Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

I paid my renovation contractor in full — why is there still a lien on my title?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: paying your contractor in full does not mean everyone down the construction chain got paid. Under Ontario's Construction Act, an unpaid subcontractor, worker or supplier can register their claim against the title to your home. Your protection is one system, and it has to start before the work does: hold back 10% of every payment, pay by progress, and search title before the last of that money moves.

This article is only about the homeowner who is renovating. Checking title before a purchase closing is a different topic, and it is not this one.

First: the lien attaches to the house, not to your contract with the trade

Under section 14, a person who supplies services or materials to an improvement of a property has a lien on the owner's interest in that property. A renovation is a classic improvement: a kitchen, a bathroom, a finished basement, an addition all count.

Money normally flows like this: you pay the general contractor, the contractor pays the trades — electrical, plumbing, tile — and the trades pay their own workers and suppliers. If the flow stops at any link, the person left unpaid does not need a contract with you to register their claim on your title. And once an unresolved lien sits on title, selling the home or refinancing it will usually stall until the lien is dealt with.

So the real risk question is not "did I pay my contractor?" It is "did the money reach the bottom of the chain?" You cannot control how your contractor pays downstream. What the law gives you instead is a cap on your exposure — the holdback in the next section.

Second: keep back 10% of every payment — it is a legal duty, not a bargaining chip

Section 22(1) is direct: on any contract or subcontract under which a lien may arise, every payer must retain a holdback equal to 10 per cent of the price of the services or materials as they are actually supplied, until all liens that may be claimed against that holdback have expired, been satisfied, or been otherwise provided for. Section 22(3) adds that this duty applies whether the contract calls for progress payments or one payment on completion. If your contract says nothing about a holdback, the duty is still there. If it says the holdback is waived, the statute still wins.

That 10% does two practical things for you:

What it does Where it comes from In plain terms
Leaves a fund for the people downstream Section 22 If the contractor does not pay a trade, that trade's lien reaches this fund first
Caps your personal liability Section 23 If you kept the holdback properly, your personal liability to lien claimants generally does not exceed the holdback you were required to retain
Lets you pay up to 90% safely Section 24 Until you receive written notice of a lien, paying up to 90% of the work supplied is the safe zone; leave the last 10% alone

An illustrative example, with numbers I made up just to show the math: a $120,000 kitchen-and-basement renovation, paid in four draws of $30,000 for work actually completed. On each draw you pay out $27,000 and keep back $3,000, so by the end you are holding $12,000. That $12,000 is not money you saved. It is money you are temporarily holding for the whole chain, and it goes to the contractor only after the lien risk window has closed.

One 2026 change is worth knowing. Amendments passed in 2024 and 2025 came into force on January 1, 2026, and section 26 now requires mandatory annual release of holdback: at each contract anniversary, the owner publishes a notice of annual release within 14 days after the anniversary, and pays the accrued holdback 60 to 74 days after the notice is published — unless a preserved or perfected lien stands in the way. A typical home renovation finishes in a few months and never reaches an anniversary. But if you are doing a rebuild or addition that runs past a year, build that annual rhythm into your payment plan early, and have a lawyer check how the transition rules apply to your contract.

Third: liens run on clocks, and your release timing should follow them

A lien is not permanent once registered. It runs on three clocks, and a homeowner should know at least the first two, because they decide when the holdback can safely be released:

Stage Deadline What it means
Preserve Within 60 days of the trigger date The claimant must register the claim for lien on title inside this window; miss it, and that lien expires
Perfect Within 90 days after the last day the lien could have been preserved A registered lien must also be backed by a court action and a registered certificate of action; the two stages total roughly 150 days
Shelf life 2 years after the action is started A perfected lien expires if the action is not set down for trial, or an order for trial is not made, within two years of the day the action began (section 37)

Be careful with the start date for the 60 days. Under section 31, a contractor generally counts from the earliest of publication of a certificate of substantial performance, completion of the contract, or its abandonment or termination. Subcontractors and suppliers also look at their own last day of supply, again taking the earliest date. A home renovation usually has no published certificate, so the count often runs from the day the contract was completed — but do not fix that date by guesswork. Before you release the holdback, have a lawyer confirm the trigger date against your contract and how the job actually ended.

The practical rule is one sentence: after the work is done, do not rush the last 10% out the door. Let the 60-day preservation window run, then do a title search to confirm nothing was registered, and only then release it. If a lien does appear, stop paying and call a lawyer — do not negotiate the amount yourself, and do not release the holdback to the contractor in the meantime.

Three common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding one: "I have no contract with that subcontractor, so they can't come after me." The lien attaches to the property and to the holdback, not to any contract between you and the claimant. A trade or supplier you never signed anything with can still register a lien on your title.

Misunderstanding two: "The 10% holdback is just industry custom, and we get along well, so we can skip it." It is not custom; it is the statutory duty in section 22. If you pay everything out without keeping it and someone downstream is left unpaid, you can end up paying twice for the same work — and you lose the liability cap that proper holdback would have given you.

Misunderstanding three: "The job is finished today, so I can settle the whole balance today." Finished is not the same as safe. The preservation window runs for 60 days after the trigger date, and a lien can be registered at any point inside it. The holdback portion of your final payment should move only after that window has closed and title has been checked.

If you are about to renovate, I suggest this order

  1. Sign a written contract before work starts, with the total price, the payment schedule and the 10% statutory holdback spelled out. Do not start on a handshake.
  2. Pay in draws against work that is actually done and inspected, pay only 90% of each draw, and track the holdback separately from your household money.
  3. Before each draw, ask the contractor for a written declaration confirming the trades and suppliers from the previous stage have been paid, and file it with your payment records.
  4. Put every change order in writing with its price before the changed work is done, and calculate the holdback on the changed amounts as the work is supplied.
  5. Write down the exact completion date. It is the reference point for the 60-day window; get it wrong and everything after it is wrong.
  6. After the preservation window expires and before releasing the final holdback, run a title search. If a lien shows up, stop paying and call an Ontario construction lawyer right away.
  7. If your project will run past a year, ask your lawyer early how the annual release rules that took effect January 1, 2026 apply to your contract — do not wait until after an anniversary has passed.

Do things honestly, and do the work solidly. I'm Ming Ren. With renovation payments, the pattern that protects your title is simple: release money one step slowly, keep evidence one step ahead. If a sale or refinance is coming after the renovation, get title checked clean first, and we'll go through the documents one line at a time.


This article is general information, not legal advice. Trigger dates, holdback release timing and the transition rules are all fact-specific; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Construction Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30, ss.14, 22, 23, 24, 26, 31, 36, 37 (Ontario e-Laws, checked November 2026, including the amendments in force January 1, 2026). The $120,000 figure and the draw amounts are an illustrative example, not a real project.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation