Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Judging a Listing Agent by Their Sold Data in Ontario: What to Ask For and How to Read It

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain version first: do not judge a listing agent by what they say about their record. Judge them by what happened to the homes they listed — including the ones that did not sell. And never read a number on its own: compare it with homes of the same type, in the same neighbourhood, over the same period. A number that survives that comparison means something. One that does not is marketing.

Every agent tells a good story in an interview. The record does not play along. This article covers three things: what to ask the agent to produce, how to read three key numbers without being misled, and whether those numbers have anything to do with your home.

1. Ask for the complete listing record, not highlight cases

Ask for a list, not a poster. Have the agent list every property they acted as listing agent for in the past 12 to 24 months, showing for each one: the address or MLS® number, the list price and every price change, the sold price and sold date, days on market, and the final outcome — sold, expired, terminated or withdrawn. For each property, also ask three questions: were they the lead listing agent or a co-listing agent, and is the sale credited to them personally, to a team, or to the brokerage; how similar is that property to yours in neighbourhood, type and price range; and was the pricing their recommendation or the owner's insistence?

Why this level of detail? Because in Ontario, what an agent states is itself regulated. Section 5 of the Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22) under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) requires a registrant to make best efforts to ensure representations are accurate and not misleading, and not to engage in misrepresentation. Section 8 requires a registrant representing a client to promote and protect the client's best interests, and section 9 requires conscientious and competent service. In other words, a track record presented to you should stand up to a property-by-property check, not be a collage of the best-looking sales.

Do one basic check yourself: search the agent's name in the public register of the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO). Confirm the person is currently shown as "registered," note which brokerage they trade under and the registration expiry, and note that the register also shows recent enforcement and discipline information. However good the record looks, if the registration is not in order, the conversation ends there.

2. Three numbers, and how to read them without being misled

Once you have the list, focus on three numbers — each one only means something with a comparison beside it.

Number How to calculate it What to compare it with
Sale-to-list ratio (sold price ÷ list price) Use the final list price, not the first one The overall sale-to-list ratio for the same neighbourhood, property type and period
Days on market (DOM) Days from listing to firm sale; note that relisting resets the count The median days on market for similar homes in the same period
Sell-through rate Number sold ÷ all listings, including expired and terminated The agent's own complete list — never just the sold ones

The sale-to-list ratio is the easiest number to game. A deliberately underpriced home will often sell over asking, and the ratio looks impressive when it is really just a pricing tactic. An agent who lists realistically and sells steadily may show a ratio under 100% while delivering a higher actual sold price. So always read the ratio together with the actual sold prices, and against the market in the same period.

An example, using invented numbers only to show the arithmetic (illustrative): an agent listed 10 homes in the past year, sold 7, had 2 expire and 1 terminated — a 70% sell-through rate. The 7 sold homes averaged a 98% sale-to-list ratio, against 97% for similar homes in the same neighbourhood and period, and the median days on market was 6 days shorter than the market's. That pattern suggests broadly sound pricing and a pace slightly ahead of the market. But if the 3 homes that did not sell were all in your price range, ask exactly why those three did not move.

Treat days on market with care as well: when the same home is taken down and relisted, the day count starts over and it can look like a quick sale. The earlier record is still in the MLS® system, and checking property by property against MLS® numbers leaves nowhere for that to hide.

3. The numbers have to match your home — then ask about process

An agent who sells a great many luxury homes in another city has not thereby shown anything about selling an ordinary townhouse in your neighbourhood. Relevance beats volume: in the past year or two, how many homes have they sold in your neighbourhood, of your property type, in a similar price range? And was the market rising or falling at the time? Read their numbers against the market of their day — in a fast-rising market almost anyone sells quickly, and that is not all skill. Pricing accurately and holding a steady pace in a flat market is the harder test.

Finally, ask about process, because results sometimes involve luck while process shows how they will work next time: how was the pricing recommendation calculated, and which sold comparables support it; how often was the strategy reviewed after listing, and on what evidence; and when offers came in, how were buyer conditions checked? Answers that come with specific documents and specific dates are worth far more than "I have a lot of experience."

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The agent with the most sales must be the best." Not necessarily. A large total may be a team or brokerage total, or may be concentrated in neighbourhoods and price ranges nothing like yours. Ask which sales were personally listed by this agent, and how many are genuinely comparable to your home.

"A sale-to-list ratio over 100% proves a strong negotiator." No. Pricing low to invite competition produces ratios over 100% on its own. First check whether the list price was realistic, then compare the final sold price with similar sales. The ratio by itself proves very little.

"Only look at what sold — the ones that did not sell were the owners' problem." The ones that did not sell are often the most informative about pricing and communication. If expired and terminated listings are left off the record, you are seeing only half of it. Whether the owner was the problem can only be judged by looking at the price-change history and the feedback from that period together.

If you are interviewing listing agents this week, do these five things in order

  1. Check the agent's registration status and brokerage in RECO's public register before you book the meeting.
  2. Ask in advance for the complete listing record for the past 12 to 24 months, including sold, expired and terminated listings and price changes, with the MLS® number shown for each property.
  3. Calculate three things yourself: the sale-to-list ratio using final list prices, days on market, and the sell-through rate including the homes that did not sell — then find the market figures for the same neighbourhood, type and period to compare against.
  4. Pick from the list two homes most similar to yours, one that sold well and one that did not sell, and have the agent walk through the pricing basis and every adjustment, property by property.
  5. Get the pricing recommendation in writing, together with the sold comparables behind it. Question any number that does not reconcile, on the spot — not after you have signed.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are choosing a listing agent, bring the record they gave you and the details of your home, and we will go through the numbers, item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice, and not an evaluation or ranking of any agent. Representation, commission and contract terms in any individual case are governed by the signed documents; consult an Ontario lawyer where needed.

Primary sources: Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO), public register information; Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and O. Reg. 365/22 (Code of Ethics), ss.5, 8, 9 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The figures of 10 listings, a 70% sell-through rate, and 98% versus 97% sale-to-list ratios are illustrative only, not data for any real agent or transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Is the agent with the most sales the best?

Not necessarily. A large total may be a team or brokerage total, or concentrated in neighbourhoods and price ranges nothing like yours. Ask which sales were personally listed by this agent and how many are genuinely comparable to your home.

Does a sale-to-list ratio over 100% prove a strong negotiator?

No. Pricing low to invite competition produces ratios over 100% on its own. First check whether the list price was realistic, then compare the final sold price with similar sales; the ratio by itself proves very little.

Should I only look at what sold, assuming the rest were the owners' problem?

The ones that did not sell are often the most informative about pricing and communication. If expired and terminated listings are left off, you are seeing only half the record, and whether the owner was the problem needs the price-change history and feedback together.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation