Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

What Sellers Should Actually Look for in an Agent: Not the Highest Price Quote

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: when a sale is over, sellers rarely judge their agent by the last few dollars on the price. What they remember is how the process felt — whether anyone returned their calls, whether anyone told them the truth about price, and whether the things they were promised actually got done. So when you interview agents, don't pick the one who quotes you the highest number. Test three things instead: communication, pricing honesty, and follow-through. All three can be checked before you sign anything.

1. Communication you never have to chase

The hardest part of selling is not waiting for a buyer. It is waiting for news. Three days after listing, with no word from the agent, a seller has no idea whether nobody came, people came and disliked the home, or the agent simply isn't pushing it. That silence is what destroys trust.

Good communication is not fancy. It comes down to three habits. First, a fixed rhythm: an update on a set day each week that covers how many showings there were, what buyers said, and what the agent plans to do next — not one answer dragged out of the agent per question from you. Second, bad news delivered straight: if viewers say the kitchen is dated or the price is high, you hear that feedback as it came in, together with the agent's recommendation — fix it, adjust the price, or hold for another week. An agent who reports only good news is asking you to make decisions blindfolded. Third, callbacks at the promised time. Sellers don't need an agent who is online around the clock; they need the promised time to actually be kept.

Ask it directly in the interview: after we list, how often will you update me, and what will the update include? What will you do when showing feedback is negative? An agent who answers with a specific, regular routine is usually dependable. One who only says "don't worry, call me anytime" deserves a second look.

One small step helps a lot: pin the communication terms down before you sign. Which channel — text, phone, or email? Which day is the regular update? If an offer comes in, how quickly will you hear about it? These sound like details, but over a long listing period it is exactly these pre-agreed rules that carry you — not the seller chasing for news every time. Whether an agent is willing to settle these points before signing is itself a preview of how they work.

2. Honest pricing, with the evidence on the table

The most common trap in agent interviews is picking whoever quotes the highest price. Some agents inflate the number to win the listing agreement, then spend the following weeks talking you down. A home that sits on the market too long starts to look like a problem listing to buyers, and it often ends up selling for less than it would have at an honest price.

Judge an agent's pricing by what they show you, not what they say. A responsible agent lays out the recent actual sales nearby, one by one — which street, what type of home, what it sold for, how long it took — then compares each one to your home: size, age, renovations, lot. The result should be a recommended range with reasoning, not a single round number pulled from the air. They should also spell out the trade-offs: what an ambitious price risks, what a sharper price risks, and then leave the final call to you.

An illustrative example, with numbers I made up just to show the question to ask: Agent A says "your home will sell for $1.3M" but can't explain why. Agent B puts three recent sales on the table — $1.12M, $1.15M, $1.18M — compares them point by point, recommends listing at $1.16M, and explains why not $1.25M. You don't need me to tell you which one to hire. Under Ontario's Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22), administered by RECO, agents must act honestly and protect their client's best interests — on pricing, telling the truth is not a personality trait, it is a professional obligation.

Ask one more question: "If we get no serious offer in the first two or three weeks, what is your next step?" An honest agent sets out the adjustment plan before you sign: what showing volume would trigger a rethink, which feedback patterns matter, and in which week the price gets reassessed. An agent with no plan — just "we'll see how it goes" — is often the same one who quotes high to win the contract and then wears you down afterwards. Pricing honesty is not only about the first number; it is about whether the agent will put "what if it doesn't sell" on the table in advance.

3. Follow-through, from listing day to closing day

The third thing is follow-through: promised work actually getting done. The photography, staging, advertising, and open houses promised before signing — are they delivered after signing? Once an offer arrives, is someone walking you through negotiation, condition deadlines, lawyer's paperwork, and key handover ahead of time, instead of you having to ask what happens next?

Pay special attention to the stretch between an accepted offer and closing day. Signing the contract does not finish the job: the buyer's inspection, financing approval, and condition removals all run on deadlines, and on your side there are lawyer's documents to prepare, utility accounts to deal with, movers and final cleaning to arrange. A good agent hands you a timeline in advance — what happens on which date — and reminds you as each date approaches. A poor one disappears after the signatures and is more passive than you are when a deadline looms. However good the price, weak follow-through in this stretch makes the whole experience a bad one.

