I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: a list price is not one number you guess. It comes in two moves. First, use homes that have actually sold to establish what your home is likely worth — a range, not a point. Second, choose a list-price strategy inside that range. Collapsing the two moves into one is where most pricing goes wrong: the price you want, the price your neighbour is asking, and the price you paid all get stirred together, and the number that goes on the listing is one nobody can explain.
This article sets out the order I actually use: separate three different prices, work through five steps to build the range and pick the strategy, and set a review date before the home ever goes live.
First, separate three prices that are not the same thing
Pricing conversations go sideways when three different terms are used as if they were interchangeable.
| Term | What it is | Who decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Market value range | What the home will most likely sell for, estimated from recent comparable sales | The market; a CMA only works it out |
| List price | The number on the MLS® listing — a marketing choice | You, on your agent's advice |
| Sale price | The price in the accepted offer, together with its conditions and closing date | Buyer and seller, by negotiation |
Two other numbers should not set your price. An MPAC assessment is for property tax, and Ontario assessments are still based on a January 1, 2016 base date — it is not today's market value. And a formal appraisal is an opinion by a qualified appraiser that a lender or a court can rely on; a comparative market analysis (CMA) is not an appraisal, and an agent should not call it one. What a CMA does give you is visible working: which sales were used, and how each one was adjusted, so you can check the arithmetic yourself.
My five steps: range first, strategy second
Step 1: Start with sold homes only — ignore asking prices for now. Begin with recent sales of the same property type in the same neighbourhood, ideally within the last three months, expanding to six only if you need more evidence. Asking prices are other sellers' hopes, not evidence, so set active listings aside at this stage. The closer the match — type, size, bedrooms, bathrooms, parking, lot — the fewer adjustments you will need later. Three to six genuinely comparable sales are enough to sketch a preliminary range; padding the set with distant sales only inflates it.
Step 2: Adjust each sale — time first, then the house itself. No two homes are identical, so do not simply average the sold prices. Adjust each comparable toward your home: subtract value for anything the comparable has that yours lacks, and add value for anything yours has that the comparable lacks. Do time first: a sale from several months ago must be carried to today using the change in the MLS® Home Price Index benchmark for that property type, in either direction. Then adjust for condition and features — renovations, a finished or unfinished basement, exposure, lot and location factors — with a dollar figure and a reason for each line. Only when that worksheet is done does the range stand up.
An illustrative example, with invented numbers only to show the method: a same-type home sold three months ago for $1,080,000, and the matching HPI benchmark has eased about 2% since then, so its time-adjusted price is about $1,058,000. Its basement was unfinished and yours is finished, so an agreed value for that finish is added. Do the same for every comparable, and the band where the adjusted prices cluster is your value range.
Step 3: Stress-test the range against active and expired listings. With the range built, look at what is on the market now. Active listings are the competition your home faces on day one: how many similar homes, at what prices, and for how long. Expired and terminated listings matter even more — those are prices buyers have already refused. If the top of your range sits above three similar active listings and you cannot name a hard reason why, that top probably will not hold. This test does not change the sold evidence; it tells you early what buyers will compare you against.
Step 4: Factor in market speed — for your pocket and property type only. A province-wide or city-wide average tells you almost nothing about one specific home. Look instead at three things for your neighbourhood and property type: months of inventory (how long current listings would take to sell at the current pace), selling time (TRREB publishes both LDOM, for the final listing, and PDOM, which also counts an earlier terminated-and-relisted period for the same property and is closer to the true time on market), and the sale-to-list price ratio. Together they tell you whether to tighten or loosen the range: when selling times stretch and inventory builds, the top of the range needs more discipline; when the evidence supports strength, there is no need to discount out of caution alone.
Step 5: Choose the list price inside the range — and set the review date the same day. Only now pick the list price. There are three usual positions: at the middle of the range, for a steady, defensible sale; slightly below the middle, which only makes sense where there are genuinely enough buyers for that type and location to compete — otherwise a low list is just a low sale; or above the range, reserved for homes with real scarcity and thin comparable evidence, with the cost stated up front: longer time on market, and usually an eventual move back into the range. Which one fits depends on your timing and closing needs, not on hope. Whichever you choose, put the review date in the calendar on listing day — for example, a data check two weeks in covering showings, feedback, and any change in competing listings — and agree in advance what evidence would trigger a price change, instead of holding on by feel.
After listing, watch three signals, not the noise
Do not ask every day whether anyone looked. At the review date, check three things. First, showings and inquiries compared with similar active listings: a clear shortfall is usually a price signal first, not a verdict on the house. Second, whether buyer-agent feedback keeps pointing at the same thing — price, condition, or layout; repeated feedback is data. Third, whether the competition moved: a similar home listed lower, or an older listing reduced first, changes your relative position, and the original strategy has to be recalculated. When all three signals argue against the current price, adjust once, decisively, into the band where buyers will engage seriously; a series of small cuts only stretches the time on market.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"What I paid, plus what I spent on renovations, is what it should sell for." No. Buyers do not pay for your costs. Your purchase price and renovation spending determine what you net, not what the home is worth. Value is set by what buyers will pay today for comparable homes — the sold evidence.
"List high and reduce later; that is safer than starting low." A reduction changes the number, not the first impression. Days on market are public, and the longer a home sits, the more buyers start by asking why it has not sold, which weakens your negotiating position. The first pricing decision is your best one — which is why the five steps above build the range carefully before anything is listed.
"The online estimate and the MPAC assessment are close to the agent's number, so list at that." Those three numbers come from completely different places: an automated estimate has never been inside your home and knows nothing of its condition or upkeep; the MPAC assessment still rests on a 2016 base date; a CMA is built from real nearby sales, adjusted one by one. If they occasionally land close together, that is coincidence. Price from the evidence that is hardest, not the number that is most convenient.
If you are pricing this month, do these five things in order
- Ask for three to six recent sold comparables of the same type first, with sale dates, type, and size set out in full. No sold evidence, no pricing conversation.
- Ask to see the adjustment worksheet: the HPI basis for each time adjustment stated, a dollar figure for each condition adjustment, and a value range as the output — not a single number.
- Pull the similar active listings and the recent expired and terminated ones, and stress-test your range against them so your position relative to the competition is explicit.
- Calibrate the range using months of inventory, selling time, and the sale-to-list ratio for your own neighbourhood and property type — not city-wide averages.
- Choose the list-price position inside the range, state the reason and the cost of that choice out loud, and write down the review date and the conditions that would trigger a change.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are pricing a home, bring the comparable sales and the adjustment worksheet, and we will go through the numbers line by line before deciding what to list at.
This article is general information only, not legal advice and not a formal appraisal. A specific home's value range depends on the sold evidence and the home's condition at the time. Before acting, work from your agent's CMA and, where needed, consult an Ontario lawyer or a qualified appraiser.
Primary sources: TRREB Market Watch definitions and published measures for LDOM, PDOM, months of inventory, and sale-to-list price ratio; CREA MLS® Home Price Index methodology (fixed benchmark attributes, published by property type and area); MPAC assessment base date of January 1, 2016 (consulted November 2026). The $1,080,000 and 2% figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Is what I paid, plus what I spent on renovations, what the home should sell for?
No. Buyers do not pay for your costs; your purchase price and renovation spending determine what you net, not what the home is worth, and value is set by what buyers will pay today for comparable homes.
Is listing high and reducing later safer than starting low?
A reduction changes the number, not the first impression. Days on market are public, and the longer a home sits, the more buyers start by asking why it has not sold, which weakens your negotiating position.
If the online estimate and MPAC assessment are close to the agent's number, should I list at that?
Those three numbers come from completely different places: an automated estimate has never been inside your home, the MPAC assessment still rests on a 2016 base date, and a CMA is built from real nearby sales adjusted one by one.


