Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Choosing a Listing Agent? Don't Count Sales — Learn to Read the Sold Record Honestly

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: a list of homes an agent has sold proves those deals happened. It does not prove the agent will sell your home well. What you actually need to check is three things — how the asking prices were set, how long the homes really spent on the market, and how closely those homes resemble yours. Check those three, and the water in the pretty numbers drains away on its own.

Most families sell a home only once every several years, or even longer. Choose the wrong agent and the cost is rarely a few thousand dollars — it is time and price lost together. Below is the method I use myself when I check a track record. Use it to interview any agent, including me.

1. The sale-to-list ratio: ask how the list price was set first

The ratio is simple arithmetic: sale price divided by list price. A high ratio looks like strong selling. But the number has a built-in weakness — the denominator is chosen by a person. The lower the asking price is set, the easier the ratio is to make look good. Often it measures not how high the home sold, but how low it started.

Take a set of illustrative figures I made up, only to show the arithmetic — not a real transaction: two similar homes on the same street. Home A is listed at $900,000 and sells for $990,000, a ratio of 110%. Home B is listed at $1,050,000 and sells for $1,020,000, a ratio of only about 97%. On ratio alone, A wins easily. But the buyer of B actually paid $30,000 more. Which home sold better cannot be settled by the percentage. You have to come back to the sale price itself, and compare it with what similar homes nearby really sold for.

So when you read this ratio, ask two more questions. First, when this agent lists a home, do they price near market value, or do they habitually list deliberately low, set a fixed offer date, and draw buyers into competing? The second approach is not wrong — in the right market it is a legitimate strategy — but the ratios it produces are naturally high and cannot be compared directly with an agent who prices at market. Second, how many of their homes sold only after a price cut? If a home was listed at $1,100,000, cut to $990,000, and sold at $980,000, the ratio against the final list price looks like a steady 99%. Against the original list price, it tells a different story. Ask which list price the ratio uses, and only then does the number mean anything.

2. Days on market: add back the relisted stretch

The second number people watch is days on market — how long a home sat between listing and sale. A short count usually means the pricing matched the market and buyers came quickly. A very long count often means the opening price was too high, or the home had an issue that needs explaining. But this number has a gap many people miss: relisting resets the count.

Again, illustrative figures only: a home is listed for 60 days without selling, is taken off, then comes back with a new price and new photos and sells in 12 days. The new record shows 12 days — neat and quick. But the time that home actually consumed on the market is the 60 days, plus the gap, plus the final 12. Read only the last record and you will think it was snapped up the moment it appeared, and that will steer your judgement wrong.

To read days on market honestly, do two things. First, when a sale shows a strikingly short count, check whether that address was listed, terminated, or expired before, and piece the stretches together into a total. Second, never read the count alone — read it with the price. A record that took a long time and still needed a large cut points to a pricing problem. A short count with a sale price that holds up is evidence of both good pricing and good execution. Be fair in the other direction too: some homes take long because the seller held firm on price, the season was wrong, or the property was unusual. That should not all be laid on the agent — but the agent should be able to explain the background of each sale clearly. Explaining it clearly is itself a skill.

3. Compare only the same area, the same type, the same period — totals prove little

The most common way a sold record misleads is not in any single number. It is in comparing the wrong homes. An agent may have sold many downtown condos over the past few years — an impressive total — but you are selling a detached house in the suburbs. Whether that experience transfers is a separate question. Different property types, price bands, and neighbourhoods mean different buyer pools, different pricing methods, and different negotiating rhythms. Total volume does not help you.

Hold any comparison to three sames. Same area: does the agent have real sales in your neighbourhood or nearby ones in the last year or two? Same type: are the homes the same kind as yours — detached results cannot be padded out with townhouses and condos? Same period: markets turn. In a hot market a few years ago almost anyone could sell high; recent records say far more about an agent's judgement in today's conditions. And you do not need many: five or six genuinely comparable, complete records are worth far more than fifty unrelated sales.

There is one more step many people skip: do not look only at what sold. Ask about what did not. How many homes did the agent list in a period, how many sold, how many expired or were terminated, and how many price cuts did the sold ones need on average? Together, that is a complete report card. Showing only the wins is human nature, but an agent who will lay out the unsold ones as well — and can explain why each one failed — is usually the more trustworthy one. Sold data generally comes from MLS® listing and sold records; when you check it yourself, use that same source and the same definitions, rather than comparing numbers clipped from different websites.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Their homes always sell over asking, so they must be excellent." Not necessarily. Check first whether the asking prices were set low on purpose. A high ratio produced by underpricing and competing offers proves a pricing tactic; it does not directly prove the home sold for more than its neighbours. In the end, what you compare is the actual sale price between similar homes.

"The record says it sold in under two weeks, so they sell fast." Check whether that address has a relisting history first. The days shown on a single record may be only the final stretch; the weeks from a terminated listing do not write themselves onto the new record. Add the stretches together and you get the home's real time on the market.

"They sell dozens of homes a year, so they must be more experienced than someone who sells a dozen." Volume has to pass the comparability test first. A handful of deals done in your neighbourhood, in your property type, in the current market can be worth more to you than dozens of unrelated sales. And high volume still needs a second look at how steady it was — how many price cuts, terminations, and expiries sit underneath it.

When you interview a listing agent, ask in this order

  1. Ask them to pick out records from the last year or two in your area and your property type — five or six is enough — and for each one show the original list price, every price change, and the final sale price, not a ratio calculated from the last list price only.
  2. For each comparable record, ask whether that address was previously listed, terminated, or expired, add the stretches together for the real time on the market, and ask them to explain why it took as long as it did.
  3. Ask them to state their pricing habit plainly: do they usually list near market value, or list low with a set offer date? Either can work, but you need to know which playbook produced the ratios they are showing you.
  4. Ask for the complete list of their listings over the same period, including the ones that did not sell, expired, or were terminated, and ask why each one failed and what they would change if they could redo it.
  5. Finally, bring it back to your home: based on those sales, what would they list your home at, why, how long do they expect it to take, and what is the next adjustment if there is no movement in three weeks? An agent who can turn other people's sales into a concrete plan for your home is an agent who truly uses data.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Choosing an agent does not require listening to whoever sounds the most exciting. Lay the record out, check it item by item in the order above, and the numbers will speak for themselves.

— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information only, not advice for any specific transaction. Market conditions, property type, and individual circumstances all affect pricing and outcomes. Before signing a listing, verify the record in person with the agent against your own home's situation.

Primary sources: the general conventions for reading MLS® listing and sold records (definitions of sale price, list price, and days on market, and the effect of relisting on the day count). The $900,000, $990,000, $1,050,000, $1,020,000 figures and the 60-day and 12-day figures are illustrative only, not real transactions.

Frequently asked questions

If an agent's homes always sell over asking, are they necessarily excellent?

Not necessarily. Check first whether the asking prices were set low on purpose; a high ratio produced by underpricing proves a pricing tactic, and what you compare in the end is the actual sale price between similar homes.

If the record says it sold in under two weeks, does that agent sell fast?

Check whether that address has a relisting history first. The days shown on a single record may be only the final stretch, and adding the stretches together gives the home's real time on the market.

Does selling dozens of homes a year mean more useful experience than selling a dozen?

Volume has to pass the comparability test first. A handful of deals in your neighbourhood, property type and current market can be worth more than dozens of unrelated sales, and high volume still needs a check for price cuts, terminations and expiries underneath it.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation