I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: Ontario commercial leasing has two different "doubles," and confusing them is the standard opening mistake in holdover disputes. Section 58 of the Commercial Tenancies Act penalizes a tenant who wilfully holds over after a written demand for possession, at double the yearly value of the land. Section 59 penalizes a tenant who gave notice to quit and then stayed anyway, at double rent. On top of both, your lease almost certainly carries a third regime — its own holdover clause. A landlord's first job is to work out which rule they are standing on before sending a bill, a letter, or a court application.
1. The two statutory penalties, side by side
| Section 58: double value | Section 59: double rent | |
|---|---|---|
| Who it catches | A tenant (or someone who came in under the tenant) still in possession after the term has determined | A tenant who gave notice to quit |
| Trigger | The landlord or person entitled has given written notice demanding delivery of possession, and the tenant wilfully holds over | The tenant's own notice period expires and the tenant remains in possession |
| Measure | Double the yearly value of the land detained, for as long as it is detained, recoverable by court action — and the statute says there is no relief against it | Double the rent, for the period of overholding |
| Practical point | The written demand and the wilfulness are the evidence that matters: send the letter first, then do the arithmetic | The tenant's own notice is the key fact — very hard for the tenant to argue with |
Both are penal statutory claims. Neither lands in your account automatically: each has to be claimed, proved, and usually sued for. Billing a holdover tenant "double, because the Act says so" in the first letter, without checking which section's preconditions you actually have, is how landlords start these files wrong.
2. The lease's holdover clause is the regime you use day to day
A mature commercial lease normally has a holdover provision, typically structured like this: overholding is charged at a stated multiple of the last monthly rent (150% or 200% are common figures in lease drafting), the tenant's status drops to a tenancy at sufferance or a monthly overholding tenancy, and the landlord's acceptance of money does not create a renewal or consent to continued occupation. Pull that clause out before expiry. It decides three things: what the overholding period costs, whether the landlord can take the money and still require the tenant to leave, and how delay losses — for example, a replacement tenant who cannot move in — are handled, if the lease addresses them at all.
One act deserves care from both sides: accepting money. A landlord who keeps accepting rent after expiry, without reserving rights in writing, risks the payments being read as acquiescence in a continuing monthly tenancy — which weakens any later "unlawful occupier" position. A tenant, in turn, should not assume that paying a holdover premium buys a renewal. The practical fix is to state the position in writing before expiry: whether a short overhold is agreed, at what price, until what date, and that payment is not a renewal. Paper beats the argument afterwards.
3. Getting the premises back runs through the court
Commercial leasing has no landlord-tenant tribunal of the residential kind. Where an overholding tenant will not leave and negotiation fails, the landlord's regular route is an application to a judge under Part III of the Commercial Tenancies Act — sections 74 and 75 set out the application procedure against an overholding tenant — leading to an order for possession, enforced by the sheriff. Self-help shortcuts — changing locks, cutting utilities, clearing out contents — carry real exposure even in a commercial setting: claims for unlawful eviction, goods, and business interruption. Do not discount that risk just because the premises are commercial. The mirror advice for tenants: if you genuinely need another month or two to move equipment, negotiate a short written overholding agreement early — price, hard end date, consequences — it costs a fraction of either side's litigation.
An invented example, only to show the shape of section 59: a print shop's lease ends March 31; in February it notifies the landlord in writing that it will vacate in April; the new shop's fit-out runs late and the tenant stays through April. That is the classic s.59 picture — the tenant's own notice to quit, followed by overholding, with double rent as the statutory claim. A landlord who replied in February confirming "possession must be delivered on expiry; overholding will be dealt with under the Act and the lease" has very little left to argue about in April.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"Hold over past expiry and double rent applies automatically." Each double has its own preconditions. Section 58 needs a written demand plus wilful holding over, and it measures double yearly value, not double the old rent. Section 59 needs the tenant's own notice to quit first. Without the preconditions, what remains is an ordinary overholding claim and the lease clause.
"If the tenant pays the premium rate, that is effectively a renewal — simpler for everyone." Holdover payments buy compensation for the occupation period, not a new term. Status, duration, and whether the tenant can still be required to leave all turn on the holdover clause and whatever the parties put in writing. A verbal "simpler for everyone" is usually the most expensive arrangement on the table.
"It is a commercial unit, so changing the locks is my right." It is not. Possession has a court process, and self-help can move a landlord who was in the right onto the defendant's side of the courtroom, with goods and business-interruption claims larger than the overholding rent.
If your tenant's term ends next month, do these five things in order
- Sixty days out, read the lease's holdover, termination, and surrender provisions and pin down the overholding price and the tenant's status during it.
- Confirm the end-of-term plan with the tenant in writing: out on time, or a negotiated short overhold. If you will require possession, deliver the written demand early — it is the evidentiary foundation of s.58.
- If the tenant gives notice to quit, reply in writing confirming receipt and the obligation to deliver possession on expiry. That nails down the s.59 facts.
- After expiry, label every payment you accept — what it is for, and that rights are reserved — so acceptance cannot be read as a renewal.
- If negotiation fails, use the court application route, and have your lawyer work out whether the statutory doubles or the lease's holdover rate serves you better and how they interact. Do not clear the unit yourself.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. In a holdover, establish which rule you are standing on before you talk money or deadlines. Get the order right and the file gets simpler by half.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Whether the double penalties apply turns on notices, the facts of occupation, and the lease wording. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7, ss.58, 59, 74-75 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The print shop example is illustrative, not a real case.


