Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Fake Offers Don't Work in Ontario: The Rules on Phantom Bids and Competing Offers

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the conclusion first, in plain terms: inventing a competing offer that does not exist, or inflating the price or terms of a real one to pressure a buyer, does not work in Ontario — and it is not worth trying. The law states it very directly: if there is no written offer on paper, a registrant cannot tell anyone that a written offer exists. And when competition is real, the rules actually hand the seller legal tools: the number of offers must be reported, and how much of their content gets shared is the seller's written choice. Real pressure is built from real things. A fabricated number falls apart, and the cost lands on your own side.

The first red line: no written offer, no claim of one

Ontario's current law is the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA), which fully replaced the old Act on December 1, 2023. Section 35.1(1) is clear: no registrant shall represent to any person that a written offer to purchase real estate exists except if the offer is in writing. In other words, a verbal conversation, an offer "being prepared," or one that is "about to come in" is not an offer — and none of those can be used to tell a buyer "we already have several offers."

Two more provisions in the same Act close the side doors. Section 34 prohibits a registrant from falsifying information or documents relating to a trade. Section 35 prohibits furnishing, assisting in furnishing, or counselling anyone else to furnish false or deceptive information or documents. The Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22) adds its own layer: section 1 requires honesty, good faith and integrity toward every person a registrant deals with; section 4 prohibits engaging in or being a party to fraud; and section 5 requires best efforts to ensure representations are accurate and not misleading, and prohibits taking part in misrepresentation. Inventing an offer, or exaggerating the terms of a real one, breaches several of these at once.

There is also a verification mechanism many people do not know about. A brokerage acting for a seller must retain copies of all written offers it receives, in accordance with the regulations. Under section 35.1(3), a person who has made a written offer — or a registrant acting for them — may ask the registrar to inquire of the seller's brokerage how many written offers it has actually received, and the registrar will disclose that number to the person who asked. So "how many offers are there, really?" is a question with an official channel for an answer. An invented number does not survive that check.

When competition is real, here is what the rules require

The detailed competing-offer rules sit in section 22.7 of O. Reg. 567/05, and RECO's Bulletin No. 4.1, "Number and content of competing offers," explains the same ground. Three points matter:

First, the number must be reported, and it is not optional. Once the seller's brokerage receives a competing written offer, it must communicate the number of competing written offers to every person who is making one of the offers. The seller cannot direct the brokerage to hide the count or report a smaller one.

Second, how much content is shared is the seller's decision. Before December 1, 2023, the content of competing offers generally could not be disclosed. Now a seller may direct their brokerage to share the substance of the competing written offers with every person making one of the offers. The seller may also direct that only parts be shared — the price but not the closing date, for example, or certain clauses only. Without the seller's direction, the brokerage may not disclose content on its own.

Third, a buyer's identity is never shared. Whatever content is shared must not include any personal information of the person making the offer, or anything else that would identify them. There is no exception to this one.

An illustrative example, with numbers I made up just to show how it works: suppose there are three written offers on offer night, and the seller has directed that only the top price be shared. Every offeror is then told "there are three offers, and the current top price is an illustrative $980,000" — but not who made that offer, how large the deposit is, or what conditions it carries. If the seller gave no direction to share content, the one fact each offeror is entitled to is the total: three offers. The rules really are that simple. Follow them and the pressure is genuine; work around them and the pressure is fabricated.

What happens when it is proven

Under section 21 of TRESA, the discipline committee hears and determines whether a registrant has contravened the Act or the regulations. If it finds a contravention, it can order additional education, apply conditions to a registration, suspend or revoke a registration, and impose a fine — up to $50,000 for an individual broker or salesperson, and up to $100,000 for a brokerage. Discipline decisions are made available to the public.

Let me put it plainly: to squeeze out a little more on price by inventing an offer, what is being wagered is the agent's registration and the seller's own credibility. And in practice, once a buyer starts to suspect the numbers do not add up, the most common outcome is not a higher bid — it is the buyer walking away, and you may lose the real offer along with the fake one. The arithmetic never works. If you want the price to go up, the honest levers are pricing, listing timing, and a well-run offer presentation date — all out in the open. The checklist below sets them out.

Common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: "We only hinted at competition — we never actually said an offer exists, so it's fine." It is not fine. Section 5 of the Code of Ethics covers more than literal falsehoods; it covers representations that are misleading. Hinting in a way that leads a buyer to believe a written offer exists when none does is still misrepresentation. And section 35.1 draws the line at the substance: if it is not in writing, it cannot be represented as existing. Changing the wording does not get around it.

Misunderstanding 2: "The seller can tell the agent to say 'several offers' without giving the exact number." No. Disclosure of the number is mandatory. Section 22.7 requires the brokerage to communicate the actual number of competing written offers to every person making one of them, and the seller has no power to direct the brokerage to withhold it. What the seller controls is how much of the content is shared — not whether the count is reported.

Misunderstanding 3: "If the seller chooses open sharing, buyers get to know who they are up against and see everything." They do not. Only the parts the seller directed to be shared are disclosed, and identifying information is never included. Buyers may learn price or term information — not the other side's identity or their full hand.

A checklist for sellers and buyers

  1. Sellers: settle the offer process with your agent before listing — the presentation date, whether pre-emptive offers will be considered, and how much content you would share if competition appears. Decide in advance, and give clear direction when content is to be shared.
  2. Sellers: create competition only with real tools — sensible pricing, concentrated showing activity, and a clear offer presentation date. If an agent suggests inventing an offer to "apply some pressure," refuse on the spot and seriously consider changing agents.
  3. Buyers: when you hear "there are multiple offers," confirm what is being counted — written offers actually received. Once you have submitted a written offer, you are entitled to be told the number of competing written offers.
  4. Buyers: ask whether the seller has directed that offer content be shared. If they have, you should receive the parts covered by that direction from the seller's brokerage. Not receiving anyone's identity is normal — do not treat that as concealment.
  5. Buyers: if you have a genuine reason to doubt the count, you or your registrant can request a registrar's inquiry into the number of written offers under section 35.1 of TRESA, or raise the matter through RECO's complaints process.
  6. Both sides: keep the communications about offer numbers and shared content in writing where you can. If a dispute ever arises, records that line up are worth more than anyone's memory.

Honest work, done properly, is what lasts. I am Ming Ren — competition in a sale should be built in the open: get the pricing and the process right, and real offers will do the work that no invented number ever could.

— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information, not legal advice. The form of a seller's direction, the scope of disclosure and the timeline in a specific transaction can affect the outcome; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c. 30, Sched. C, ss.21, 34, 35, 35.1; O. Reg. 567/05 (General), ss.22.7, 22.8; O. Reg. 365/22 (Code of Ethics), ss.1, 4, 5 (all read on Ontario e-Laws, November 2026); RECO Bulletin No. 4.1, "Number and content of competing offers." The three offers and $980,000 figure are an illustrative example, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Is it fine to only hint at competition without actually saying an offer exists?

It is not fine. Section 5 of the Code of Ethics covers representations that are misleading, and section 35.1 draws the line at substance: if it is not in writing, it cannot be represented as existing.

Can the seller tell the agent to say several offers without giving the exact number?

No. Disclosure of the number is mandatory under section 22.7, which requires the brokerage to communicate the actual number of competing written offers to every person making one of them; the seller controls how much of the content is shared, not whether the count is reported.

If the seller chooses open sharing, do buyers learn who they are up against and see everything?

They do not. Only the parts the seller directed to be shared are disclosed, and identifying information is never included; buyers may learn price or term information, not the other side's identity or full hand.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation