion. Other municipalities run their own sign by-laws and fees; Toronto's numbers do not travel. Check the by-law of the municipality where the property actually sits.
2. Why an existing permitted site is hard to replace
Toronto's Sign By-law divides the city into sign districts. Third party signs are permitted in only a limited set of districts and must meet separation and setback rules from residential districts, sensitive uses, other third party signs and highways, plus limits on sign area, height, and, for electronic signs, brightness and copy-change intervals. The practical result: a sign approved years ago could not be re-approved today one lot over. That "cannot be re-approved" quality is where much of an existing site's value lives.
An invented example, only to make the point: two neighbouring buildings on the same arterial road. Building A carries a sign permitted for years; Building B has a blank wall. B's owner assumes the same lease is available — until a by-law check shows B cannot obtain a third party sign permit at all. Half the value of A's lease is not in the wall; it is in a permit that cannot be recreated. An owner who renews at ordinary wall-rent thinking has given that half away.
Lawful today is not automatically lawful forever, either. Verify the sign's permit status, whether it survives only through a variance or an earlier approval, and whether a conversion to an electronic sign needs a fresh approval. When an operator proposes "upgrading to digital while we're at it," that is usually a new permit and a new negotiation — not a free extra.
3. The clauses that actually decide the money
Rent is only one clause. These decide the rest:
| Clause | Owner-unfriendly version | What to settle |
|---|---|---|
| Term and renewal | Long term plus operator-only renewal options at small fixed increases | Renewals re-confirmed by both sides; increases tied to market or an index |
| Exclusivity | No other sign of any kind on the property, including the owner's own signage | Limit exclusivity to third party advertising; keep your own signage rights |
| Removal and restoration | Silent on who removes the structure, when, and at whose cost | Removal deadline, restoration standard and cost on the operator |
| Sale and assignment | Operator may assign freely; a long below-market lease locks in the next buyer | Assignment needs owner consent; before selling, work out whether the lease adds to or subtracts from price |
| Tax and upkeep | Sign tax, insurance and structural safety left vague | Sign tax, structure maintenance and insurance expressly on the operator |
On a sale, treat three things separately: how the lease carries over as a contract, how the permit is dealt with at the City, and how the sign income is counted in valuation. Stable sign rent can support value — but a below-market lease with long operator-only renewals makes buyers discount the property. The same sign, papered differently, can move price in opposite directions.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The sign is on my building, so the permit must be mine." No. Structure and permit usually sit with the operator. You hold the location and the lease, and on a sale or a change of operator each layer is dealt with separately.
"The rent has not changed in years, so that must be its value." More likely the lease was never re-priced under current rules. The tighter the by-law, the scarcer existing sites become — and the less an old rent tells you.
"The sign tax is a property charge, so the owner ends up paying it." In Toronto the third party sign tax is charged to the sign owner. If your lease shifts it to you, treat that as a straight rent reduction.
If a sign sits on your property today, do these five things in order
- Assemble all three files first: the current lease, the sign permit, and the property's sign district and compliance status under the local by-law. Do not discuss price with any of them missing.
- Mark up the expiry date, who holds renewal rights, the increase formula and the exclusivity scope.
- Before renewing, have someone who knows the local sign by-law confirm whether this location could be approved new today, and what a digital conversion would require.
- Put removal, restoration, insurance, sign tax and structural maintenance into the lease itself, not into verbal assurances.
- If you plan to sell, address the billboard lease six months early, so a buyer's diligence finds a clear answer on whether it helps or hurts the price.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. For any "small rent" on a property, first ask how scarce the location it occupies really is — then we can talk numbers.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Sign by-laws differ sharply by municipality; outcomes depend on the local by-law, permit status and the lease itself. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Toronto Municipal Code Chapter 694 (Signs, General) and Chapter 771 (Third Party Sign Tax); Municipal Act, 2001, S.O. 2001 (Ontario e-Laws), consulted November 2026. No specific rents or tax amounts are used in this article; check the current by-law and fee schedule for the property's municipality.


