Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Fire, Flood, or a Government Shutdown Order: Whether Rent Stops Depends on Two Paragraphs in Your Lease

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: when disaster hits, the question every Ontario commercial tenant asks is "can the rent stop?" The law's answer is cold: Ontario has no statute called force majeure, and no authority will declare your rent suspended. Your position is decided entirely by two paragraphs most people skim at signing — the force majeure clause and the casualty (damage and destruction) clause. Only if both fail you does the doctrine of frustration remain, and its threshold is very high. Ontario's courts worked through all three lines during the pandemic years, and every commercial tenant and landlord should know where they landed before they need to.

1. Three lines — work out which one you are on

Line Basis Typical effect
Force majeure clause Pure lease drafting; courts enforce it as written When a listed event occurs, the performance the clause names is excused or extended; most leases state expressly that force majeure does not excuse the obligation to pay rent
Casualty clause Lease drafting — a separate section for physical damage such as fire or flood Who must repair, whether rent abates during repair, and how long the landlord has before one side may terminate — all as that section provides
Frustration Common law doctrine, with the Frustrated Contracts Act adjusting money afterwards Only where an event makes performance radically different from what was undertaken — not merely more expensive or harder — does the contract end altogether; temporary shutdowns generally do not qualify

The first practical distinction is between rows one and two. A government closure order runs through the force majeure clause; a fire or a flood runs through the casualty clause. The two sections routinely have different event lists, different notice requirements, and different consequences. Running a shutdown through the casualty clause, or a fire through force majeure, misfires at step one.

2. What the courts actually decided

Two Ontario decisions draw the boundaries clearly:

Braebury v. Gap (2021, Superior Court). During the pandemic lockdowns, the tenant argued the lease was frustrated and rent should stop. The court held that the lockdowns engaged the lease's force majeure clause, but that clause expressly did not excuse rent — and that the lockdowns did not frustrate the lease either. Rent remained payable. The case set the practical tone: the clause means what it says, and frustration will not rescue a temporary interruption of business.

Niagara Falls Shopping Centre v. LAF Canada (2023, Court of Appeal). A fitness tenant's force majeure clause covered government restrictions, while another sentence said lack of funds was not a force majeure event. Reading the clause word by word, the Court of Appeal produced a result that surprised both sides: the tenant still owed rent for the closure periods, but the term of the lease was extended by the length of the closures, rent-free for the extension. The lesson cuts both ways — a force majeure clause is not boilerplate decoration. What it extends, what it excuses, and what it excludes will be enforced literally. If you do not read it at signing, you will live with someone else's reading of it in a crisis.

Read together, the current Ontario position is this: the rent obligation is extremely shock-resistant. It pauses or ends only where the lease says so in words, or where an event is grave enough to change the contract's very nature. Expecting the law to "understand" because something big happened is, in commercial leasing, a plan to be disappointed.

3. Insurance is a third ledger — do not merge it with the first two

One more layer is constantly confused with the clauses: insurance. The landlord's property policy and the tenant's property and business interruption coverage respond according to their own triggers — many business interruption policies require physical damage, and a government closure order alone may not trigger them. But keep the ledgers separate: an insurance payout answers "where does the money come from," not "was the rent legally owing." The negotiation that actually works puts all three ledgers on the table at once — what the clauses say, what insurance will cover, and where each side can give ground. Inferring lease rights from a policy, or policy coverage from a lease clause, is a category error in both directions.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Force majeure is built into the law; it applies automatically in a disaster." Ontario common law has no free-standing force majeure doctrine. If your lease does not contain the clause, there is no clause. If it does, it operates only for the events it lists and the consequences it states — not an inch further.

"The government ordered us closed, so of course rent stops." Braebury says otherwise: a closure order may trigger the clause without excusing rent, and most leases expressly carve rent out of the relief. Whether rent stops is read off your lease's text, not off the news.

"The building burned down, so the lease is simply over." Physical damage runs through the casualty clause: first come repair obligations and deadlines, and only if the damage is not restored within the agreed period does a termination right arise for one side or the other. Until that machinery runs, neither the lease nor the rent obligation necessarily disappears. "It burned, so it's over" is the most dangerous assumption in this area.

If you are signing or renewing a commercial lease, do these five things in order

  1. Read the force majeure clause word by word: does the event list reach government orders, utility failures, and epidemics? Is rent expressly excluded from relief? Is there a written-notice deadline for invoking it?
  2. Read the casualty clause separately: who repairs, over what period, what happens to rent meanwhile, past what deadline may either side terminate, and how deposits and prepaid rent are settled on termination.
  3. Flag any mismatch between the two sections while you can still negotiate — for example, force majeure extending the term while the casualty clause terminates on the original expiry date. Fixing conflicts at signing is the cheapest it will ever be.
  4. Have your insurance broker align the policies with the lease: business interruption triggers, waiting periods, and limits, measured against the rent risk the lease actually leaves on you.
  5. If disaster does strike, do three things immediately: preserve the scene and your loss evidence, give the written notices the lease requires, and notify your insurer — the notice deadlines in both the lease and the policy are hard dates.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. The two least-read paragraphs in a lease routinely decide where a great deal of money goes in the worst week of a tenancy. Read them before you sign — then we can talk rent and term.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The interpretation of force majeure and casualty clauses depends heavily on the lease's exact text and the facts of the event. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Braebury Development Corp. v. Gap (Canada) Inc. (Ont. S.C.J.); Niagara Falls Shopping Centre Inc. v. LAF Canada Co., 2023 ONCA 159; Frustrated Contracts Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. F.34 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026).

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation