Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Assignment or Sublet? The Real Question Is Whether You Stay on the Hook

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the short version. When your business is being sold, shrinking, or moving and your lease still has time to run, only two questions matter: who is coming in, and who does the landlord chase if things go wrong. An assignment and a sublet both put someone else in your space, but they differ in the one place that counts — whether you have actually stepped out of the lease. Sublet, and you may leave the premises while your liability stays behind. Assign, and you have a chance to exit — but a clean release is something you negotiate and get in writing, not something that happens automatically.

First: two structures, two very different chains of liability

An assignment transfers your whole position under the lease to an assignee. The assignee steps in as the landlord's tenant and carries on under the same rent and terms. It suits a sale of the business or a permanent exit. A sublet is different: your head lease with the landlord stays exactly as it is, and you sign a separate sublease giving a subtenant part or all of the space for a period of time. The subtenant's contract is with you, not with the landlord.

Point of comparison Assignment Sublet
Your relationship with the landlord The assignee takes your place Unchanged — you remain the tenant
Does the incoming party contract directly with the landlord? Yes No — only with you
Do you remain liable? Depends on the lease and consent documents; landlords often keep the original tenant on the hook unless an express release is given Yes — your obligations under the head lease remain entirely yours
Best suited to Selling the business, leaving permanently Temporary downsizing, sharing surplus space, possibly returning later

A simple invented example, with numbers used only to illustrate: you have three years left and you sell your restaurant together with the lease — that is an assignment, and what you negotiate is your exit. If instead you sublet a third of your back storage space to a small neighbouring business for a year, that is a sublet, and what you negotiate is how you are protected when the subtenant defaults. Different deals, different risks.

Second: landlord consent — where the statute helps, and where it stops

Both routes normally need the landlord's written consent first. Section 23(1) of Ontario's Commercial Tenancies Act gives a measure of protection: where a lease contains a covenant against assigning or subletting without the landlord's licence or consent, that covenant is read as subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld — unless the lease contains an express provision to the contrary. Under s. 23(2), if the landlord refuses or neglects to consent, the tenant, assignee, or subtenant can apply to a judge of the Superior Court of Justice, who may decide whether consent was unreasonably withheld and, if so, make an order that stands in place of the landlord's consent, so the transaction is not a breach.

That protection has real limits, and I will state them plainly:

  • Your lease can contract out of it. The section itself says so. If your lease states that consent is in the landlord's sole discretion, the s. 23 default may not help you. Read your lease before assuming the statute is on your side.
  • "Unreasonable" is fact-specific. A financially weak assignee, an unlawful use, or a use that conflicts with the property can support a refusal. Wanting to use the request as leverage for higher rent may not. Each case turns on its evidence.
  • Court takes time and money. Section 23(2) is a remedy, not a shortcut. A business sale has a closing date, and court schedules rarely cooperate — which is why, in practice, most consents are won by applying early with a complete package.

Third: an assignment does not automatically release you

This is the point most often stated wrong. Many commercial leases expressly keep the original tenant liable for the assignee's performance after an assignment, or require the original tenant to sign a guarantee or indemnity. And a landlord's consent to the assignment is not the same thing as a release of you: consent permits the transfer; a release ends your liability. They are separate intentions and must be documented separately.

So when you negotiate an assignment, the valuable words are these: whether you are released on the effective date; if not, whether your liability has a time limit or a cap; and what notice and cure rights you get if the assignee defaults. If you cannot get a release, price that contingent liability into your business sale instead of accounting for yourself as fully out. On the sublet side there is no ambiguity at all: if the subtenant stops paying, damages the space, or disappears, the landlord looks to you under the head lease, and you pay first and chase the subtenant afterwards. Your sublease should deal with deposits, default, and your right to inspect.

Common misunderstandings

"Once I sublet it, it's not my problem." The opposite is true. Under a sublet you remain the landlord's tenant, so the subtenant's default is your default.

"The law says consent can't be unreasonably withheld, so the landlord must agree." Section 23 applies only where the lease does not expressly provide otherwise — and "not unreasonably withheld" is not "must always be granted." A landlord with a legitimate reason can refuse.

"The landlord consented to my assignment, so I'm released." Consent allows the transfer. A release has to be stated separately in the consent document or the lease.

"A verbal okay is fine; we'll paper it later." Consent, assignments, and subleases should all be in writing. Verbal arrangements help almost no one when rent stops or a sale closing is at risk.

If you have to deal with an unexpired lease now, I suggest this order

  1. Pull the assignment, subletting, and consent clauses from your lease and read them word for word — especially any express wording that displaces the s. 23 default.
  2. Decide whether you want a permanent exit or a temporary arrangement: exit points to an assignment with a negotiated release; temporary points to a sublet with proper protection.
  3. Send the landlord a complete package the first time: the incoming party's financial information, business plan, proposed use, and track record. A complete file makes an unreasonable refusal harder to sustain.
  4. Negotiate consent and release as two separate items. If there is no release, build the contingent liability into your price.
  5. Have an Ontario commercial leasing lawyer review everything before signing — and, on a business sale, align the lease closing conditions with the sale's closing date.

I am Ming Ren. If you are dealing with a commercial lease you need to exit or share, bring the lease itself — we will go through the clauses one by one, on the documents and the numbers.


This article is general information, not legal advice. Your lease wording, the consent documents, and your transaction structure will affect the outcome; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary source: Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7, s. 23 (Ontario e-Laws, reviewed November 2026). The restaurant and storage examples are invented illustrations, not real transactions.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation