I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain version first: once the seller changes your terms, signs, and sends the document back — a sign back — your original offer is no longer on the table. The only live document is the seller's new offer. You cannot go back and say "I accept my original price instead," because under general contract principles a counter-offer is a rejection of the offer it answers, combined with a new offer of its own. The original cannot be accepted by either side after that.
If a signed-back document has just reached you, work through three things, in this order: which document is live, whose irrevocable deadline is running, and how your answer has to be delivered to count.
1. After a sign back, the seller's version is the live one
Ontario's standard contract is OREA Form 100, the Agreement of Purchase and Sale. The usual flow is that the buyer signs an offer, and the seller may accept it as written, let it go, or change terms and sign it back. In practice the changes are usually made on the same Form 100 — price, completion date or conditions crossed out and rewritten, each change initialled — or set out in an added schedule. That is industry practice, not the only form the law allows.
What matters is that the legal roles have flipped. The moment the seller signs back, the seller becomes the party making the offer and you become the party who may accept it. OREA's Form 801, the Offer Summary Document, records the negotiation the same way: the listing brokerage keeps a separate record for each submission, and the outcome is recorded as one of three — accepted, signed back/countered, or expired/declined. In the seller's own file, your original round is already closed as "signed back."
So if you want your original price back, the correct move is not to "accept the original offer." It is to change the price on the seller's signed-back document back to your number, sign, and send it over. Understand what that is: a fresh counter-offer, and the decision is now the seller's.
2. This round, the clock binds the seller
Clause 1 of Form 100 is the irrevocability clause. Its logic is simple: the party who submits an offer may not withdraw it before the date and time written in the clause, and after that time, if it has not been accepted, the offer is null and void and any deposit is returned to the buyer in full without interest.
When you submitted your offer, that deadline bound you. After a sign back, it binds the seller: the seller writes a new irrevocable time on the signed-back document, the seller cannot withdraw the counter-offer before that time, and your decision has to be completed before it.
An illustrative example, with invented times only to show how the counting works: suppose the sign back is irrevocable until 9:00 p.m. that evening. You sign at 8:50 p.m., but the document is not delivered until 9:05 p.m. Under clause 20, time is of the essence in the agreement, and a late acceptance cannot revive an offer that has already become void. Times in the agreement are read by the local time where the property is located, so if you are in another province or abroad, convert before you plan around the deadline.
The same discipline applies in reverse. When you counter again, the clock binds you: inside the new irrevocable time you write, you cannot withdraw either. Set that time as deliberately as you set the price — do not casually give away a whole evening.
3. A signature is not enough. Delivery is what counts
Clause 13 of Form 100 provides that upon acceptance of the offer there is a binding agreement of purchase and sale between buyer and seller. But acceptance is not complete when the ink dries. It also has to be delivered.
Clause 3, the notices clause, sets three rules:
- Notices must be in writing. The clause groups the offer, any counter-offer and any notice of acceptance together as a "Document." A phone call saying "we accept" is not delivery under this clause.
- A Document counts when it reaches the specified place. It is deemed given and received when delivered personally or hand delivered to the Address for Service in the Acknowledgement, or, where a fax number or email address is provided in the agreement, when transmitted to that number or address.
- A brokerage can act as notice agent, with an exception. Ordinarily the seller appoints the listing brokerage, and a buyer who has signed a representation agreement appoints the buyer's brokerage, to give and receive notices. But where one brokerage represents both seller and buyer (multiple representation), or one side is a self-represented party, the brokerage cannot be appointed as either side's notice agent, and documents must go directly to the address or email written into the agreement.
Registrants have their own duty here. Under section 22.10 of O. Reg. 567/05, made under Ontario's Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, a registrant who receives a written offer must convey it to their client as soon as possible, and that duty extends to written amendments and other written documents directly related to the offer — which is the category a signed-back document falls into.
If you accept the sign back with all its changes, the last party to sign completes the Confirmation of Acceptance on Form 100, recording the date and time the agreement "with all changes both typed and written" was finally accepted by all parties. Once acceptance happens, other clocks start: if the deposit line reads "Upon Acceptance," the form defines that as delivery of the deposit to the Deposit Holder within 24 hours of acceptance.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The seller's price does not work for me, so I will just accept my original offer." You cannot. Under general contract principles, the counter-offer rejected the original, so there is no original offer left to accept. To get back to your price, change the number on the signed-back document and send it back — that is a new counter-offer, and the seller may decline it.
"I signed, so we have a deal. When it gets sent over does not matter." It matters. Clause 3 turns on delivery: the signed document must reach the specified address or email before the irrevocable time runs out. A signature sitting in your inbox past the deadline accepts an offer that no longer exists.
"If I do not respond, am I in breach? Do I owe anything?" No. Saying nothing and letting the signed-back document pass its irrevocable time makes it null and void under clause 1, and any deposit already paid is returned in full without interest. Walking away is a complete answer, not a breach. If you still want the house afterwards, you may submit a brand-new offer — the seller is simply under no obligation to take it.
When a sign back reaches you, do these five things in order
- Find every change first: price, completion date, deposit, conditions, included items. Check that each change carries the seller's initials, and look for any added schedule you may not have noticed.
- Read clause 1 on this round's document: does the irrevocable time bind the Seller or the Buyer, and until what date and time? Convert to the property's local time and leave room for delivery — do not plan to land at the final minute.
- You have exactly three decisions. If every change works, sign and accept. If any change does not, change it back and sign — treated as a new counter-offer. If the terms do not work at all, do not sign and let it expire; you do not owe anyone a counter just to be polite.
- If a change adds, removes or rewords a condition, have your real estate lawyer look at it before you sign. An agent can work through price and process with you; the legal effect of wording is a lawyer's call.
- Deliver the signed document the way clause 3 requires, and keep proof of when and how it was sent. If the deal is accepted, note the Confirmation of Acceptance time — the deposit and the other deadlines all run from there.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If a signed-back document has landed in front of you and you are not sure what is still open, bring the complete paperwork and we will go through every change and every deadline, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Whether a counter-offer rejects the original offer is a matter of general contract principles; Ontario has no statute that states it word for word, and how it applies to a specific transaction is a question for an Ontario lawyer before you act.
Primary sources: OREA Form 100 (Agreement of Purchase and Sale), clauses 1, 3, 13 and 20, the deposit provision and the Confirmation of Acceptance; O. Reg. 567/05 under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, s.22.10 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The times in the example are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
The seller's price does not work for me, so can I just accept my original offer?
You cannot. Under general contract principles, the counter-offer rejected the original, so there is no original offer left to accept. Going back to the original number means signing it back again — a new round the seller may refuse.
I signed, so we have a deal — when it gets sent over does not matter?
It matters. Clause 3 turns on delivery: the signed document must reach the specified address or email before the irrevocable time runs out. Signed but sitting in your hands past the deadline, it is void.
If I do not respond, am I in breach? Do I owe anything?
No. Saying nothing and letting the signed-back document pass its irrevocable time makes it null and void under clause 1, and any deposit already paid is returned in full without interest. Walking away is a complete response, not a breach.


