I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: that extra $100K is, by itself, neither good news nor bad news. It is a claim waiting to be tested. The more believable number is not the one delivered with more confidence — it is the one backed by the same set of sold properties, line-by-line adjustments, and a written pricing rationale you can check item by item. A high number that cannot be written down has an old name in this business: "buying the listing" — trading an attractive promise for a signature on an exclusive listing agreement, then talking about price reductions after the ink dries. That is what a seller actually needs to guard against.
This article sets out a practical test: two agents, two numbers, one table to compare them on.
First: Make Both Agents Work From the Same Sold Properties
A valuation should start from homes that have actually sold — not from homes still listed, and not from asking prices that no buyer has agreed to pay.
My approach: ask each agent for a list built to exactly the same brief — sold properties from the same period, in the same neighbourhood, closest to your home in type and size, each with its sale price, sale date, bedrooms and bathrooms, lot and condition. When the lists arrive, do not look at the conclusions first. Look at whether the two agents are even using the same houses.
If the lists are largely the same but the conclusions differ by $100K, the gap is not in the market — it is in each agent's method, and that is exactly where you dig next. If the higher agent's list is full of bigger homes, newer renovations, or properties in a different area, his $100K was not calculated from your home; it was borrowed from somebody else's. The reverse also holds: if the lower agent left out the most recent, closest sale, his number deserves the same question mark. Step one of testing any number is aligning the foundation.
Second: The $100K Has to Break Apart, Item by Item
Once the foundation matches, ask the higher agent to take the extra $100K apart: which specific features are worth money, and how much is each one worth?
Here is a set of illustrative numbers I made up to show the method — they are not a valuation of any real home. Suppose the closest comparable sold for $1.2 million and the high valuation is $1.3 million. The $100K gap is broken down as: slightly larger lot, plus $30K; newer kitchen, plus $40K; finished basement, plus $30K. The three items add up to exactly $100K, which looks tidy. Now keep asking. Was the kitchen in that $1.2 million sale actually dated? If its condition was about the same as yours, that $40K is double counting. Is the $30K for the basement already reflected in the size or layout comparison? Ask item by item: keep what holds up, cross out what is duplicated or unexplained, and what remains is the part of the $100K that actually has evidence behind it.
One more detail that often gets skipped: the same sold property can be used in opposite directions by two agents — one cites it to prove your home should sell for more, the other to prove it is worth no more than that. When that happens, do not argue about whether the house is "similar." Go back to the concrete differences — how much size, how much lot, how many years of renovation — and land each one in dollars. A comparison that cannot be landed in dollars is an adjective, not a valuation, no matter how lively it sounds. Adjectives are fine to listen to; they are not a basis for a list price.
Also ask about time: how many months ago are the comparables from, and have prices for similar homes moved since? Comparing across months without a time adjustment quietly distorts the number. Finally, ask both agents to put the pricing rationale in writing — one page is enough: which sales they used, how much each adjustment is, and why they recommend that list price. A number someone is willing to write down carries different weight from one only spoken across a table. Ontario's rules for registrants include a Code of Ethics requirement not to make false or misleading representations — a written rationale that can be re-read later protects the seller, and it is also how an agent stands behind his own number.
Third: The List Price Is Your Decision — But Plan for "What If It Doesn't Sell" First
One point needs to be clear: the price written on the listing agreement is the seller's decision — it is your name on that agreement. The agent's job is to lay out the evidence and the risks, not to decide for you. So when an agent talks only about "how high it can go" and never about "what happens if it doesn't sell," it is up to you to ask the second half.
Ask three things. First, the rhythm: if you list at this price and showings and offers come in below expectations, when do you review it, and by what standard do you adjust? Settle that before signing, ideally in your written arrangements — not in a fresh negotiation every week after listing. Second, the term: how long is the listing agreement, can it be ended early, and is there a fee for doing so? The longer the term and the harder the exit, the longer an inflated starting price locks you in. Third, the net: do not compare gross prices. Ask both agents to estimate, on the same basis, what you actually keep after commission, taxes and closing adjustments. A $100K gap in gross is usually not a $100K gap in net, and decisions should be made on the net figure.
In short, trying a higher price is not out of the question — but it should be a decision with a time limit, a review standard and an exit, not a promise traded for a long contract.
Three Common Misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "Whoever values it higher knows my neighbourhood better." Not necessarily. A higher number may simply mean a bolder speaker. Knowledge shows in whether the comparables are recent and local and whether the adjustments survive questions — it has nothing to do with the size of the number.
Misunderstanding 2: "It sells for what it sells for anyway — if we list high, we can always reduce." Reductions are not free. A home that sits too long and drops repeatedly makes buyers assume something is wrong with it, and you start every later negotiation on the defensive. The further the starting price is from reality, the more the correction costs.
Misunderstanding 3: "The lower agent just wants a quick, easy sale." It is equally possible the lower agent's comparables are simply more solid. Judge the motive after the evidence: have him put out his list and adjustments the same way. A lower price that can be shown and explained deserves more serious consideration than a higher one that cannot — and a lower price that cannot be shown should not be signed either.
When Both Agents Are Sitting Across From You, I Suggest This Order
- Set the same assignment in advance: each agent brings sold properties from the same area and period, as close to your home in type and size as possible — no asking prices of homes still on the market.
- Compare the lists before hearing the conclusions: are they working from the same sales, which ones differ, and why?
- Have the higher agent break the extra $100K into items, each with an amount and a basis, and cross out any double counting on the spot.
- Ask each agent for a one-page written pricing rationale: which sales were used, how the adjustments were made, and the recommended list price.
- Compare on net, not gross: deduct commission, taxes and closing adjustments on the same basis, then look at the gap.
- Before signing, settle the second half: the agreement's term, the standard for reviewing and adjusting price, and the conditions for ending it early — all confirmed before you sign the listing agreement.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. If you have two valuations on your table that are far apart, bring both lists in. We will go through the same sold properties and the same adjustments, item by item, and only then decide who to sign with.
This article is general information only. It is not legal advice and not a valuation of any specific property. The terms and exit conditions of your own case are governed by the documents you sign; consult an Ontario lawyer where needed.
Primary source: the requirement in the Code of Ethics, O. Reg. 365/22 (Ontario e-Laws, reviewed November 2026) that registrants not make false or misleading representations. The $1.2 million, $1.3 million and adjustment figures above are illustrative numbers, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Does the agent who values my home higher know my neighbourhood better?
Not necessarily. A higher number may simply mean a bolder speaker; knowledge shows in whether the comparables are recent and local and whether the adjustments survive questions, not in the size of the number.
If we list high, can't we just reduce the price later at no cost?
Reductions are not free. A home that sits too long and drops repeatedly makes buyers assume something is wrong with it, and you start every later negotiation on the defensive; the further the starting price is from reality, the more the correction costs.
Does a lower estimate mean that agent just wants a quick, easy sale?
Not necessarily — the lower agent's comparables may simply be more solid. Judge after the evidence: a lower price that can be shown and explained deserves more serious consideration than a higher one that cannot.


