I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: when a title search on a commercial purchase turns up an old restriction, do not panic, and do not ignore it either. The right sequence has only three steps — confirm what it actually restricts, count how many years it has been registered, and only then discuss whether it can be removed. Many alarming old covenants, once you run them through section 119 of Ontario's Land Titles Act, are already deemed to have expired. For the ones still alive, negotiation comes before court, and that order saves money.
1. What does it actually restrict? Keep it separate from zoning and from leases
A restrictive covenant is a private restriction registered against land. It runs with the land, not with a person: you never signed it, but buy the parcel and you are bound anyway. Section 119(10) of the Land Titles Act says it plainly — a condition or restriction registered as annexed to land binds anyone who later becomes the registered owner, as if that person had entered into the covenant personally.
On commercial parcels, the restrictions usually fall into four groups:
| Type | Typical wording | Practical effect |
|---|---|---|
| Use | No specified business, or one permitted use only | The shop or operation you plan may breach the covenant from day one |
| Signage and appearance | Limits on sign size, placement, or building façade | Visibility and alteration room for a street-front business are squeezed |
| Exclusivity | Protects a business on neighbouring land; no competing use on this parcel | Your leasing list is cut down before you start, and the tenant pool shrinks |
| Building form | No building, or limits on height, type, or density | Additions, alterations, and redevelopment plans must clear this gate first |
Two distinctions matter. First, a covenant is not zoning: zoning is municipal public-law regulation, changed through the municipal process; a title covenant is a private restriction, removed by agreement or by a court. The two routes do not substitute for each other. Second, a covenant is not an exclusivity clause in a lease: a lease term binds only the landlord and tenant who signed it and dies with the lease, while a title covenant binds every successive owner of the land. Look at which document the restriction sits in, and whether it binds land or a person, before you spend money.
One more layer: being on the register is not the same as being enforceable. Section 119(6) states that registration itself does not make a covenant run with the land if, by its nature or wording, it would not otherwise do so. Whether both the burden and the benefit truly attach to the land, and whether the benefited land is ascertainable from the instrument, are case-specific legal questions for a lawyer reading the original registered documents.
Here is an illustrative example I have invented, with figures used only to show the sequence: suppose you are looking at a street-front parcel for a retail store with an automotive service component, and your lawyer finds a covenant registered in 1982, with no expiry date stated, barring automotive-related uses. Count the years first: 1982 plus 40 is 2022, so under section 119(9) that covenant is already deemed to have expired, and the next step is asking the land registrar to delete it — not rushing to renegotiate the price or walking away from the parcel. Get the year wrong, and everything after it is wrong.
2. How long does it bind? Look first for a fixed date
Section 119 of the Land Titles Act provides two time-based exits:
- No period or date fixed for expiry: forty years after registration, the condition, restriction, or covenant is deemed to have expired, and the land registrar may delete it from the register (s.119(9)). In Andrews v. Rago, the Ontario Superior Court confirmed that writing "forever" does not fix an expiry date, so such a covenant still falls under the 40-year rule — on Ontario title, "forever" often means forty years.
- A fixed period that has expired: ten years after that period ends, the registrar may remove the entry (s.119(8)).
Read the other direction too: if a covenant states a clear expiry date that has not yet arrived — say, a stated 60-year term — it does not fall under the 40-year deemed-expiry rule and remains in force within its term. Do not treat "40 years" as the universal lifespan of every covenant. Read whether the instrument fixes a date first, then apply the subsection that matches.
One boundary: these two rules operate under the Land Titles system. Most Ontario land has been converted to Land Titles, but a small amount remains under the older Registry system, and the rules cannot simply be carried across. Which system governs your parcel appears on the parcel register — do not skip that step on an assumption.
3. Still in force? The routes to removal, in order
From least to most burdensome, there are usually three routes:
First, a negotiated release. Find who the covenant was created to protect — the owner of the benefited land — reach agreement, have that party sign a release or discharge, and register it against title. Whether the beneficiary is an individual, a company, or an entity that no longer exists changes the difficulty completely, and there is no standard price. It is usually the cheapest route.
Second, a court order under section 119(5) of the Land Titles Act. A condition or covenant may be modified or discharged by court order on proof that the modification will be beneficial to the persons principally interested in its enforcement. That is a real threshold, not a test of whether the covenant inconveniences you.
Third, an application to the Superior Court of Justice under section 61(1) of the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act to modify or discharge the covenant. Courts exercise this power with caution; in practice an applicant generally must show the covenant is spent, or so obsolete as to be of no value, that insisting on it would be clearly unreasonable. An order may be appealed to the Divisional Court (s.61(2)). Note the hard boundary in s.61(3): a building restriction imposed by a zoning by-law cannot be discharged under this section — that goes back to the municipal zoning process.
Which route fits depends on whether the beneficiary can be found, how many years the covenant has left, and how directly it collides with your intended use. That is not a broker's call. Have a real estate lawyer give a written opinion on your parcel's registered instruments, then choose.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"This restriction is decades old, so it must be dead by now." Not necessarily. Whether it has expired depends on whether it fixes an expiry date and how long it has been registered. A covenant with a long stated fixed term may be fully alive decades later; one with no date still needs the full 40 years to be deemed expired. Count each one. Do not guess.
"Zoning allows my use, so the line on title does not matter." Wrong. Zoning and a title covenant are two independent gates: municipal permission does not release a private covenant, and discharging a covenant does not amend the zoning. Your use has to pass both gates, or it does not land.
"It says 'forever,' so it can never be removed." No. Under Andrews v. Rago, "forever" fixes no expiry date, so a covenant with no stated date still falls under the 40-year rule; and even before expiry, a negotiated release and a court application remain available. The word "forever" frightens more than it binds.
If you are buying commercial land, do these things in order
- During your conditional period, have your lawyer pull the parcel register and list every restrictive covenant separately: what it restricts, when it was registered, and whether it fixes an expiry date. Miss none of them.
- Count the years first: for a covenant with no fixed date that has been registered 40 years, look at deletion by the registrar under s.119(9); for a fixed period that expired more than 10 years ago, look at s.119(8).
- For a covenant still in force, identify the benefited land and whether the beneficiary still exists, and assess a negotiated release — its feasibility and cost — before turning to a court application.
- Run the title covenant check and the zoning check separately: counsel on title, counsel or a planning consultant on zoning. Have both answers before you decide whether to proceed.
- Do not waive your due diligence condition before title is clear. A covenant found before closing is the cheapest version of the problem; after closing, your leverage on price and exit is largely gone.
- If your development or business plan collides directly with a covenant, put the lawyer's written opinion, the removal route, and its time and cost into your offer and your budget before you sign — not after.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. The most expensive mistake on commercial land is often not the old restriction itself, but the fact that nobody spent ten minutes counting its years. Get the sequence right, and then we can talk price.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Whether a particular restrictive covenant is enforceable against a particular parcel, and which removal route applies, depend on the registered instrument and the facts. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Land Titles Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.5, s.119(5), (6), (8), (9), (10); Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.34, s.61 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); Andrews v. Rago, 2019 ONSC 800. The 1982 automotive-use covenant above is an illustrative example, not a real transaction.