Follow-through can also be tested before you sign. Ask the agent for one or two past clients as references — RECO itself suggests asking for references and calling them to hear about their experience. Ask the agent to walk you through their process from listing to closing, step by step, and who handles each step. An agent who can describe a clear process usually runs one. An agent whose whole pitch is "I have lots of experience and connections" is offering nothing you can verify.

Two basic checks round this out. Every agent in Ontario must be registered with RECO, and RECO's Public Register lets you look up an agent's registration status and any disciplinary history — do not skip this step no matter how well the interview goes. And RECO recommends interviewing at least three agents before deciding. It also requires the agent to give you the RECO Information Guide and explain it before providing any services; an agent who never hands you that guide is telling you something about how carefully they do the rest.

Common misunderstandings

"Whoever quotes the highest price must be the best agent." A quote is just words; the market sets the sale price. Inflating the quote to win the contract and then pressing for reductions is the oldest play in the book. Judge the evidence, not the size of the number.

"The lowest commission is the best deal." There is no official commission rate in Ontario. RECO states plainly that commissions are not fixed or approved by RECO, any government authority, or any real estate association — they are negotiated between you and the brokerage. So compare what the fee buys, not just the percentage: photography, staging, advertising, open houses, negotiation, and follow-up — which of these are actually written into the contract? Comparing rates without comparing services can save you a fraction of a percent and cost you a full price reduction.

"The agent with the most ads and the biggest name is the safest choice." A big advertising presence only proves a big marketing budget. Who personally runs your listing, how often they report to you, and what their pricing is based on — that is what shapes your experience. Big brokerages have agents who don't return calls; small teams have agents who track every listing closely. Judge the person, not the brand.

Rank the three and the picture is simple: communication is what you feel every day, pricing decides what you end up with, and follow-through decides how much of the worrying lands on you. If any one of the three clearly fails, most sellers will not use that agent again or recommend them — even if the price turned out fine. When all three are solid, sellers usually accept even a result the market made difficult, because the whole way through they could see what the agent was doing and why.

Interviewing agents: ask in this order

  1. Start with RECO's Public Register: confirm each candidate's registration status and disciplinary record before you book interviews.
  2. Interview at least three agents, and ask each of them the same set of questions so you can compare answers side by side: pricing evidence, communication rhythm, service list, commission structure.
  3. On pricing, make the agent put the recent comparable sales on the table and explain the differences one by one. A total with no evidence behind it loses marks.
  4. Pin down the reporting rhythm: how often after listing, what the update includes, how showing feedback reaches you, and how bad news is handled.
  5. Get the service list into the contract: photography, staging, advertising, open houses — only services written into the seller representation agreement are actually promised.
  6. On commission, clarify the total, the portion offered to a buyer's brokerage, and how taxes apply — all of it in the written agreement. Verbal promises don't count.
  7. Ask for one or two past seller clients as references and call them yourself: Did the agent reply quickly? Was the pricing accurate? Did they do what they said they would?
  8. Before signing, read the term and expiry date carefully. RECO also notes you can have a lawyer who practises real estate law review anything you are unsure about.

Honest dealing and solid work — that is how I do this job. I am Ming Ren. If you are choosing a listing agent, put each candidate's pricing evidence and service list side by side, and we can go through them against these three tests, one by one.


This article is general information, not legal advice. An agent's professional obligations and your contract terms are governed by current Ontario law and the agreement you sign; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting if you have questions.

Primary sources: RECO, RECO Information Guide, and RECO's seller guidance "How do I choose a real estate agent as a seller?" (reco.on.ca, checked November 2026); Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and its Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22), Ontario e-Laws. The $1.12M–$1.3M figures above are an illustrative example I invented, not real sales.

Frequently asked questions

Must whoever quotes the highest price be the best agent?

No. A quote is just words; the market sets the sale price. Inflating the quote to win the contract and then pressing for reductions is the oldest play in the book, so judge the evidence, not the size of the number.

Is the lowest commission the best deal?

Not necessarily. There is no official commission rate in Ontario; commissions are negotiated between you and the brokerage. Compare what the fee buys — photography, staging, advertising, open houses, negotiation and follow-up — not just the percentage.

Is the agent with the most ads and the biggest name the safest choice?

No. A big advertising presence only proves a big marketing budget. Who personally runs your listing, how often they report to you, and what their pricing is based on is what shapes your experience, so judge the person, not the brand.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation