I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: a list price is not a wishing well. Set it above the market and it looks like you are leaving yourself room — but in most cases the seller is the one paying for that number. The bill does not arrive as a single charge. It arrives as fewer showings, a listing that slowly goes stale, and a final price and closing date that both get dragged down.
Many sellers have said the same sentence to me: "Let's start high — we can always come down." It sounds safe. The problem is that the market does not work that way. There are three gates below, and every one of them depends directly on where the price sits. Once you see them, you will understand that a high price does not block buyers from bargaining — it blocks your own sale.
Gate one: the price decides who can even see your home
Today, buyers start on their phones, not in their cars. They set filters — area, home type, maximum budget — and the list is cut in one pass. That maximum is not a casual number. It usually sits right on two lines: the amount of their mortgage pre-approval and the cash they can actually put down. There is very little stretch above it.
Take an illustrative set of numbers, used only to show the mechanism — not any real sale: suppose recent sales in your community support a reasonable range around $950,000, and you list at $1,050,000. Every buyer whose search cap is set at $1,000,000 never sees your home at all. It is not that they dislike it; it simply never appears in their results. The buyers who do see a $1,050,000 price have budgets that could buy a better home, so they compare yours against homes in that tier — and walk away.
Buyers' agents filter the same way. The client's budget is what it is, and a listing priced well above it usually does not make the showing route, because the trip would be wasted. So the first cost of overpricing is not "earning a little less." It is shutting out, as a group, the buyers who fit your home best. With too few people through the door, no pricing strategy and no negotiating skill has anything to work with.
One more point is easy to miss: your home does not sit on the market alone. On the same street and in the same community, new listings come out every week, and the ones priced close to recent sales pull buyers' attention away again and again. If your price stays parked high, your home becomes the backdrop that makes the newer listings look like good value. By the time you finally come down to a sensible level, the strongest buyers in that round may already have bought someone else's home and left the market. The buyer pool is not standing still. Miss one round and you wait for the next — and by then, your home is no longer the new listing.
Gate two: the longer it sits, the worse the label gets
A home carries the most weight in its first stretch on the market. A new listing lands in agents' and buyers' alerts, and people give it a closer look. As time passes, the label changes. Days on market are right there in the open for everyone to see. When a home has sat for a long time without selling, a buyer's first thought is rarely "this seller is patient." It is usually one of two guesses: the price is not serious, or the home has a problem nobody is mentioning.
A price cut does not restore the launch position either. The first cut sends the signal "the seller is starting to face reality." A second cut reads as "the seller is getting anxious." Offers that arrive at that stage are often not really about the home — they are aimed at your cutting pattern. The buyer counts all the months you spent priced high as a reason to offer low, assuming there is more room to fall.
The feedback from showings changes flavour too. Early visitors are mostly genuine buyers, and their comments are about the home itself — layout, light, finishes. The people still willing to come after a long sit include bargain hunters who specialize in stale listings, and their first question is how much the seller will give up. At that point the negotiation feels completely different: the other side does not believe they are buying a good home from you; they believe they are waiting out a price that will keep dropping. The high number you defended for months becomes their most convenient argument for a discount.
Then there is the arithmetic anyone can do. Every extra month on the market, property tax, insurance, mortgage interest and upkeep keep running — none of them pause. Still using illustrative numbers: a home with carrying costs of about $3,500 a month that spends three extra months on the market because of its price burns more than $10,000 in carrying costs alone, before you count anything that comes off the final sale price. Time is never free; the bill just arrives quietly.
Gate three: even a willing buyer at your price can hit the appraisal wall
Suppose luck is on your side and a buyer does sign at your high price. The story is still not over. If that buyer needs a mortgage, the lender orders an appraisal. The appraiser does not work from your list price, or from what the buyer agreed to pay, but from what similar nearby homes have actually sold for. If the sold record cannot support the contract number, the appraisal comes in low.
A low appraisal opens a gap. The buyer either covers the difference in cash, comes back to renegotiate the price, or the deal falls apart. Buyers who both have a large amount of spare cash and are willing to pour it into one home are rare in real life. And if the deal does collapse, the home returns to the market with its days on market still accumulating — every label from gate two sticks back on, harder to remove than before.
So a high price is not insurance. It shuts out buyers first, burns time second, and can still break on the appraisal third. Walk through all three gates and not one of them is working in the seller's favour.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding one: "Price high so buyers have room to negotiate down." Buyers anchor their offers to recent sold prices nearby, not to your list price. Price as high as you like — if nobody comes through the door, there is nothing to negotiate. Real negotiating room grows on its own when several buyers want the same home at the same time and compete. It is not created by writing a bigger number.
Misunderstanding two: "If it doesn't sell, we cut the price — a cut is the same as relaunching." It is not. The size and number of your cuts, and your accumulated days on market, stay in the MLS record where buyers and agents can see them. A reduced home is read by the market as "a listing that has been cut," not as a new listing — and buyers will follow the cutting pattern and guess where you will land next.
Misunderstanding three: "My home is special, so the neighbours' sale prices don't apply." Every home has its own features — renovation, lot, exposure, quiet — and those should absolutely be discussed and priced in, item by item. But pricing in means adding and subtracting on top of the sold data, not inventing a separate number outside it. In the end, the buyer's lender and the appraiser recognize completed sales, not the number in the seller's head.
Before you set a price, I suggest working through this order
- Ask for data before you ask for a number: have the agent list, one by one, the homes in your community that have actually sold in recent months, with each sale price, its date, and how it differs from your home. A pricing case built on asking prices instead of sold prices deserves a question mark.
- Go through the adjustments line by line: size, age, renovation, lot, parking — and a time adjustment, bringing a sale from months ago forward to today at the pace the market has actually moved. Every plus and every minus should come with a reason.
- Set a range first, then choose where the list price sits: establish a reasonable low, most likely, and high for your home, then decide where inside that range the asking price goes — and be able to say why it sits there, instead of simply picking the top number.
- Put the review date in the calendar before you launch: for example, if showings and feedback in the first two weeks fall short of an agreed level, the price gets adjusted on a set day, to a set level. Agree on it in advance, so you are not torn between holding on and wasting more weeks.
- Add up your monthly carrying cost: tax, insurance, interest and upkeep together. With that number in hand, you know what "let's wait a little longer" actually costs each month, and you negotiate with a clearer head.
- Prepare for the appraisal in advance: organize the sold records that support your price, plus a list of your home's upgrades, into one package that can go to the buyer's lender when the appraisal is ordered. A price holds up when the paperwork holds it up.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. Pricing does not need guessing. Put the sold data on the table and go through it home by home — the price that comes out of that work is the price the market will actually meet.
This article is general information only. It is not an appraisal, and it is not legal or mortgage advice. The right price for your home depends on the latest sales in its community, its condition, and the market at the time; review a full CMA and professional advice before you price.
Primary basis: pricing in this article rests on recent sold records from TRREB MLS® (reviewed through REALM / PropTx) as the primary evidence. No third-party statistics about how much overpriced homes lose are relied on. The figures $950,000, $1,050,000 and $3,500 per month are illustrative numbers only — not a real transaction or a real property.
Frequently asked questions
Price high so buyers have room to negotiate down?
Buyers anchor their offers to recent sold prices nearby, not to your list price. Price as high as you like — if nobody comes through the door, there is nothing to negotiate. Real negotiating room grows when several buyers want the home and compete with each other.
If it doesn't sell, we cut the price — is a cut the same as relaunching?
It is not. The size and number of your cuts, and your accumulated days on market, stay in the MLS record where buyers and agents can see them. A price-cut home reads as a price-cut home, not a new listing.
My home is special, so do the neighbours' sale prices not apply?
Every home has its own features — renovation, lot, exposure, quiet — and those should absolutely be discussed and priced in, item by item. But pricing in means adding and subtracting on top of the sold data, not inventing a separate number outside it. The buyer's lender and appraiser ultimately rely on sold records.


