I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The conclusion first: a new tenant or a new use does not automatically mean you must add parking. In Ontario you check three layers, in order. First, is the land in an area where provincial law now forbids parking minimums altogether? Second, what does the current zoning by-law of that municipality actually say for the new use — a minimum, a maximum, or nothing? Third, what protection does the building's existing lawful use still carry? Get the order wrong and you will get the answer wrong.
Layer one: where the land sits
Paragraph 6 of section 34(1) of the Planning Act lets a municipality require owners or occupants to provide and maintain parking and loading facilities. Two words matter. Requirements attach to a use, so a tenant in a different use category can face a different number. And the duty is to maintain the parking, not merely to build it once.
The province later added a ceiling. Under section 34(1.1), a zoning by-law may not require automobile parking (bicycle parking excepted) on land inside areas such as a protected major transit station area identified in the official plan. If your unit sits in one of those station areas, the municipality can no longer use zoning to force you to add car spaces. Before you buy or sign a lease, confirming the lot's position on the official plan map matters more than counting the spaces that happen to be painted today.
Layer two: what the local by-law says for the new use
Outside those areas, open the zoning by-law of the municipality the property is actually in. Every city's table is different, and several have changed recently. In Toronto, Zoning By-law 569-2013, as amended by By-law 89-2022, now sets only a maximum — no minimum — for a number of uses including retail, restaurant and medical office. In Toronto, a retail unit becoming a clinic may have no parking shortfall at all.
In another municipality the same move can come out the opposite way: if the by-law still sets a minimum for restaurants or clinics and the new use calculates higher than the spaces on site, a shortfall appears. Never carry Toronto's table into another city's building. Check three things: how the new use is classified, the parking formula for that class, and any transition provisions for existing buildings.
An invented example, only to show the method: suppose a by-law requires 4 spaces per 100 square metres for a clinic. A 300-square-metre unit needs 12; the site has 9; the apparent gap is 3. Whether that gap is real depends on what layers one and three leave standing.
Layer three: if there is a gap, what closes it
Do not conclude the deal is dead. The usual routes are:
| Route | Authority | When it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Cash-in-lieu of parking agreement | Planning Act, s.40 | The municipality will accept payment instead of built spaces |
| Minor variance | Planning Act, s.45 | The gap is small and the four variance tests can be met |
| Verify existing lawful use | By-law transition rules and legal existing-use principles | The building and prior use were lawful and only the new standard is higher |
One more check people skip: are the existing spaces themselves compliant — dimensions, aisle widths, accessible spaces? Sometimes the count is fine but the layout is not; sometimes re-striping closes the gap. Have a planning consultant or lawyer verify against the by-law text. An agent's eyeball estimate is not verification.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The unit next door did this last year, so I can copy it." No. Transit-area location, municipality, and prior use category — change any one and the answer can flip. There is no such thing as one parking answer for a whole plaza.
"These spaces have been here for years, so they must be protected." Existing-use protection is conditional, and it generally protects the use that was lawfully established, not any future use. Whether it carries over on a change of use depends on the by-law's transition wording.
"If parking is short, the city will shut us down." In practice the issue usually surfaces at permits, lease conditions, or a Committee of Adjustment application, where remedies are discussed. The real danger is nobody checking before signing and finding out after the fit-out, at the occupancy stage.
The order I recommend
- Locate the land on the official plan and zoning maps; confirm whether it falls in a protected major transit station area or similar no-minimum area.
- Get written confirmation from municipal planning staff: the new use's classification, the applicable formula, and the current by-law version.
- Measure the existing spaces — count, dimensions, accessible spaces — and compare against the formula to get the true gap.
- If a gap remains, ask which of the three routes is available — cash-in-lieu, minor variance, or existing-use verification — and keep the answer in writing.
- Put the parking conclusion into the conditions of the purchase or lease. Do not close on a verbal assurance.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you buy or lease a commercial unit, send me the address and the intended use, and we will check the documents item by item before we talk price.
This article is general information only, not legal or planning advice. The zoning, by-law version, and facts of your unit can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario planning consultant or lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, ss.34(1), 34(1.1), 40, 45 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); City of Toronto Zoning By-law 569-2013 and By-law 89-2022. The clinic size and space counts are illustrative only.


