I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: a construction lien arising from a tenant's fit-out attaches first to the tenant's own leasehold interest — which is why many landlords file the whole subject under "the tenant's problem." That judgment fails in one very common situation. Where all or part of the cost of the improvement is accounted for under the lease, or an agreement connected to the lease, to be paid on the landlord's side — the standard tenant improvement allowance is the textbook case — section 19 of the current Construction Act makes the landlord's interest subject to the lien as well, to the extent of 10% of that payment. The rule changed on July 1, 2018. The old belief that "no contractor notice reached the landlord, so the landlord is safe" is out of date.
1. The three pillars of the current rule
| Pillar | Provision | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| Whose interest a lien attaches to | The Construction Act generally | A person who supplies services or materials to an improvement to land and is not paid may register a lien against the interest of the "owner." A tenant is the owner of its leasehold interest, so a fit-out lien lands on the leasehold first |
| When the landlord's interest is pulled in | s.19(1), current version in force July 1, 2018 | If payment for all or part of the improvement is accounted for under the terms of the lease or any renewal, or under any agreement to which the landlord is a party that is connected to the lease, the landlord's interest is also subject to the lien, to the extent of 10% of the amount of that payment |
| The holdback | s.22 | Every payer in the chain must hold back 10% of the price of services and materials supplied, until the time to register liens has expired — the fund lien claimants actually reach, and the payer's own protection |
The pre-2018 rule was entirely different: a contractor who wanted the landlord's interest had to give the landlord written notice before the work, and the landlord could escape by giving written notice within 15 days that it assumed no responsibility. The current rule abolished that advance-notice step and substituted an automatic 10% exposure driven by the lease's payment structure. A landlord still reasoning from the old rule is exposed without knowing it.
2. The deadlines are short, and they are hard deadlines
In lien law, the calendar matters more than the argument:
- Preservation: A lien claimant must register the claim for lien on title within the statutory period — currently 60 days from the relevant trigger, such as the last supply of services or materials. Miss it and the lien right is gone, not discounted — gone.
- Perfection: After preservation, the claimant must take the next steps — suing and registering a certificate of pending litigation — within a further 90 days, or the preserved lien expires.
- Information requests: Under the current s.39, a person with a lien may require the landlord to provide information about the lease — the parties, and the amount of any payment for the improvement accounted for under it — and the landlord must answer within 21 days. Do not treat such a request as junk mail. It is usually the overture to lien activity, and ignoring it carries its own legal consequences.
For a landlord, the practical meaning is this: the construction period and the two months after completion are the highest-risk window. Tenants fall behind with contractors, liens get registered, and landlords often first learn of it when the registration appears on title. Under the current s.19, "nobody told me" is not the defence — the lease's payment structure is what counts.
3. The landlord's defence is built in advance — in the lease and the allowance process
Remedies after the fact always cost more than clauses before it. The defences that actually work are these:
- Lease clauses. Require the tenant to keep the landlord's interest free of liens; require any registered lien to be discharged or vacated with security at the tenant's cost within a short period; give the landlord the right to pay to clear the lien and recover the amount from the tenant or set it off against deposits and letters of credit.
- How the allowance is paid. Pay a tenant allowance in stages, against progress and proof of payment, with statutory declarations and lien waivers from the general contractor along the way. Never fund it in full up front. The larger the amount you account for, the larger the 10% base under s.19 — and money fully advanced on work that was never paid for down the chain is the worst combination there is.
- Process control. Before work starts, require the tenant to declare the scope, the general contractor, and the contract price. Hold back the final slice of the allowance through the post-completion lien window. When a s.39 request or an unexpected registration appears, put a lawyer on it immediately rather than answering by guesswork.
An invented example, with invented numbers, only to show the mechanics: a lease gives the tenant an improvement allowance; the tenant's general contractor collapses mid-job owing its subcontractors. A subcontractor registers within its 60 days — against the leasehold interest, and, under s.19, against the landlord's interest to the extent of 10% of the allowance amount. A landlord who paid the allowance in documented stages and carried pay-and-recover clauses in the lease deals with this in a few lawyer's letters. A landlord with none of that negotiates from a standing start, at lien prices.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The construction contract is the tenant's, so a lien can never reach me." Where the landlord funds part of the work under the lease, the current s.19 expressly exposes the landlord's interest to the extent of 10% of that payment. The more generous the allowance, the more carefully this needs to be calculated in advance.
"Nobody notified me about the work, so I have no exposure." That is the pre-2018 rule. The current rule removed the contractor's advance-notice requirement and looks instead to the payment arrangements in the lease. Receiving no notice does not equal having no exposure.
"A registered lien will just go away if I ignore it." A preserved and perfected lien rides on title and surfaces in every sale, financing, and new tenant's diligence. It does not process itself away. Discharge or vacating steps still have to be taken — though note the other side's 60- and 90-day clocks: if the claimant misses them, the picture reverses, which is a date calculation for your lawyer, not an assumption.
If your tenant is about to start a fit-out, do these five things in order
- Before work begins, review the lease's construction, lien, and allowance provisions; if the defensive clauses are missing, add them through the landlord's consent-to-alterations document before anyone swings a hammer.
- Release the allowance in stages against invoices, proof of payment, and lien waivers, with the staging written into the documents.
- Require the tenant to declare the general contractor, major subcontractors, and contract amounts in writing, updated as the job changes.
- Stay alert through the 60-day post-completion window: watch title, and answer any s.39 information request within its 21 days, through your lawyer.
- If a lien is registered, check dates before strategy: tenant discharge, landlord payment with recovery, or vacating with security — and do not let the claimant perfect while you are still deciding.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. With tenant construction, a landlord's protection is not created on the day the lien lands — it is created on signing day and allowance day. Write the clauses first; then we can talk about how much to fund.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Which version of the Act applies (divided by contract and procurement dates), deadline calculations, and case-specific payment arrangements can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer practising construction law before acting.
Primary sources: Construction Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30, ss.19, 22, 31, 36, 39 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026; the current s.19 has been in force since July 1, 2018). The example is illustrative, not a real transaction.


