Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Choosing a Listing Agent: Ask for These Four Sets of Numbers First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: the worst opening question for a listing agent is "how much can you get me?" Hire whoever names the highest number and the usual result is a home listed too high, weeks lost, and a series of price cuts. Ask instead how that number was built, how the agent's listings in your own area have actually finished, and what they will do if the home does not sell. Whether the answers come with data you can check against MLS records matters far more than the promise.

You can put the four sets of questions below to any agent you interview. The questions are simple. The skill is in knowing what a good answer sounds like.

1. Which sold homes stand behind the estimate?

Make the agent list the sales behind the price, one by one — not just hand you a single figure.

A proper answer names each comparable by address or MLS number, with its sale date, sale price, layout and size, and then walks through how it differs from your home — lot, age of renovations, parking, exposure — and what dollar adjustment each difference carries, and why.

A good answer has three marks. First, it rests on homes that have actually sold; homes still listed only show what sellers hope for, not what buyers have paid. Second, the sales are close in time and place, starting in your own neighbourhood in recent months and widening only with an explanation. Third, the adjustments are consistent: one difference, one amount, applied the same way throughout.

An illustrative example, with invented figures only to show how to listen: if an agent prices your home $60,000 above a comparable sale because of a finished basement, ask what a finished basement has been worth in nearby sales, and whether another sale with a basement backs that up. An estimate that survives follow-up questions is an estimate. One that collapses was a high number offered to win the listing.

Watch this especially: if one agent's figure sits well above the others and the extra amount has no sold evidence behind it, treat that as a risk, not as luck.

2. In your area, how have their listings actually finished?

Years licensed and career totals tell you little about your home. Narrow the scope: for homes like yours, in your community, over a recent period, what was the relationship between their list prices and final sale prices? How many of those listings sold, and how many expired, were withdrawn, or came back to market with a different agent?

Learn to read these figures together, not one at a time. A sale at or above list price sounds strong, but if the strategy was to list low deliberately to draw competing offers, the real test is whether the final price holds up against the genuine sold comparables from the first set of questions — listing low and selling over asking is not the same as selling for more than market value. The other way round, a sale well below list does not automatically mean weak work; the seller may have insisted on starting high. What matters is the explanation: why was that starting price chosen, and what evidence drove any change?

With a team, add one question: are these the team's numbers or this agent's own, and who actually handles the day-to-day work after you sign — showings feedback, follow-up, negotiation? Team numbers with a different person doing the work is not necessarily a problem, but you should know it before you sign, not after.

3. When a home sits, what do they do — and what is their price-cut record?

What happens after listing day says more about an agent than anything before it. Ask directly: if showings are thin in the first few weeks, or showings happen but no offers come, what do you check first, what do you change second, and at what point do you advise me to adjust the price? A good answer separates the possible causes — price, photos and presentation, showing access, or a shifting market — and names the signals used to tell them apart, such as how many similar homes sold in that period and how your showing traffic compares. "Let's just wait" is not a plan.

Then ask about their recent price reductions: on how many of their listings did the price come down, how long had those homes been listed before the cut, and by how much each time? If an agent says they never reduce prices, read that alongside the second set of answers: did they price accurately from the start, or do their listings simply run long, with a share never selling at all? Frequent small cuts usually mean the starting price was too high and each correction was too timid; the market starts treating the home as stale, and buyers bid more cautiously, not less. A price set on evidence, adjusted once with a clear reason and a clear amount when the evidence changes, is what normal professional work looks like.

Write these answers down. If a price discussion comes after you sign, you can hold the conversation to the standards the agent set out in the interview.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The agent with the highest estimate is the most capable." No. An estimate is a question you can check on the spot: lay out the comparables, do the adjustments, and the extra amount needs sold evidence. A high price with no evidence just postpones the price cut.

"Selling above asking means it sold well." Not necessarily. An asking price can be set low on purpose. Judge the result by comparing the final sale price with genuine comparable sales, not only with a list price the agent chose.

"An agent who will not share numbers is protecting client privacy." Aggregate records — how an agent's comparable listings finished against list price, or on how many the price was reduced — do not expose any individual client's private information. The real question is whether the agent cannot produce the record, or would rather you not compare it. You can ask to look at the record together, on the spot.

If you are interviewing agents now, do these things in order

  1. Interview two or three agents, put the same questions to each, and write the answers side by side on one page. Do not choose from memory or impressions.
  2. Have each agent list the sold homes behind the estimate, with MLS numbers and the reason for each adjustment — and press both the highest and the lowest estimate on where the difference comes from.
  3. Ask how their listings for homes like yours, in your community, finished against list price, and how many did not sell at all. Do not accept success stories only.
  4. Make the "what if it sits" answer specific: which signals, how often you review them together, what triggers a price change, and how large a change — and keep the answer on file.
  5. Confirm who personally handles your listing after signing, and how often you will hear showing feedback and market updates that include new comparable sales, not just "someone came through."
  6. Talk commission and term last. Get total cost, what services are included, and the conditions for ending the agreement early, in writing, before you sign. A verbal promise is not a term.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. If you are choosing a listing agent, get these numbers first, compare them properly, and then we can go through the documents and the data item by item — no need to rush into a promise.


This article is general information only, not a promise of services or legal advice. An agent's duties, the terms of a listing agreement, and disclosure requirements are governed by Ontario law, RECO guidance, and the agreement you sign. Read every term before signing.

Primary sources: Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) consumer information guide and seller representation materials; Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $60,000 figure is illustrative only, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Is the agent with the highest estimate the most capable?

No. An estimate can be checked on the spot: lay out the comparables, do the adjustments, and the extra amount needs sold evidence — a high price with no evidence just postpones the price cut.

Does selling above asking mean the home sold well?

Not necessarily. An asking price can be set low on purpose, so judge the result by comparing the final sale price with genuine comparable sales, not only with a list price the agent chose.

Is an agent who won't share numbers just protecting client privacy?

Aggregate records — how comparable listings finished against list price, or on how many the price was reduced — do not expose any individual client's private information. The real question is whether the agent cannot produce the record or would rather you not compare it.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation