Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Your Lease Says You Must Stay Open. Can an Ontario Landlord Actually Make You Trade?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The conclusion first: no Ontario statute directly orders a commercial tenant to keep operating — the Commercial Tenancies Act contains no continuous-operation obligation at all. That duty exists only where your lease creates it, as a contract term. And when a dispute comes, what a landlord can realistically pursue is usually money for the breach, not an order forcing you to open the doors and run the business every day. So the key question is never just "what does the clause say" — it is "what does the other side actually want: money, or an open store?"

1. Where this obligation comes from — and where it does not

Separate two layers. Ontario's basic commercial leasing statute is the Commercial Tenancies Act, but that Act gives a landlord no tool to compel a tenant to trade. A continuous-operation or operating covenant — lease language along the lines of "continuously and actively carry on business" — is purely a term the parties agree to in the lease. Whether it exists, how it is worded, and what hours it demands are all questions answered by that one document.

Two consequences follow. First, a tenant who never signed such a clause does not breach a statute merely by closing; your duties start with your contract. Second, a tenant who did sign cannot say "no statute mentions it, so the clause is void" — a contract promise is a promise, and breaking it is a breach. What remains to argue about is the consequence. Mixing these layers up is where most of these disputes start: the tenant thinks the statute is a shield, the landlord thinks the clause is a lever to force trading, and both are aiming in the wrong direction.

2. What a landlord can realistically get

If a tenant goes dark early, the landlord's practical remedies are mainly monetary: rent and damages under the lease, and, where the lease language and facts support it, steps toward terminating the lease and recovering the premises. Those are accounting questions — how much loss, proved how, under what wording — and courts have well-worn paths for them.

An order compelling the tenant to keep operating is a different species of request. It asks a court to supervise a live business for months or years: opening hours, staffing, stock. Courts are inherently cautious about orders that need that kind of continuing supervision, and in practice very few cases end there; most land on damages and on whether the lease survives. So I tell landlord clients: do not treat this clause as a guarantee at signing — it is better understood as a doorway to compensation. And I tell tenant clients the mirror image: the fact that a landlord probably cannot force you to trade does not make closing free. The bill for the breach still arrives.

One more piece of the framework: if the landlord moves to terminate, the relief-against-forfeiture provisions in sections 19 and 20 of the Commercial Tenancies Act come into play. In short, where a landlord enforces a right of re-entry or forfeiture, the tenant may apply to the Superior Court of Justice for relief, and the court decides, on all the circumstances, whether the lease continues and on what terms. That is why "going dark" rarely turns into "locked out" overnight: notice, an opportunity to remedy, and possibly a court application usually sit in between.

3. How to negotiate this clause properly at signing

For tenants: first, pin down the scope — must you operate for the whole term, or simply open during stated hours? Are there carve-outs for renovations, holidays, or seasonal adjustments? Second, agree the consequence of closing in advance — a defined amount or a proven-loss measure — rather than leaving damages open-ended. Third, if your business model is genuinely uncertain, negotiate a shorter term or an exit mechanism instead of signing an operating promise you cannot keep.

For landlords: first, do not rely on the bare words "continuously operate" — specify hours and minimum operating standards so the clause can actually be proved and enforced. Second, where rent includes percentage rent, this clause matters twice as much, because a dark store destroys your share of sales; draft it together with the sales-reporting obligations. Third, decide in advance what you truly want — for most landlords it is rent and foot traffic, not that particular store — and draft to that goal instead of copying a template.

An invented example, with fictional people: a small retailer signs a five-year lease with an operating covenant, and two years in, the business is no longer viable and she wants to close early. Under the framework above, the right first step is not "can the landlord force me to stay open?" It is to have a lawyer price three things: what breach closing would be, how damages would be measured, and whether a negotiated exit is possible. Most of these files settle at a table, not in a courtroom.

Common misunderstandings

Myth 1: "The law requires a commercial tenant to operate until the lease ends." There is no such law. The operating duty comes from the lease itself; the Commercial Tenancies Act does not create it.

Myth 2: "The landlord cannot force me to open, so closing costs nothing." Wrong. Forcing you to trade is hard; billing you for the breach is not. Damages, termination, deposits and guarantees are all real consequences.

Myth 3: "Writing the words 'continuous operation' is enough." Far from it. Without hours, exceptions and consequences spelled out, the clause is hard for either side to rely on when it matters.

If you are negotiating a lease with an operating covenant, do these in order

  1. Find the clause and read it word by word: scope, hours and exceptions, item by item.
  2. Tenants, price the breach first; landlords, decide first whether your goal is compensation or recovering the unit — the negotiation differs completely.
  3. Negotiate exceptions for closures, renovations and holidays at signing, not after a problem starts.
  4. Where percentage rent applies, review the operating covenant together with the sales-reporting duties.
  5. Already closed, or already holding a landlord's notice? Have an Ontario commercial leasing lawyer review the lease and the sections 19-20 relief route before you reply.

Straight dealing and careful work — that is how I do business. I am Ming Ren. Bring the documents, and we will go through them line by line.


This article is general information, not legal advice. The effect of an operating covenant depends on the lease wording and the facts; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources checked: Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7 (which contains no continuous-operation obligation), including the relief-against-forfeiture framework in ss.19-20 (Ontario e-Laws, checked November 2026). The retailer example above is invented and illustrative only.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation