I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The conclusion first: in Ontario, whether an arrangement for commercial space is a lease or a licence is decided not by the word at the top of the document, but by what the arrangement actually gives you. The core test is exclusive possession: for the agreed period, can you keep everyone — including the owner — out of a defined space? If yes, what you hold is likely a lease, whatever the document calls itself. If no, you likely hold only a personal permission to use space, which can be taken back. This is not wordplay. It decides, when the owner wants you out, whether you have the statutory route of applying to court for relief against forfeiture under section 20 of the Commercial Tenancies Act — a route a pure licensee does not have.
1. The layer on which a licence and a lease differ
A licence is, in principle, a personal permission: the owner allows you to be on their property for a purpose. What you get is a right to be there, not an interest in the land itself, and permission of that kind is in principle easier to revoke; the occupier holds no right in the space that can be asserted against others.
A lease is different in kind: it grants exclusive possession of a defined space for a defined term, and with it an interest in the land. That is why a tenant carries a framework beyond the contract itself, including protections under the Commercial Tenancies Act. The dividing line is not the price, not the length of the term, and not the document's title. It is whether possession is exclusive: can the owner walk in at will, move you to a different spot, or share the space with others? Those facts, taken together, are the material a classification is made from.
2. Why the label cannot be trusted
Documents calling themselves licences are everywhere in practice: a mall kiosk, a coworking desk, a monthly parking spot, a short-term pop-up. Some of those arrangements genuinely are licences — a floating desk, an operator who keeps the right to move you and to enter, points that way. But some documents say "licence" while in substance handing over a fixed space, the occupier's own lock, and no right for the owner to enter at will. That arrangement is very likely a lease in substance.
Courts look at substance, not labels, weighing the whole document together with how the arrangement actually operates: is the space defined, is the term defined, can the occupier exclude others, how much control did the owner keep? The most dangerous assumption at signing is "it says licence, so it is flexible and easy to walk away from." Flexibility is not conferred by the title; in a dispute, what you actually received is what counts. The mirror warning applies to owners: renaming a document a licence does not strip a tenant of statutory protection if the substance is a lease. Renaming changes nothing underneath.
3. Why the dividing line is worth real money
The sharpest practical difference appears when you are asked to leave. If the arrangement is a lease and the landlord enforces forfeiture for a breach, the tenant may apply to the Superior Court of Justice under section 20(1) of the Commercial Tenancies Act for relief against forfeiture, and the court decides, on all the circumstances, whether the lease continues and on what terms. A pure licensee has no such statutory application; when the permission is revoked, their position rests on what the document itself says.
Stability differs too: a leasehold interest generally stands up better when the property is sold or circumstances change, while a licence hangs more heavily on the person who granted it and the paper it is written on. For a small business this is not abstract. If you have paid for fit-out and built a customer base in that spot, how secure your occupation is decides whether that investment is protected. My practical advice: before signing any "licence," measure it with the exclusive-possession ruler. If it measures as a lease, negotiate term, exit and protections with lease-level care. If it truly is a licence, nail down the notice period and the conditions for taking the space back — do not sign paper that lets you be removed at will.
An invented example, with fictional people: a small retailer signs a one-page "Licence Agreement" for a fixed kiosk in a mall concourse, with her own lock, which mall staff never enter. Eighteen months later the mall wants the spot back on short notice. The argument that matters is not the document's title — it is what kind of possession she actually enjoyed for those eighteen months. If someone had run the exclusive-possession test for her at signing, her negotiating position would have been entirely different.
Common misunderstandings
Myth 1: "The document says licence, so I definitely am not a tenant." No. Labels do not decide classification; substance does. A "licence" that grants exclusive possession is very likely a lease.
Myth 2: "A licence is more flexible, so it is better for the occupier." Flexibility has a flip side: no lease means no statutory route such as relief against forfeiture under section 20. When permission is revoked, the document is all you have.
Myth 3: "An owner can avoid commercial tenancy protections by calling the deal a licence." Renaming avoids nothing. Courts classify by substance; if the substance is a lease, the protections — and the owner's obligations — follow.
If you are about to sign a "licence" for space, do these in order
- Measure exclusive possession first: is the space fixed, can you lock it, can the owner enter or move you? Compare the document with the actual arrangement, item by item.
- Read the notice and take-back terms: how much warning can end your occupation, and is there any treatment of your fit-out investment?
- If you are spending on fit-out or building a business there, get term and stability into the document — not into a verbal promise.
- If classification is genuinely unclear, have an Ontario commercial leasing lawyer classify the arrangement by substance before you sign.
- If you receive a take-back notice, classify first, then reply: if it is a lease, the section 20 relief route needs attention immediately.
Straight dealing and careful work — that is how I do business. I am Ming Ren. Bring the documents, and we will go through them line by line.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Classification of a licence versus a lease depends on the document and how the arrangement actually operates; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources checked: Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7, ss.1 and 20(1) (Ontario e-Laws, checked November 2026); the exclusive-possession framework is a common-law principle. The kiosk example above is invented and illustrative only.


