Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

The Asking Price Is Not the Sale Price: Lowballing, Anchoring High, and Pricing Right in Ontario

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: an asking price is never the sale price. It is simply the first signal you send the market. Send it straight, and the right buyers walk in. Send it crooked — deliberately low or deliberately high — and in the end it is usually the seller who pays for it. After all these years, I have found only one approach that holds up: work out what the home is genuinely worth first, then price close to that value. And one more thing up front: pricing is strategy, but statements have to be true. Those are two different things.

1. Pricing low is a bet that enough buyers show up at the same time

Underpricing means listing well below what comparable sales support, setting a common offer date, and hoping buyers bid each other up. Using illustrative numbers only: a home worth roughly $850,000 on recent comparable sales, listed at $799,000, looks like a bargain, and showings will indeed pick up.

But the tactic stands on one condition: on offer night, several groups of buyers must actually be willing to bid against each other. If only one or two offers arrive, the picture flips — buyers know perfectly well it is a traffic price, they offer close to the ask, and you have just built a low ceiling over your own home. There is a second cost that is easy to miss: experienced buyer agents spot a traffic price at a glance, and many will steer their clients away from it, or advise offering at true value and refusing to run in the auction. The most serious buyers — the very people you wanted — leave first. Whoever remains, if they are inexperienced or not properly pre-approved, may produce an exciting offer night and a shaky closing.

So underpricing is not forbidden territory, but it needs evidence behind it: buyers must genuinely be competing for this type of home in this neighbourhood right now, and your agent should be able to prove that demand with recent sales and active listings. No data, just "price it low and it will take off" — that is not a strategy. That is a gamble, and the stake is your home.

2. Pricing high: the anchor never lands, because the buyers were filtered out first

Anchoring high is the opposite idea: post a big number first, so that whatever buyers negotiate off it feels like a win. Same illustrative example: the home worth roughly $850,000, listed at $949,000 to leave so-called negotiating room.

The problem is that an anchor only works on a buyer who sees the home, walks in, and makes an offer. Buyers today search online by budget first. Someone working with a budget around $850,000 sets their search ceiling in that range, and a $949,000 listing never enters their results at all. Fewer showings mean fewer offers; the longer a home sits, the more buyers wonder what is wrong with it, and the days-on-market figure itself becomes a mark against you. When you finally start cutting, every cut is public, and buyers read it as room to push further. After the long way around, the home often closes for less than it would have if it had been priced right on day one.

One line has to be stated clearly here: where you set the price is strategy; false statements are a violation. Section 37 of Ontario's Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 prohibits a registrant from making false, misleading or deceptive statements in any advertisement relating to trading in real estate. Section 5 of the Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22) requires a registrant to make best efforts to ensure representations are accurate and not misleading, and not to engage in or be a party to misrepresentation. The asking price itself is the seller's number, and setting it high or low is a pricing decision. But inventing an offer that does not exist, exaggerating the home's condition, or putting statements in the advertising that do not match the facts — that crosses the line.

3. Pricing right: no mind games, just the value, stated plainly

The third approach is the least flashy: calculate the value from recent, genuinely comparable sales in the same community — same type, similar condition — and set the asking price close to that value, adjusting only modestly and only where the evidence supports it. Priced this way, the home lands inside your target buyers' search range the moment it lists. Showings concentrate, feedback is honest, and if the home truly is in demand, multiple offers form on their own. That kind of competition is carried by real demand, and those buyers' conditions and ability to close tend to be more solid.

Pricing right also keeps you in control of the negotiation. A defensible price gives you the footing to refuse unreasonable lowballing. And if the market's response differs from expectations, you hold real information — showing counts and buyer-agent feedback — and can decide whether to adjust, instead of being dragged through a series of reactive cuts by an inflated anchor.

One more detail is worth stating on its own: pricing does not end on listing day. The showing volume and buyer feedback in the first week or two are the market's first honest report card. If that report card contradicts the assumptions behind your price, adjusting promptly on the evidence is far wiser than defending a number the market has already rejected. Adjustments need evidence too — cutting a little today and a little more tomorrow, on emotion, only teaches buyers to keep waiting for your next cut.

Buyers today can pull up sold records as easily as anyone. If your price lines up with recent sales, buyer agents will bring their clients through seriously. If it does not, no amount of polished wording will carry it for more than a few weeks.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Price it low and the bidding will surely push it past market value." Not necessarily. A low price only brings people through the door. Whether the price climbs depends on how many real buyers are there that night. With only one or two offers, the low number is not a starting point — it is the ceiling.

"Pricing high costs nothing; we can always reduce later." It costs twice. The high price first filters you out of your target buyers' search results, and every later reduction publicly tells buyers you could not hold your number. The longer the home sits, the weaker your position at the table.

"Pricing is all psychology, so the truth of the statements doesn't matter." Wrong. The room for strategy exists only at the level of how the price is set. Representations must be true. Fabricated offers, exaggerated conditions, and advertising that does not match the facts are matters for TRESA and the Code of Ethics in Ontario — not salesmanship.

If you are about to list, do these five things in order

  1. Have your agent lay out recent sales of the same type in the same community, compared home by home on condition, and settle on a market-value range you accept — before anyone talks about an asking price.
  2. If your agent suggests underpricing, ask the follow-up: what happens if only one or two offers come in? Agree on the answer before listing day, not on offer night.
  3. If your agent suggests anchoring high, ask which buyers' search ranges that price puts you in, and which buyers it shuts out. Test it with search logic, not with "leaving room to negotiate."
  4. After launch, watch two signals: showing volume and buyer-agent feedback. If serious feedback is not coming, look at the price and the presentation first instead of sitting and hoping.
  5. Hold one line throughout: the price is negotiable, the statements are not. Refuse any suggestion that involves inventing an offer or overstating the facts.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are unsure how to price your home, bring out the recent sales first — we will go through the numbers one by one, and then decide how the price should be set.

Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information only, not advice on any individual listing or brokerage matter. Your community's market conditions, your home's specific condition, and your timing will all affect the right pricing conclusion. Review the latest comparable sales with your own brokerage before acting.

Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c.30, Sched. C, s.37; O. Reg. 365/22 (Code of Ethics), s.5 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $850,000, $799,000 and $949,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real listing or transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Price it low and the bidding will surely push it past market value?

Not necessarily. A low price only brings people through the door; whether bidding pushes past market value depends on how many real buyers show up that day. With only one or two offers, the low price is a ceiling, not a starting point.

Does pricing high cost nothing since we can always reduce later?

It costs twice. The high price first filters you out of your target buyers' search results, and every later reduction publicly tells buyers you could not hold your number. The longer the home sits, the weaker your negotiating position.

Pricing is all psychology, so does the truth of the statements not matter?

Wrong. The room for strategy exists only at the level of how the price is set; statements must be true. Fabricated offers, exaggerated terms and advertising that does not match the facts are TRESA and code-of-ethics matters in Ontario, not tactics.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation