Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Your Agent Says One Price, the Appraiser Says Another — Which One Counts?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the short answer first: you may end up holding three different numbers for the same home, and none of them is necessarily wrong. They were simply built for different jobs. An agent's comparative market analysis (CMA) is an opinion used to set a listing strategy. An appraiser's report is a formal valuation made for a lender. MPAC's number exists to calculate property tax. Compare the three as if they were the same thing and you will only confuse yourself.

First: how an agent's CMA is built

When I prepare a CMA for a seller, the method is not complicated. I start with recently sold homes in the same neighbourhood that are closest to yours in type and size, and I look at similar homes currently listed. Then I adjust, item by item: newer renovations add a little, one fewer parking space takes a little away, and if a comparable sold some time ago, I adjust for how the market has moved since. The result is not one fixed number. It is a range, and we set the asking price from that range based on how quickly you want to sell.

A simple example I made up, with illustrative numbers only: a home on your street just sold for $1,000,000 (illustrative). Yours has one extra bathroom but an older roof. After those adjustments, I might suggest thinking in a range of $1,010,000 to $1,030,000 (illustrative) instead of picking a number out of thin air.

One more layer matters: what similar homes are currently asking, how long they have sat unsold, and which listings expired because the price never worked. Sold prices tell you what buyers have paid; active and expired listings tell you what buyers refuse to pay. A range built from both sides is a range you can stand on.

A CMA is close to the market and fast to update. Its limit is just as clear: it is my professional opinion as a broker, not a formal appraisal, and a bank will not lend against it. There is no single province-wide CMA form, either, and three agents can produce three ranges for the same home. That is not necessarily incompetence — it is a reminder to ask not "what is your number?" but "which sales did you use, and how did you adjust them?" A number you can audit is a number you can trust.

Second: why an appraiser's report is the formal one

A formal appraisal is usually ordered because a lender requires it. When a buyer applies for a mortgage, the bank wants to confirm the home supports the loan, so it engages a designated appraiser. In Canada, appraisers hold the AACI or CRA designation from the Appraisal Institute of Canada (AIC) and work to CUSPAP, the Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.

An appraiser also works mainly from comparable sales for a typical home, but the discipline is stricter: an in-person inspection, measurements, records checked, and a written reason for every adjustment, in a report that has to stand up to the lender's review. The appraiser answers to the lender, not to the buyer or the seller, so the number does not go up just because a seller hopes for more, and it does not go down because a buyer wants a discount. Whether your home is tidied up on inspection day does not change the measured area or the recorded condition — the report runs on verifiable facts, not first impressions.

And when a purchase price comes in above the appraised value, lenders generally lend against the lower figure — which is why some deals need extra down payment money at the financing stage. The reverse is not a licence to raise the price either: an appraisal at or above the sale price only means the lender's hurdle is cleared. The market's answer was already given on the day the deal was signed.

Third: why the MPAC number so often looks off

MPAC is Ontario's property assessment body. The assessed value it assigns to your home is used to calculate property tax. It is not a selling price. Assessments are done in bulk, as of a common valuation date, and cannot be adjusted house by house for your latest renovation the way an appraiser would. So an MPAC figure well below — or above — today's market is nothing unusual, and it is not a number to negotiate with.

Put side by side, the three documents look like this:

Document Who prepares it Who it is for Can it set the sale price?
CMA (comparative market analysis) Real estate agent / broker Seller's listing strategy; buyer's offer decisions An agent's opinion — useful reference, not a formal appraisal
Formal appraisal report AIC-designated appraiser (AACI / CRA), under CUSPAP Mainly the lender The lender lends against it; the market may still pay a different price
MPAC assessment MPAC Municipality, for property tax No — it is not market value

Three common misunderstandings

1. "The agent's estimate is the number the bank will use." No. A CMA guides pricing strategy. The bank relies on the appraisal it ordered, written by a designated appraiser under CUSPAP. The two numbers being close is reassuring, but they are not the same document.

2. "MPAC assessed it low, so that is all my home is worth." No. MPAC's figure serves taxation, and its valuation date is not today's selling market. Pricing your home off it means measuring with the wrong ruler.

3. "What I spent on renovations should be added to the price." No. The market only counts what a buyer will pay extra for that work. Spend $80,000 (illustrative) on a highly personal renovation and buyers may credit only part of it — or none. Money in and value out are rarely one-to-one.

If you are getting ready to sell, I suggest this order

  1. Ask your agent for a CMA backed by actual comparable sales. Look at the range, not a single number, and ask how each adjustment was made — especially whether a time (market) adjustment was included.
  2. Set the MPAC figure aside. Use it to check your tax bill, not to discuss pricing.
  3. Rehearse the low-appraisal scenario in advance: if the bank's appraisal comes in below the sale price, how much extra down payment does the buyer need, and does the deal still hold together?
  4. Keep one honest sentence in mind: the final price is whatever a buyer actually pays. No document calculates it. The documents exist so you price and negotiate with your feet on the ground.
  5. If the lender or the other side requires a formal appraisal, get ready for the appraiser's visit: renovation receipts and the home's basic records, gathered in advance, make for a steadier report.

Honest work, done properly, is how I do business. I am Ming Ren. If you come to me holding three numbers that do not match, we will sort them by what each document is actually for — and only then talk about an asking price.


This article is general information, not legal advice and not a formal appraisal. Pricing and financing outcomes depend on the property, the market, and the lender's requirements; consult a licensed professional before acting.

Primary sources: Appraisal Institute of Canada (AIC) public material on the AACI and CRA designations and the CUSPAP standards; MPAC (mpac.ca) public material on property assessment for taxation. The figures $1,000,000, $1,010,000–$1,030,000, and $80,000 are illustrative numbers I invented for explanation, not real transactions.

Frequently asked questions

Is the agent's estimate the number the bank will use?

No. A CMA guides pricing strategy, while the bank relies on the appraisal it ordered, written by a designated appraiser under CUSPAP. The two numbers being close is reassuring, but they are not the same document.

If MPAC assessed my home low, is that all it is worth?

No. MPAC's figure serves taxation and its valuation date is not today's selling market. Pricing your home off it means measuring with the wrong ruler.

Should what I spent on renovations be added to the price?

No. The market only counts what a buyer will pay extra for that work. Money spent on a highly personal renovation may be credited only in part or not at all, and money in and value out are rarely one-to-one.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation