I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: a list price is a strategy number the seller puts on the table. It is not what the home is worth. The same home, listed a little low or a little high, can end up selling for much the same amount — and a sale price below asking does not, by itself, mean you got a bargain. The comparison that matters is never "how far am I from the asking price?" It is "how does this price compare with what similar homes have actually sold for recently?"
This article covers three things: how to recognize the two pricing plays you will see most often in the GTA, what the rules actually entitle you to know during an offer process, and how to set your own ceiling before you bid.
1. Recognize which play the seller is running
The first play is a low list price with a set offer date. The asking price sits noticeably below what you would expect for comparable homes, and the listing states that offers will be reviewed on a specific day and time, not before. The purpose is straightforward: give buyers time to view, gather everyone interested into one evening, and compare several offers side by side. The seller is not selling at the list price — the list price is the bait. For a buyer, the worst mistake on this kind of listing is anchoring to that number. Every dollar you offer has to be measured against value, not against a figure that was set low on purpose.
The second play is a high list price with offers welcome at any time. The price is set above recent comparable sales, there is no offer date, and the seller reviews offers one at a time — waiting for someone willing to pay up, or leaving room to negotiate down slowly. A long time on market and one or two price changes are normal here, not a warning sign by themselves. For a buyer, "how much I got off the asking price" is the most meaningless victory of all: the seller raised the price first, and what you negotiated away may simply be the cushion built in from the start.
The third, most ordinary case is a list price set close to recent sold prices, with no staged competition and no padding. These are actually the easiest homes to judge, because the asking price and the value are close, and the negotiation is about conditions, closing dates and details — not about first correcting a fictional number.
How do you tell them apart? Check three things: how far the list price sits from recent comparable sales in the same area, whether the listing sets a specific offer review date and time, and how long the home has been on the market and whether the price has changed. Match those three, and the play is usually clear.
2. What the rules entitle you to know in an offer process
Ontario real estate is governed by the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and its regulations. Under the phase of the rules in force since December 1, 2023, several points bear directly on bidding, as set out in guidance published by RECO, Ontario's real estate regulator:
- Holding offers to a date requires the seller's written direction. A brokerage must normally convey an offer to the seller as soon as possible. Delaying presentation to a set date is allowed only on the seller's clear, specific written direction — a line in the listing alone is not enough. That direction must also say how pre-emptive offers (often called bully offers), submitted before the date, will be handled. If the seller changes course, that takes a new written direction, and people who have expressed interest must be notified.
- You are entitled to the number of written offers. Once you have submitted a written offer, the seller's brokerage must tell every person who made one how many competing written offers there are. Verbal expressions of interest, and offers not yet submitted, do not count.
- The contents of other offers are private by default. Prices and conditions may be shared only if the seller directs the brokerage in writing to share them — and if anything is shared, it must be shared with every person who submitted an offer, not selectively. Information that could identify a buyer must never be shared. The seller can also change that direction.
Put together, the picture is this: an offer date is not a game invented by an agent; it rests on the seller's written direction. And the one fact you are guaranteed is the count of offers — not anyone else's price. Your price has to come from your own homework.
3. Before you bid, set your ceiling from the sold records
Value comes from comparable sales analysis: taking homes that have actually sold recently on MLS, choosing the ones genuinely similar to the subject property, and adjusting for the differences. The order I weigh things in: location as close as possible, same immediate area before the wider district; type, bedrooms, bathrooms and size as close as possible; lot size and orientation counted in; and condition and sale date adjusted — a sale from months ago cannot be carried into today's market unchanged. Two further signals matter: the longer a home sits and the more often its price changes, the more its original pricing is failing to hold up.
An illustrative example, with invented numbers used only to show the method, not a real transaction: a home is listed at $999,000 with an offer date. You find three truly comparable recent sales that, after adjustments, point to a value range of $1,080,000 to $1,120,000. Your discussion should start from that range — not from "how far above asking shows good faith." Now the reverse: another home is listed at $1,280,000, offers anytime, but the comparable sales support only $1,180,000 to $1,210,000. Offering $1,200,000 there — $80,000 under asking — is still simply offering at value. You have neither won a discount nor overpaid; you have just declined to pay for the seller's high opening number.
Set your ceiling before offer day, and write it down: where the top of the value range is, and the figure past which you stop. On the day itself, a higher-than-expected offer count and a heated room are not reasons to move that ceiling. The only legitimate reason is a new fact that changes the value — not the fear of losing.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"It sold below asking, so the buyer got a deal." Not necessarily. Check the comparable sales first. If the asking price was set high to begin with, a sale a little below it can still be above value.
"On a low-priced listing, offering well above asking must mean overpaying." Not necessarily either. A low list price is a deliberately lowered starting point; the test is still the value range. An offer above asking that sits inside what comparable sales support can be sound — while an offer below asking that sits above value is the one that is truly expensive.
"On offer night, the agent should tell me what the others offered." Under the current rules, you are entitled to the number of competing written offers. Contents are shared only on the seller's written direction, equally to everyone who submitted an offer, and identifying information about buyers is never shared. Building your bid on finding out about the others is building it on the wrong foundation.
If you are about to offer, do these six things in order
- Identify the play first: measure the list price against recent comparable sales, and confirm any offer date, days on market, and price-change history.
- Have your agent lay out the comparable sales one by one, with the adjustments shown, so you can see how the value range was built — do not accept a single total with no workings.
- Fix your ceiling before you offer, and be honest about the reason you would cross it: because the home is worth it, or because you do not want to lose.
- Ask three process questions: are offers being held on the seller's written direction, how will pre-emptive offers be handled, and has the seller directed that any offer contents be shared?
- After you submit a written offer, confirm the count of competing written offers the seller's brokerage gives you. If the count changes, you should know promptly — but do not treat the count alone as a reason to raise your ceiling.
- Do not give away conditions just to look serious. Price what financing and inspection conditions are worth to you, put them in your total calculation, and only then decide what to trade away.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are unsure about an offer, put the comparable sales on the table first and we will go through the numbers one by one — by the data, not by the temperature of the room.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. TRESA regulations and RECO guidance are updated from time to time, and the seller's directions and listing arrangements in your transaction will affect the process. Confirm the details with your brokerage and an Ontario lawyer before signing.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and O. Reg. 567/05, s.22.7; RECO Bulletin 4.1 (number and content of competing offers) and Bulletin 4.2 (managing a delayed offer presentation process) (RECO, consulted November 2026). The figures $999,000, $1,080,000–$1,120,000, $1,280,000 and $1,180,000–$1,210,000 are illustrative numbers I invented for this article, not real transactions.
Frequently asked questions
It sold below asking, so did the buyer get a deal?
Not necessarily. Check the comparable sales first: if the list price was set high, selling a few ten-thousands below it can still be above value.
On a low-priced listing, does offering well above asking mean overpaying?
Not necessarily either. A low list price is a deliberately lowered starting point; the test is still the value range supported by comparable sales.
On offer night, should my agent tell me what the others offered?
Under the current rules, you are entitled to the number of competing written offers. Contents are shared only on the seller's written direction, equally to everyone who submitted an offer, and identifying information about buyers is never shared.


