Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

What Overpricing Your Home Really Costs You

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: the most expensive pricing mistake is usually not asking too little — it is asking too much. "List high, and if it doesn't sell, we'll drop it" sounds like it leaves you room. In practice, every drop you make is public, and every extra month on the market comes with real bills. Your asking price is not a number you get to test slowly. It is the first signal your home sends the moment it hits the market — and if that signal is wrong, everything after it is repair work.

This article sticks to the main line: the routes by which an inflated price quietly makes you sell for less, and how to price so you don't pay for them.

Route one: the new-listing attention only happens once

A home gets its largest audience in the first days after it goes on MLS. Buyers with saved searches get new-listing alerts, buyer agents push fresh listings to clients who are actively looking, and everyone clicks on what just came out.

That window does not repeat. If the price sits clearly above what similar homes have actually sold for, most buyers will not even book a showing — not because they refuse to negotiate, but because they won't spend an afternoon on a home that doesn't look seriously priced. When you cut the price a few weeks later, the home is no longer new in buyers' eyes: the alerts don't go out a second time, and the people who scrolled past don't come back looking for you. You have spent your strongest burst of exposure on a price nobody was going to act on.

So the order matters. Don't list first and feel out the water temperature later. Study the comparable sales before you list, and set a price that gives buyers a reason to walk through the door. Nothing else in a sale happens until someone walks in.

Route two: sit long enough, and the listing starts talking about you

On REALTOR.ca, every listing publicly shows how long it has been on the site (Time on REALTOR.ca), and price changes are visible too. Your pricing process is not private — it is written on the listing page for everyone to read.

The longer a home sits, the more buyers and their agents start adding a layer of suspicion: if it hasn't sold, is something wrong with the house, or is the seller hard to deal with? The home may be perfectly fine, but once that thinking sets in, offers come in more cautiously and with more conditions attached. Price cuts work the same way. One decisive adjustment is repricing. A small cut every two or three weeks reads, to a buyer, as a seller giving ground step by step — so they wait, or they offer on the assumption that you will drop again.

That is what I call chasing the market down. Each cut only reaches the price buyers might have paid last month, while your own pattern of cuts has already pushed their expectations lower. Once you hand over that initiative, it is very hard to get it back.

There is one more layer sellers often miss: even if a buyer does offer at your high price, the deal may not survive. A buyer who needs a mortgage will face a lender's appraisal, and that appraisal is built on the same real comparable sales. If the appraised value comes in well below the purchase price, the loan can shrink, and the buyer must either cover the gap in cash or the transaction runs into trouble. A price with no sold evidence behind it may not even clear the "we got lucky and found a buyer" stage.

Route three: every extra month is real money out the door

The first two routes cost you opportunity. This one costs cash. Until the home sells, the mortgage interest (if any), property taxes, insurance, utilities and condo fees (if any) keep running. If you staged the home, the furniture rental is billed by the month. If you have already bought your next home and the closing dates don't line up, you may be looking at bridge financing or an extension on top of everything else.

Here is an illustrative example — I invented these numbers to show the arithmetic, nothing more. A home an agent values at about $980,000 is listed at $1,099,000 because the seller wants to "try." Showings in the first month are thin. The price drops to $1,029,000 and it sits for another month and more. Only after a cut to $985,000 does an offer arrive, and it settles at $950,000. Compared with pricing at market from the start, roughly $30,000 is gone from the sale price alone. Add the extra two-plus months of carrying costs — say about $4,500 a month in interest, taxes, insurance and utilities — and that is another $10,000 or so. That is before counting two months of keeping the house showing-ready at all hours.

Notice that nothing dramatic happened in this example. No failed inspection, no collapsed deal. The price was simply set too high, and time and money leaked out together.

Common misunderstandings

"Ask high — buyers will just negotiate down." Negotiation requires a buyer in the room first. When the price is out of line, most buyers don't negotiate; they go and see the next home. The "negotiating room" you built in mostly turns into weeks of silence.

"My home is better than my neighbour's, so it should be priced much higher." A better home can absolutely sell for more — but the premium needs evidence: what was renovated and what it cost, lot size, exposure, real differences in layout, each one matched against actual sales. Buyers, their agents, and the lender's appraiser all work from evidence, not from a feeling. A premium you can't explain is a premium the market won't pay.

"If it doesn't sell, we just drop the price — no real harm done." A price drop is not shameful, but as noted above, days on market and price-change history are publicly displayed. The longer it drags on, the heavier the "stale listing" impression, and the bigger the cut you need later to buy back the same amount of attention. The harm is real; it just arrives in a different form.

Before you list, work through this checklist

  1. Have your agent pull recent, real sold prices for the same community and home type, and look at where each one differs from yours. Asking prices are wishes; sold prices are the market.
  2. List your home's pluses and minuses against those sales — renovation, lot, exposure, layout, age — and for each one ask: how much more would a buyer actually pay for this, and is there a sale that proves it?
  3. Write down your monthly carrying cost: interest, taxes, insurance, utilities, condo fees, staging rental. Know exactly what one extra month on the market costs you.
  4. Set the list price, and set a review point at the same time. If showings and feedback in the first week or two are clearly below what the price assumes, don't dig in — make one decisive adjustment to a defensible level instead of a series of small cuts.
  5. If you genuinely are in no rush and want to test a higher price, keep the test small, and decide in advance what signal will end the test and when.
  6. When an offer comes in, judge it as price plus total time and total cost — not as one number measured against your original asking price.

In the end, pricing is not a tug-of-war with buyers. It is an honest quote to the market. Price it honestly and buyers come quickly — and, somewhat counterintuitively, you negotiate from strength. Price it on hope, and time will do the buyers' negotiating for them, and send you several months of bills for the service.

Honest work, done properly, is the whole of my approach — and on pricing I would rather spend two extra days with you studying the sales before we list than spend two months walking the price down after we do. — Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information about pricing a home for sale. It is not legal or financial advice; for a specific transaction, consult a licensed brokerage, a lawyer and an accountant.

Primary sources checked: listing pages on REALTOR.ca (operated by the Canadian Real Estate Association, CREA), which publicly display "Time on REALTOR.ca" and price changes; and bulletins published by the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) on registrant duties and advertising. All sale prices and costs in the worked example are the author's illustrative figures, not market statistics.

Frequently asked questions

Ask high — will buyers just negotiate down?

Negotiation requires a buyer in the room first. When the price is out of line, most buyers don't negotiate; they go and see the next home. The negotiating room you left mostly becomes time with no showings.

My home is better than my neighbour's, so should it be priced much higher?

A better home can absolutely sell for more — but the premium needs evidence: what was renovated and what it cost, lot size, exposure, real differences in layout, each one matched against actual sales. Buyers, their agents, and the lender's appraiser all work from evidence, not from a feeling.

If it doesn't sell, we just drop the price — no real harm done?

A price drop is not shameful, but days on market and price-change history are publicly displayed. The longer it drags on, the heavier the stale listing impression, and the bigger the cut you need later to buy back the same amount of attention.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation