Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

An Offer Before a Price Cut vs. an Offer After One: How a Seller Should Actually Compare Them

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: whether an offer arrived before or after a price cut tells you nothing, by itself, about which one is better. Only three things matter — how much money each one actually puts on the table once both are measured the same way, how few and how solid its conditions are, and how likely it is to reach closing. Labelling an offer by its timing is the easiest arithmetic mistake a seller can make.

This article covers three things: why the two offers cannot be compared by percentage, what to compare instead, and how to respond to each kind.

1. Put both offers on the same measuring stick first

A price cut changes more than a number. Once the asking price moves, the reference point for every negotiation moves with it: the earlier offer was made against the old price, the later one against the new price. Comparing them by "percentage of asking" uses two different rulers on the same question. The result looks precise and means very little.

There is also a procedural fact worth knowing first: a list price is not changed by a broker typing a new number into a system. Changing the price means amending the listing agreement, with a signed amendment confirming the new price and terms, and only then does the change take effect publicly. So a decision to cut — and by how much — is a formal, signed decision, not a casual "let's try lower and raise it back if it doesn't work." The market can see the history either way.

The correct comparison is simple: convert both offers to actual dollars, then factor in the conditions. Here is a set of figures I made up, for illustration only — not a real transaction:

Item Offer before the cut Offer after the cut
Asking price at the time $1,200,000 $1,120,000
Offer amount $1,110,000 $1,060,000
Share of asking at the time About 92.5% About 94.6%
Conditions Financing, 5 business days Financing, home inspection, and status review
Closing 60 days 90 days

By percentage, the post-cut offer looks closer to asking. In dollars, it is $50,000 less, with more conditions and a later closing. What reaches your pocket is dollars, not percentages. Do this conversion first, and much of the "did the cut cost me money?" anxiety settles itself.

One more warning: if the pre-cut offer has passed its irrevocability deadline, it has expired. You cannot keep it in your pocket as a backup. The only offers you can compare are ones still alive, or ones the buyer is willing to sign again.

2. Beyond the dollars: compare conditions and certainty

When the money is close, these are the items that decide which offer is actually better:

  • Deposit and payment picture: How much deposit, when it is delivered, and how far the buyer's financing pre-approval has actually gone tell you how real the offer is.
  • Number and length of conditions: Financing, inspection, condominium status review — every added condition is another exit door for the buyer, and every extra day is another day your home is tied up.
  • Closing date: The closing has to fit your own arrangements — the closing on your next home, how your existing mortgage is handled. Fast is not automatically good; fast that clashes with your own dates creates problems.
  • Whether the buyer has seen the home: A buyer who has walked through, come back, and asked detailed questions will usually travel to closing differently from a buyer who offered sight unseen. It is not a hard rule, but it is worth asking about during negotiation.
  • Irrevocability: How long the buyer gives you to consider. A very short deadline is often pressure to decide in a rush; a reasonable one leaves room to negotiate properly.

There is also a baseline rule of procedure: whether an offer arrives before or after a cut, if it is a written offer, your registrant must convey it to you, and the decision to accept, reject, or sign back is yours — it is not the registrant's job to screen offers out first. That duty sits in the framework of O. Reg. 567/05 under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002; unless you have given clear written instructions for a different arrangement in advance, every offer should reach your hands. If you ever suspect an offer never reached you, start by asking about that rule.

3. The two offers call for different responses

For a pre-cut offer: sign back first, instead of rushing to cut the price to attract a new one. If the amount is in a reasonable range and the conditions are workable, use a sign-back for the gap: counter at a price you can accept, write the condition periods and closing date out clearly, and give the buyer a definite deadline to reply. While the negotiation table is still warm, a sign-back costs far less than starting over. A flat rejection with no counter sends away a buyer who is already at your door, in exchange for a bet that someone better will appear after a cut — and that bet has no guarantee behind it.

For a post-cut offer: do not feel you must accept quickly just because you have already cut once. The first wave after a cut is a mixed group: some buyers genuinely like the home and were waiting for the price to reach their range, and some watch for price-cut signals and open by pushing lower still. The test does not change: convert to dollars, read the conditions, check the deposit. If a buyer uses your cut as a reason to push far below it, you can sign back to the number you had in mind when you set the new price. A price cut is your pricing decision; it is not a promise of a further automatic discount to everyone who asks.

When is cutting first and waiting actually right? If comparable sales clearly show the original price sat well above the market, and showings have stayed thin for a long time, then a cut is correcting the price, not conceding. In that case, rather than burning time defending an asking price nobody will meet, sign the amendment, move the price to where the sales support it, and then take the post-cut offers seriously. The order matters: get the sales support first, then cut. Do not cut the price in order to wait for an offer that has not appeared yet.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The post-cut offer is a higher percentage of the new price, so it is better." The two percentages were calculated against two different asking prices; they are not comparable. Convert both to dollars and the answer often reverses.

"The pre-cut offer was too low. If I reject it, I can always go back to it." An offer past its irrevocability deadline has expired. That buyer may have bought something else, and bringing them back means asking for a fresh offer — at a price and on conditions that may have changed.

"Let's cut a little and test the water." A price change requires a signed amendment; it is a formal pricing act. Frequent small cuts are visible to everyone watching the listing, and watchers simply wait for your next step. If you cut, cut once, to a position the comparable sales can defend.

If an offer is sitting in front of you right now, do these things in order

  1. Before asking whether it came before or after a cut, write down its five basics: amount, deposit, conditions, closing date, and irrevocability deadline.
  2. Compare it against recent comparable sales, one by one, and measure its distance from a supported market price — not from your asking price.
  3. If you hold two offers at once, convert both to dollars and net conditions and lay them side by side in a table before deciding; do not choose from memory or impression.
  4. If the gap is negotiable, sign back with a counter and a clear reply deadline; do not end the negotiation with a bare rejection.
  5. When considering a cut, have your broker show you the sales that support the new price first, then sign the amendment. Do not set a new price by feel.
  6. If any written offer did not reach you, ask your registrant why. Conveying offers is the default; an exception needs your written instructions.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are holding an offer and are unsure whether to take it, put the offer and the recent sales side by side and we will go through the dollars and the conditions, item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. How a listing agreement may be amended, the exact requirements for conveying offers, and the terms of your own case can affect the conclusion. Check the documents with your registrant before acting, and consult an Ontario lawyer where needed.

Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and O. Reg. 567/05 (Ontario e-Laws), framework for a registrant's duty to convey offers; RECO guidance on conveying offers and amending a listing agreement (consulted November 2026). The $1,200,000, $1,120,000 and related figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

The post-cut offer is a higher percentage of the new price, so is it better?

The two percentages were calculated against two different asking prices; they are not comparable. Convert both to dollars and the answer often reverses.

The pre-cut offer was too low — if I reject it, can I always go back to it?

An offer past its irrevocability deadline has expired. That buyer may have bought something else, and bringing them back means asking for a fresh offer — at a price and on conditions that may have changed.

Can we cut a little and test the water?

A price change requires a signed amendment; it is a formal pricing act. Frequent small cuts are visible to everyone watching the listing, and watchers simply wait for your next step. Move once, to a position the sold data supports.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation