Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Buy or Lease Your Business Premises? Start With Whether the Business Looks the Same in Three Years

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: neither buying nor leasing is inherently the smarter move. Buying converts monthly rent into an asset you own, at the price of tying up your down payment and losing the freedom to move or expand. Leasing buys flexibility and preserves cash, at the price of owning nothing when the term ends. The right starting point is not "how many years of rent have I already paid" — it is two questions: how stable is this business's cash flow, and how certain are you about location and size over the next several years? This article sets out the full cost comparison and the financing routes on the buying side.

First: compare both sides over the same number of years, with nothing left out

Comparing "mortgage payment versus rent" guarantees a wrong answer. Each side carries costs the other does not:

Buy (owner-occupied) Lease
Upfront cash Down payment plus closing and financing costs, committed at once Deposit and initial fit-out — far less cash tied up
Monthly outlay Mortgage payment + property taxes + insurance + maintenance Net rent + additional rent (TMI), plus 13% HST
Commonly missed Major-repair reserves, vacancy risk, the return the down payment could have earned inside the business Rent escalation on renewal, relocation and refit costs at the next premises
What remains at the end The property, less the outstanding loan balance Flexibility: move, expand, or wind down

An illustrative example with numbers I invented: a unit leased for five years at roughly $6,000 a month in net rent and additional rent pays out about $360,000 over the term, with a possible increase at renewal. Buying a comparable property at, say, $1,200,000 with 30% down commits $360,000 upfront; taxes, insurance and maintenance ride on top of the mortgage, and after five years you hold a property net of its loan balance — but that down payment could not work inside your business for those five years. Which side wins depends on what your business earns on its cash and whether you still need that location in year five. That is exactly why there is no universal answer.

Second: if you buy, ask about two financing routes first

The first is a conventional commercial mortgage. Owner-occupied property is underwritten differently from a pure investment property: the lender focuses on your business's financial statements, whether the operation can carry the payments, and how much of the property your business itself occupies. Loan-to-value, rates and amortization vary widely between lenders, so I will not quote figures here — any percentage promised without seeing your financials is not worth relying on. Get real quotes and compare them.

The second is the federal Canada Small Business Financing Program (CSBFP). These are the terms as verified against ISED's official program pages: it serves small businesses operating in Canada with gross annual revenues of $10 million or less; the term loan maximum is $1 million, and the portion used to purchase or improve real property you will own can reach that full $1 million; a line of credit of up to $150,000 is available on top, for a combined maximum of $1.15 million; for real property loans, the government's coverage period runs up to 15 years, while payments may be amortized over up to 25 years; and there is a key owner-use rule — at least 50% of the property must be used to operate your business. You apply through a bank or other financial institution, not to the government directly, and the lending decision rests with the institution.

Surplus space can sometimes be leased to other tenants, with their rent offsetting your payments — but confirm the zoning permits it and that you genuinely want the landlord workload before counting that income.

Third: ownership structure and tax belong before the offer, not after

A common structure is for a holding company to own the property and lease it to your operating company, driven by liability separation and tax planning: how the rent between the companies is set, how capital cost allowance is used, how a future sale's gain is treated, and how succession works all turn on the structure. There is no universally best answer, and restructuring later costs far more than structuring correctly at the start. My rule: before you offer, have your accountant and lawyer draw the structure. Your broker does not decide your taxes.

The reverse case deserves equal honesty: if the business is still expanding, may need double the space in three years, or is still testing its location, my advice is usually to lease and keep the cash in the business. For a growing business, flexibility is not waste — it is insurance.

Three common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: "Five years of rent was a down payment thrown away." That counts only one side. In those five years you paid no property tax, insurance or major repairs, your capital was never locked into a building, and you kept the freedom to move or grow. All of that has value.

Misunderstanding 2: "Owner-occupied financing always comes at a very high loan-to-value." There is no such guarantee. Leverage depends on your business financials, debt coverage and the property itself, and the CSBFP has its own caps and owner-use requirement. Get a real lender decision before you price an offer.

Misunderstanding 3: "Once I buy, leases are no longer my problem." If part of the space is rented out, you have become a landlord: Ontario's commercial tenancy rules under the Commercial Tenancies Act and the work of managing tenants land on you. And the lease between your holding company and your operating company should be a proper written lease too.

If you are weighing buy versus lease now, I suggest this order

  1. Write down your honest five-year view: will the location change, will the space need change, how stable is cash flow? If any one of the three is uncertain, lean toward leasing.
  2. Build the full five-year cost of both sides from the table above, leaving nothing out, then compare.
  3. Before offering, get a lender pre-approval, and check CSBFP eligibility item by item: the $10 million revenue ceiling, the $1 million term loan maximum, and the at-least-50% owner-use rule.
  4. Have your accountant and lawyer settle the ownership structure — individual, operating company or holding company — before the offer, and price its tax effect into the comparison.
  5. If you lease instead, negotiate the renewal right, escalation limits and early-termination terms properly. The flexibility of leasing only exists if the contract protects it.

I am Ming Ren. Decide buy versus lease on the stage of the business and the full numbers first, and look at specific properties second.


This article is general information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Loan terms are subject to lender approval; CSBFP terms are as published by ISED; consult your accountant and an Ontario lawyer on structure and tax.

Primary sources: Canada Small Business Financing Program official pages (Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, consulted November 2026): gross annual revenues of $10 million or less, term loan maximum of $1 million, line of credit of $150,000, and at least 50% of the property used to operate the borrower's business; Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7 (Ontario e-Laws). The $6,000 monthly and $1,200,000 price figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation