I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the conclusion first: the biggest number on an offer sheet is only half of the deal. The other half is whether that offer can actually get to the closing day. Once its conditions have been dealt with, an accepted offer is a binding contract. But before that point, the size of the deposit, the number of conditions, and whether the closing date fits your plans are the variables that decide where the risk sits. Choosing an offer is not choosing a number. It is choosing a person who can carry a contract to the end.
This article covers three things: the types of buyers you will usually meet and the one extra question to ask each type; the three things that really matter beyond price; and how to compare two offers side by side, item by item.
1. Know who you are dealing with: the usual types of buyers
No type of buyer is good or bad in itself. The only question is whether they fit your home and your timetable. They roughly divide like this:
| Type | What they usually look like | The one extra question a seller should ask |
|---|---|---|
| Owner-occupier whose financing is still in progress | They love the home, but the lender has not given final confirmation | How far has the pre-approval gone, and how long a condition period do they need |
| Owner-occupier who is well prepared | Paperwork in order, decisions made quickly, a clear moving plan | Can their closing date line up with your next home |
| Buyer who must sell first | Their money is tied up in their current home | Is that home listed yet, and is it priced realistically |
| Investor buyer | They run rent and return numbers and fuss less about the home itself | Is the decision based on a single number, and what would make them change their mind |
| Cash or low-borrowing buyer | They need to borrow little, so the process is relatively simple | Can they show proof of funds, and how much deposit will they put down |
Sorting buyers this way is not labelling people. It is a reminder that each type carries risk in a different place. For an owner-occupier, the risk is usually at the financing step. For a buyer who must sell first, the risk is whether their home sells. For an investor, the risk is that the assumptions behind their arithmetic change and they change their mind with them. Know which box the risk sits in first, and you will negotiate conditions far more accurately.
One more point that is often overlooked: whether the buyer's agent replies promptly and writes clean paperwork also affects how smoothly a deal runs. It is not decisive, but sloppy documents and vaguely written conditions usually mean every later step takes extra time to confirm.
2. Beyond price, these are the three things that really count
First, the deposit. The deposit is money the buyer puts down up front, and it is part of what walking away will cost them. Treat a high-priced offer with a very small deposit that is slow to arrive with extra caution. Look at three things: the amount, when it will be delivered, and where it will be held. All three belong in the contract, not in a verbal promise.
Second, the conditions. Common conditions cover financing, a home inspection, and the buyer selling their own property first. Every condition is an exit through which the contract can be ended for a period of time. Conditions are not bad things — they protect the buyer and give the deal an orderly structure. The questions are how many there are, how long they run, and who confirms, against what standard, that they have been satisfied. At the same price, the offer with fewer conditions, shorter periods, and clearer wording leaves you carrying uncertainty for less time.
Third, the closing date. A closing date is not just any day picked off a calendar. If you have not yet bought your next home, or your purchase closes later, a gap of a few weeks can turn into temporary accommodation or two loans that do not line up. A buyer willing to fit the closing date around your arrangements is giving you something of real value — sometimes worth more than a slightly higher price. The reverse is also true: if a buyer insists on a date you simply cannot meet, no price makes that offer workable.
Here is an example I made up, with illustrative numbers only and not a real transaction: Offer A is higher than Offer B by some amount, but A carries a long financing condition and a small deposit. B is a little lower, but has no financing condition, its deposit arrives on time, and its closing date lines up exactly with your next home. Once you count what it would cost you if A fell away during its condition period — extra weeks back on the market and the price ground you might give up — B's real value may be no lower than A's. A seller should count the number that actually lands, and can land, not the biggest number on offer night.
3. Two offers side by side: compare them this way
Do not choose on a feeling, and do not rely on a verbal summary. Break every offer down into the same table: price, deposit amount and delivery time, each condition and its deadline, closing date, and any extras the buyer is asking for, such as furniture left behind or extra visits. Laid out in one table, the strengths and weaknesses of each offer are plain to see.
If the highest offer loses on only one variable, do not eliminate it too quickly. You can counter back on that one point: ask for a shorter condition period, a larger deposit, or a closing date moved into a range you can accept. If they agree, you have the offer that is both high and solid. If they do not, you have learned where their limit is, and you can choose the steadier offer with your eyes open.
Keep a fallback as well. While you and your first-choice buyer have not yet dealt with the conditions, do not close the door too firmly on the offer in second place. Markets move quickly. If the first deal cannot be completed and the second is still there, you do not have to start again from zero with a fresh listing. That is not playing two sides; it is ordinary risk management in a sale, and exactly how to handle it should be worked out with your agent and your lawyer.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"If I do not pick the highest price, I am losing money." No. Price is one clause of a contract, not the whole contract. If a high price cannot be exchanged for a certain closing, you may be the one who loses: the home goes back on the market, its days on market grow, and the next round of buyers will ask why the last deal did not close.
"An offer with no conditions cannot possibly go wrong." No. Having no conditions only removes a few lawful exits. It does not guarantee the buyer will have the money on closing day. The deposit, the funding arrangements, and the other side's record of completing deals still need the same scrutiny. Reading "firm" as "zero risk" is its own kind of carelessness.
"The bigger the deposit, the better — the more the merrier." Not on size alone, either. A deposit has to be read together with the price, the delivery time, and what the contract says about how the deposit is handled. A deposit arrangement that is not written clearly can be hard to explain in a dispute, however large the amount. The number matters; having it written down in black and white matters more.
On the day you actually have to choose, do these things in order
- Have your agent put every offer into the same comparison format — price, deposit, conditions, deadlines, closing date, nothing left out — rather than relying on a verbal report.
- Ask each type of buyer the one key question for their type: how far the financing has gone, whether the home they must sell is listed, whether proof of funds can be shown.
- Pick out the high offer that loses on only one variable, and try countering on that variable first. If that fails, fall back to the steadier offer.
- Check the deposit amount, delivery time, and holding arrangements against the contract word by word. Do not accept "roughly" or "should be fine" as an answer.
- Through the condition period, watch every deadline: when it expires, who confirms it, and what the confirmation document looks like. Plan this with your agent in advance, not the day before a deadline.
- Questions such as whether a condition can be removed, or how a deposit dispute is handled, belong in front of your Ontario real estate lawyer. An agent's experience is not a substitute for legal advice.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are weighing offers on a home you are selling, bring the comparison table for all of them, and we will go through price, deposit, conditions and closing date one by one — no decisions on gut feeling.
— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The wording of each offer, its conditions, and the facts of an individual case can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before signing.
Primary sources: the general structure of the OREA Agreement of Purchase and Sale (Form 100) commonly used in Ontario, and RECO's general guidance on offers, conditions and deposits (this article makes general statements only and cites no specific statistics; consulted November 2026). Offers A and B above use illustrative numbers only and are not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
If I do not pick the highest price, am I losing money?
No. Price is one clause of a contract, not the whole contract. If a high price cannot be exchanged for a certain closing, the home may go back on the market and the next round of buyers will ask why the last deal did not close.
Can an offer with no conditions possibly go wrong?
Yes. Having no conditions only removes a few lawful exits; it does not guarantee the buyer will have the money on closing day. The deposit, funding arrangements and the other side's record still need the same scrutiny.
Is a bigger deposit always better?
Not on size alone. A deposit has to be read together with the price, the delivery time, and what the contract says about how the deposit is handled; an unclear arrangement can be hard to explain in a dispute however large the amount.


