Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

How Should You Price Your Ontario Home for Sale? Start With These Three Questions

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: an asking price is not the price you hope to get, and it is not a price any buyer has to accept. It is a signal — one that brings the right buyers in at the right time. The real pricing question is not "how much do I want?" It is "based on recent comparable sales, can this price be defended, and will buyers still walk in?"

This article covers three things: where the anchor for a price actually sits, the rule boundaries around a low price paired with an offer date, and what to do when a high price sits too long.

1. The anchor is comparable sales, not your target

Pricing always starts by looking backward: what have similar homes in the same community, of the same type and in similar condition, actually sold for recently? The further your asking price sits from that anchor, the stronger your reasons need to be — condition, lot, school district, closing date — and each reason should point to a specific sold comparable, not to "our home is nicer."

An illustrative example, with invented numbers only to show the arithmetic: suppose comparable sales support a market value of about $1.18 million. You have three routes. Price near $1.18 million and buyers get a clear expectation, suited to offers anytime and normal negotiation. Price around $999,000 with an offer date and you are trading a low sticker for traffic — which only works if enough buyers actually show up. Price at $1.29 million or above and you are betting on something unique, at the cost of fewer showings from day one. None of the three is wrong in itself. What is wrong is choosing a route with no evidence behind it and no fallback.

One floor applies to all of it: under Ontario's Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22), a registrant's advertising and statements must be accurate and not misleading. A price can be a strategy, but it cannot be a fake signal you never intend to accept, set only to bait traffic. Buyers and their agents can tell, and once trust is gone, everything after it costs more.

2. A low price with an offer date: settle the rules first

A low asking price is not itself a violation. A messy process is. Before using this approach, a seller should settle several things in writing:

  • Holding offers requires the seller's written direction. Under RECO Bulletin 4.2, if a seller decides offers will be held to a set date and time, that direction must be clear, specific and documented. The agent cannot change the date on their own; a change needs fresh direction from the seller, notice to all interested buyers, and an updated listing.
  • How pre-emptive ("bully") offers will be handled must be decided in advance. Under RECO Bulletin 4.3, the seller should state beforehand whether an offer arriving before the offer date will be considered. If the plan changes, interested buyers must be notified as the rules require. A vague note that the seller "reserves the right" does not make the position clear.
  • When there are competing offers, the number must be disclosed. Under section 22.7 of O. Reg. 567/05, the seller's brokerage must communicate the number of competing written offers to every person who has made one of them.
  • Whether offer content is shared is the seller's written choice. Also under section 22.7, only if the seller directs it may the brokerage share the substance of competing written offers — or parts of it — with everyone who made one. Nothing that identifies the person making an offer may be shared, and the seller can change or revoke the direction.

In short, this strategy sells concentrated competition, not opacity. The earlier the process is written down, the fewer disputes there are on offer night. And if there simply are not enough buyers that week, a low price performs no magic: you may receive one low offer and be left with a first impression of "it didn't even sell at that price." Use it only where your home is genuinely scarce in today's market — not because it worked for someone else last year.

3. The biggest cost of pricing high is time

Pricing high is not a sin. If a home is genuinely distinctive and you are in no rush, leaving negotiation room can be a defensible choice. But count the cost: days on market are public. The longer a listing sits, the more buyers first ask "why hasn't this sold?" — and the more they treat your time on market as a reason to bid lower.

So a high price needs a pre-agreed trigger for adjusting it, settled before listing, not improvised two months in. For example, illustratively: if showings in the first two weeks run clearly below comparable listings in the community, or showings produce no offers, move toward the comparable-sales anchor by the amount agreed in advance. Adjusting is not surrender; it is correcting the signal. Once the price reaches a range buyers will enter, showings and negotiating position usually improve more than they do under a high price held out of stubbornness.

One last point: the asking price, the offer date, and whether offer content will be shared are best decided together, in writing, around the time the listing paperwork is signed. Changing any of them mid-listing means notifying another round of people, every time.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Price it low and competition will always bid it back up." Not necessarily. A low price only brings people in. The final price depends on how many qualified written offers actually arrive that night. If nobody competes, a low price is just a low price.

"The offer date is the agent's business; the seller doesn't need the details." No. Holding offers and how pre-emptive offers are handled are the seller's instructions, and they belong in writing. An agent changing a date on their own, or failing to notify buyers of a change, is a problem that has actually appeared in RECO discipline cases.

"Sitting on the market doesn't matter — I won't drop the price and a buyer will come." Time on market changes how buyers judge the home. It is not neutral: it gets read as a problem with the property or the price, and it shows up in the offers that follow.

Before you set a price, do these five things in order

  1. Pull the recent real sales of the same type in the same community, compare them property by property, and fix the market-value anchor before discussing an asking price.
  2. Choose one of the three routes — near market value with offers anytime, low with an offer date, or high with room to negotiate — and say the reasons and the risks out loud.
  3. If you use an offer date, put the hold direction, the treatment of pre-emptive offers, and whether offer content will be shared, all in writing before you list.
  4. Set the price-adjustment trigger before listing: how many showings, how long a wait, what situation triggers a change, and by how much. Do not rely on feel in the moment.
  5. Watch the real feedback in the first two weeks — showings, offers, and what buyer agents actually say — and act on the trigger you set, without dragging it out.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are working through a selling price, pull the comparable sales first and we will go through the numbers item by item before deciding what to ask.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. Listing strategy, offer procedures and disclosure duties depend on your listing agreement and your circumstances. Consult an Ontario lawyer, or confirm with your brokerage, before acting.

Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA); O. Reg. 567/05 s.22.7 (disclosure of the number and content of competing offers); O. Reg. 365/22 Code of Ethics (statements must be accurate and not misleading); RECO Bulletins 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, 5.1 (consulted November 2026). The $1.18 million, $999,000 and $1.29 million figures are illustrative only, not real sales.

Frequently asked questions

If I price it low, will competition always bid it back up?

Not necessarily. A low price only brings people in; the final price depends on how many qualified written offers actually arrive that night. If nobody competes, a low price is just a low price.

Is the offer date the agent's business, with no need for the seller to know the details?

No. Holding offers and how pre-emptive offers are handled are the seller's instructions, and they belong in writing. An agent changing a date on their own, or failing to notify buyers of a change, is a problem that has actually appeared in RECO discipline cases.

Does sitting on the market matter if I refuse to drop the price?

Yes. Time on market changes how buyers judge the home — it gets read as a problem with the property or the price, and it shows up in the offers that follow.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation