I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: most sellers who refuse to lower their price are not ignoring the market — they are stuck on a set of numbers that feel impossible to let go of. What they paid. What they spent on renovations. What a neighbour's home sold for. What they still owe the bank. Every one of those numbers is real. Not one of them is the number a buyer looks at. A buyer looks at exactly one thing: what similar homes have actually sold for recently. A good pricing decision keeps those two sets of numbers in separate columns, and never lets the first column overrule the second.
This article is not about the carrying-cost arithmetic of overpricing — that is a separate topic. This one is about what is really going on in a seller's head when the price will not move, and how to make the decision with numbers instead.
The first thing sellers cannot let go of: what they spent
The most common opening line I hear is: "I paid this much for it, then I put that much more into the kitchen, the roof and the basement — how can I sell it for less than that total?"
That makes complete emotional sense, and no market sense at all. Money already spent is a sunk cost: it is gone whether the home sells high or low. A buyer walking through your door does not ask what your renovation cost before deciding what to offer. They compare your home with the one that sold last week — where yours is better, where it is worse. Renovations can absolutely be worth money, but only in the form of "how much better is this home than the comparable sales," never as a stack of invoices added back onto the price.
There is a second layer underneath: pride. For many sellers, lowering the price feels like publicly admitting "I priced it wrong." In truth, pricing slightly high is one of the most ordinary things in real estate — the market moves every month and nobody nails it every time. Treat a reduction as an admission of failure and you will stall. Treat it as issuing a new quote and reopening the conversation with the market, and it becomes much easier.
The second thing sellers cannot let go of: waiting for "the right buyer"
The next idea is: "It's not that nobody wants it — the right person just hasn't come along yet. Let's wait."
Waiting is not automatically wrong. Waiting with no deadline and no test is. The market has been giving you feedback the whole time; it just does not arrive as a letter. It arrives as a showing count, as the comments buyers leave after a visit, as whether anyone asks a second question, as whether even one low offer shows up. If weeks pass with a handful of showings and the feedback keeps coming back as "too expensive," buyers have not failed to arrive — they have already voted with their feet, and they are out looking at other homes, not waiting for yours.
One more thing worth knowing: time on market and every price change are publicly displayed on the home's REALTOR.ca listing page. The longer you wait, the louder the question in a buyer's mind — "why hasn't this one sold?" Waiting is not a neutral act.
And what about the suspicion that "my agent wants me to cut the price just to get a quick sale and a commission"? I understand that suspicion, and it deserves to be raised openly. The test is simple: don't accept conclusions, demand evidence. Have the agent lay out the comparable sales one by one and explain the differences. If the evidence holds up, the reduction is for you. If no evidence is produced, you are fully entitled not to cut. Doubting your agent, though, is not the same as defending your old price to the end.
Give the decision back to the numbers: three columns
When I help a seller decide, I ask them to write three columns on one sheet of paper.
Column one is your history: purchase price, renovation spending, and what you still owe. This column decides what you walk away with and whether the mortgage gets cleared. It is a real financial constraint — but it does not set the price.
Column two is the market's evidence: recent, genuinely comparable sales in the same community and property type, adjusted one by one into a defensible range. This is the only column buyers and lender appraisers will recognise.
Column three is the market's feedback: how many showings since launch, what buyers said, and whether any offer has appeared. This column tells you how far column one's hopes sit from column two's evidence.
Here is an illustrative example — the numbers are invented, only the method matters. A seller bought at $880,000, spent roughly $90,000 on renovations, and holds a personal floor of "it has to be $1,050,000." Adjusted comparable sales support a range of $960,000 to $990,000. Listed at $1,050,000 for a month, the home gets four showings, no offers, and feedback that keeps saying "overpriced." With the three columns side by side, the conclusion is hard to dodge: $1,050,000 came out of column one, not column two, and column three confirms it. The question stops being "but I don't want to accept less" and becomes a clean choice: keep holding a price no evidence supports, or re-quote at the evidence and take back control of the negotiation.
A quick word on process, because it matters whose decision this is. In Ontario, the asking price is the seller's decision — your agent cannot change it for you. A formal price change is made by signing an amendment to the listing agreement (OREA Form 240) that records the current price and the new price, signed by the seller, after which the brokerage notifies the real estate board to update the MLS listing. The decision is yours from start to finish — which is exactly why it deserves to be made with numbers, not with mood.
Common misunderstandings
"Lowering the price means locking in a loss — my money is gone." No. Your home was worth what the market says it is worth before you ever touched the asking price; a reduction simply aligns the asking price with that value. What actually costs sellers money is usually not the reduction itself, but burning the hottest weeks of the listing period defending a price buyers have already rejected.
"Someone will eventually pay extra for a good home." Occasionally, yes — but that is not a pricing strategy. And even when such a buyer appears, a buyer who needs a mortgage still has to pass the lender's appraisal, which is based on surrounding sales. If the appraisal comes in low, the deal can still stall. Pricing for a low-probability buyer has a certain cost: most ordinary buyers simply never book a showing.
"Give it another month — the market might come back." It might, or it might keep sliding. The point is that the call needs evidence: are comparable homes selling for more or less than they were, and how much new competition is listing? If you cannot point to any of that, "let's wait" is not a strategy. It is just postponing the decision.
Before you decide, do these things
- Write the three numbers down separately — your history and what you owe, the range the comparable sales support, and the real feedback since launch. Do not blend them into one figure.
- Make your agent present the comparable sales one at a time: which home, when it sold, for how much, how it differs from yours, and what adjustment was made. If they cannot lay it out, do not act on the advice.
- If you choose to wait, give the wait an expiry date and a trigger: for example, two more weeks — and if showings stay below an agreed number with still no offer, you adjust to the price agreed in advance, with no fresh argument.
- If you decide to reduce, reduce once, to a position the evidence supports. Do not drip-feed small cuts — every change is publicly visible, and small, repeated cuts teach buyers to wait for the next one.
- If you decide not to reduce, write the reason down: which sales you are relying on and what signal you are waiting for. If you cannot write it, the decision is being made by feelings, not judgement.
- Once decided, follow the process: confirm the new price with your brokerage, sign the amendment, and make sure the MLS listing and every portal update together so no two prices are floating around.
At the end of the day, this is a home you lived in and put real care into. Being attached to it is human, and I never tell a seller to switch their feelings off. I only ask for one separation: feelings in one place, pricing in another. What you paid and what you hoped for can stay in the first column, where they belong. The asking price belongs to the evidence.
Honest in conduct, diligent in work. A price set on evidence is a negotiation you can stand behind. — Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron
This article is general information about pricing a home for sale and is not legal or financial advice. For a specific transaction, consult a licensed brokerage, a lawyer and an accountant.
Primary sources: this article was checked against the text of OREA Form 240 (Amendment to Listing Agreement — the price-change/amendment form) and the time-on-market (Time on REALTOR.ca) and price-change information publicly displayed on CREA's REALTOR.ca listing pages. All prices and showing figures in the worked example are illustrative numbers set by the author, not market statistics.
Frequently asked questions
Does lowering the price mean locking in a loss?
No. Your home was worth what the market says it is worth before you ever touched the asking price, and a reduction simply aligns the asking price with that value. What actually costs sellers money is usually burning the hottest weeks of the listing defending a price buyers have already rejected.
Will someone eventually pay extra for a good home?
Occasionally, yes, but that is not a pricing strategy. Even when such a buyer appears, a buyer who needs a mortgage still has to pass the lender's appraisal based on surrounding sales, and if the appraisal comes in low the deal can stall, while most ordinary buyers simply never book a showing.
Should I give it another month in case the market comes back?
It might, or it might keep sliding. The call needs evidence: whether comparable homes are selling for more or less, and how much new competition is listing. If you cannot point to any of that, waiting is not a strategy, just postponing the decision.


