Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Your Commercial Tenant Walked Out Mid-Lease. Do You Have to Re-Let Right Away? Pick Your Route First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: in Ontario commercial leasing, "does the landlord have a duty to mitigate" is asked in the wrong order. After a tenant abandons, the landlord's first job is to elect a route — keep the lease alive, terminate it, or re-let on the tenant's account — and whether a mitigation duty follows depends on which route is chosen. Choose badly, or mix routes, and you can lose both the money and the right to claim it. The Commercial Tenancies Act says nothing about abandonment or mitigation; this area is built entirely by the courts, starting with the Supreme Court's 1971 decision in Highway Properties, a framework the Ontario Court of Appeal confirmed again in the 2024 Aphria case.

1. Four routes, and they are mutually exclusive

The options set out in Highway Properties shut each other out. Step onto one and the others close:

Route What the landlord does Duty to mitigate
1. Keep the lease alive Refuse the repudiation; the lease continues and rent is sued for as each instalment falls due None. There is no obligation to find a replacement tenant; the space can sit empty while rent is billed
2. Terminate and claim only what has accrued Accept the repudiation, terminate, retake the premises, and sue for arrears and breaches up to the termination date The lease is over as to the future, so future-rent mitigation does not arise
3. Terminate and claim the loss of the whole lease Terminate with notice to the tenant that damages will be claimed for losing the benefit of the lease: the present value of future rent for the unexpired term, less the premises' rental value and what re-letting brings in Yes. Claiming future loss means actually mitigating, and being able to prove the effort
4. Re-let on the tenant's account Tell the tenant the repudiation is not accepted, but re-enter and re-let the premises for the tenant's benefit, suing for any shortfall as it occurs Re-letting is the content of this route; shortfalls are recovered as they arise

The detail that decides real cases sits in route 3: the notice that future-loss damages will be claimed must be given when the lease is terminated. Sending it months later does not work. Landlords regularly lose here — they terminate, clear the tenant out, and only later decide they want three years of rent differential, by which time route 3's door has closed.

2. Your conduct will be read as an election

Courts look at what you did, not only what you said. Handle these carefully:

  • Do not casually accept the keys, change the locks, and let a new tenant start fitting out while also claiming the old lease is alive and rent is still accruing. Conduct that contradicts your stated route can be treated as accepting a surrender, and route 1 closes with it.
  • If you intend route 1, steps taken to inspect, secure utilities, and prevent further damage should be documented as exactly that — not as retaking the premises for yourself.
  • If you intend route 3, say so in the termination notice itself, and begin genuine re-letting efforts from that day: listing records, showing logs, and offer correspondence are the evidence your mitigation will be judged on.

In the 2024 Aphria litigation, the tenant argued that even a landlord who keeps the lease alive should have to mitigate. The Court of Appeal did not accept that and left the Highway Properties framework standing. So under current Ontario law, route 1 — leaving the space empty and suing for rent as it comes due — remains available. Its price is cash flow: you recover instalment by instalment, and whether the tenant (and any guarantor) can still pay at the end of the term is a separate calculation.

3. Tenants misread this too

From the tenant's side, walking out does not zero the account. Leaving stops the use of the premises; it does not end the contract. The unexpired term, rent shortfalls, and restoration costs can all be pursued afterwards. A tenant who genuinely needs out is almost always better off negotiating a written surrender agreement, or pursuing an assignment or sublet, than disappearing. Landlords should hear the mirror image of the same point: a clean, signed surrender is often worth more than winning a multi-year claim. On both sides, the negotiating table usually offers more than the courtroom.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The mitigation rules from residential leasing apply to commercial too." They do not. Residential tenancies run on the statutory framework of the Residential Tenancies Act. Commercial abandonment is common law, and it turns on the landlord's election. Importing residential instincts into a commercial unit gets the first step wrong.

"Once the tenant moves out, the lease ends automatically." It does not. A tenant's unilateral walkout is a repudiation. Whether the lease ends depends on the landlord's election; if the landlord does nothing and keeps the lease alive, rent keeps accruing instalment by instalment.

"Terminate first, clear the tenant out, and work out future losses later." The sequence is backwards. A claim for the unexpired term has to be notified at termination and pursued on that footing. Terminate first and notify later, and the foundation for route 3 is gone.

If your tenant abandoned today, do these five things in order

  1. Confirm and document the facts first: photograph the premises, record the state of the keys, the arrears, and anything the tenant said or wrote — but take no step that could be read as accepting a termination until you have advice.
  2. Pull the lease and note what drives the choice: length of the unexpired term, guarantors, deposits, and any letter of credit.
  3. Settle the election with your lawyer and notify the tenant in writing which route you are taking — for route 3, that notice must travel with the termination.
  4. Act consistently with the election: bill and pursue rent if the lease is alive; market the space in earnest, with records, if you are claiming future loss.
  5. Weigh the tenant's and guarantors' ability to pay before funding litigation. Winning a judgment you cannot collect is another kind of loss.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. When a tenant walks out, do not rush to change the locks — pick the right route first, and we will walk it step by step.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The lease terms, the parties' conduct, and the evidence can change how a court reads the landlord's election. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Highway Properties Ltd. v. Kelly, Douglas & Co., [1971] S.C.R. 562 (Supreme Court of Canada); Canada Life Assurance Co. v. Aphria Inc., 2023 ONSC 6912, aff'd 2024 ONCA 882 (Ontario Court of Appeal, leaving the Highway Properties framework in place); Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026 — the Act contains no provisions on abandonment or mitigation).

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation