Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Why Overpricing Your Home Can End Up Costing You the Sale in Ontario

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: pricing high does not leave you room to negotiate. It spends the period when your home is easiest to sell. Buyers do not pay more because you asked for more — they go and look at other homes first, and when you cut the price later, many of them decide to wait a little longer. That is how a seller can end up accepting less than a price supported by the sold data on day one would likely have brought.

This article covers three things you can check against records, not feelings: why the early period of a listing matters most, what happens when time on market stretches out, and why a price cut so often makes a seller's position weaker, not stronger. In Ontario the seller sets the list price and confirms it in the listing agreement. Before you do, work through these three points.

1. Buyers compare you with sold prices, not with your asking price

When buyers and their agents tour homes, they are not measuring your home against your hopes. They are measuring it against similar homes nearby that have actually sold. TRREB's monthly Market Watch and MLS® Home Price Index track exactly that kind of record — sold prices, days on market, the ratio of sale price to list price, and the number of active listings — and CREA's national statistics are also built from completed sales. The market's memory is the sold price, not the asking price.

An illustrative example, with invented numbers only to show the point: suppose three similar homes on your street recently sold for $980,000, $1,000,000 and $1,020,000, your home is in mid-range condition, and you list at $1,150,000. Buyers are unlikely to think, "this seller will probably come down to $1,020,000." They are more likely to put your home at the back of the list and go see the homes priced near the sold record first. Price far above the sold range and you remove yourself from the short list at step one. Good photos and open houses only help after someone clicks and walks in.

That is why the first measuring stick for pricing is always comparable sales: same type, similar size and age, as recent as possible, adjusted item by item for floor, exposure, condition and lot — including a time adjustment, so a sale from months ago is first restated to where the market sits today rather than used at face value.

2. The longer it sits, the more buyers assume something is wrong

A newly listed home naturally receives its most concentrated attention at the start: buyer alerts fire, agents add the new listing to their showing lists, and people already searching in the area take a look. That attention is not spread evenly across the whole listing period. When the price is clearly too high, that first wave looks at the price and moves on — you have used your busiest period to prove the home is expensive.

As time passes, the problem changes character. Buyers who see a home that has sat for a long time rarely think, "the seller is patient." They think, "what is wrong with it that is not in the listing?" or "the seller must be getting close to giving in." Even if nothing is wrong with the home, buyers protect themselves: a lower offer, more conditions. Meanwhile the seller keeps carrying mortgage interest, property taxes and insurance — plus condo fees for a condominium, and maintenance and risk on a vacant home. Those holding costs accrue every day, whether or not a higher price ever arrives.

There is a further risk: if new sales in the same community close during that waiting period at prices below what you expected, your reference point gets pulled down with them. By the time you reduce to the price you could have listed at, the market may no longer be at that level.

3. After the first price cut, buyers wait for the second one

Many sellers think of a price cut as a promotion: cut once, and buyers will rush in. Buyers read the same event differently. A cut tells them the original price could not hold and the seller has started to move — so why not wait and see whether there is another cut? Instead of creating urgency, the reduction gives people who were watching a reason to keep watching.

A cut also cannot undo the first impression. Buyers who saw the home early and dismissed it as too expensive often do not reconsider it seriously when a reduction notice arrives. New buyers see a longer time on market and a reduction history before they decide whether to offer at all. A high start followed by cuts does not give you a fresh start; it gives you a listing with a history.

None of this means a price can never be adjusted. If the market moves, or showing feedback points consistently at price, adjusting early and in one step to a supportable position is better than several small steps. The mistake is treating "list high and see" as a free experiment. It is not free — the first two sections are the cost.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"List high, and after buyers negotiate down it will land exactly where I want." Buyers usually do not negotiate seriously against a price that sits well above the sold record. They buy the reasonably priced homes first. If nobody tours and nobody offers, there is no negotiation that lands where you wanted.

"I spent a lot on renovations, so that amount should be added to the price." What a renovation cost and what the market will pay extra for it are two different accounts. Buyers price from comparable sales and the home's current condition, not from the seller's receipts. Spending more does not automatically mean selling for more, and that distinction belongs in the pricing conversation, not after closing.

"List it and try — if it does not work, we will just reduce. Nothing is lost." What is lost is the concentrated early attention, your negotiating position once time on market grows, and the holding costs in between. Ending below what correct pricing on day one would have brought is a common outcome of that route, not a rare one.

Before you list, do these five things in order

  1. Start with a complete CMA: pull recent sales in the same community, adjust each one for condition, floor, exposure and time, and arrive at a supported range — instead of picking a number you want and then looking for examples that support it.
  2. Then review the active listings competing with you right now: what similar homes a buyer can tour this week are asking, and how long they have been sitting. Your price has to compete inside the buyer's real set of choices.
  3. Add up your monthly holding costs as a concrete number — mortgage interest, taxes, insurance and condo fees where they apply — and write it down. Then ask whether holding out for the higher figure is still worth several more months of that number.
  4. Set your review points and adjustment rule before you list: for example, how much showing feedback, or how long without a serious offer, triggers a fresh review against the latest sales. If you do adjust, adjust once to a supportable position rather than in small probing steps.
  5. Before the price goes into the listing agreement, confirm the remuneration, the services and the term are all clearly written. Ontario law does not set your list price — the seller decides it — but once the price is published, the market's reaction is not the seller's to decide. Be clear on that before you sign.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are working through a selling price, bring the recent sold data and we will go through the numbers and the paperwork, item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice and not a valuation of any specific home. Pricing a particular property depends on its condition, the latest sales in its community, and market conditions at the time. Confirm the details with your agent and an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: TRREB Market Watch and MLS® Home Price Index (published measures of sold prices, days on market, sale-to-list price ratios and active listings); CREA national residential statistics; RECO Information Guide and the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) on listing agreements (consulted November 2026). The $980,000, $1,000,000, $1,020,000 and $1,150,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

If I list high, will negotiation land exactly where I want?

Buyers usually do not negotiate seriously against a price that sits well above the sold record; they buy the reasonably priced homes first. If nobody tours and nobody offers, there is no negotiation that lands where you wanted.

I spent a lot on renovations, so should that amount be added to the price?

What a renovation cost and what the market will pay extra for it are two different accounts. Buyers price from comparable sales and the home's current condition, not from the seller's receipts, so spending more does not automatically mean selling for more.

Can I list it and try, then just reduce if it does not work, with nothing lost?

What is lost is the concentrated early attention, your negotiating position once time on market grows, and the holding costs in between. Ending below what correct pricing on day one would have brought is a common outcome of that route.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation