I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: when a deal dies, whether commission is owed has no one-line answer. It turns on two things — who caused the deal to fail, and what the commission clause in your own listing agreement actually says. If the seller defaulted and refused to complete, the standard wording says commission is payable, in so many words. If the buyer defaulted and walked away, the standard form contains no matching sentence at all, and a brokerage trying to collect faces a much harder road.
The trap is timing: most sellers never read that clause when they sign the listing. They read it for the first time when the invoice arrives after the deal has already collapsed.
First: commission is a contract question — go back to what you signed
No regulator sets commission in Ontario. Under section 36 of the Trust in Real Estate Services Act (TRESA) and RECO's published consumer guidance, commission is whatever you and the brokerage agree to in the contract — a fixed amount, a percentage of the sale price, or a combination. RECO, the government, and real estate associations do not set or approve the rate.
So the answer to "do I owe commission on a deal that never closed?" lives in your own listing agreement. Ontario's standard listing agreement (OREA Form 200), clause 2, is structured like this:
| Situation | How the standard wording (Form 200, clause 2) treats it |
|---|---|
| The transaction completes | Commission is payable as agreed, plus taxes |
| The transaction is not completed because of the seller's default or neglect | Commission is still payable, on the date set for completion |
| The transaction is not completed because the buyer defaulted | Clause 2 contains no matching express wording — collectability falls back on contract interpretation and case law |
| The buyer paid a deposit | On a completed transaction, the deposit is applied first to reduce the commission; the seller pays any shortfall |
Notice the structure. The only failed-deal scenario the standard form expressly writes into the contract is the seller's own default: if your own conduct killed the deal, you cannot leave the brokerage unpaid. Buyer default is a different matter, and the form does not write a sentence covering it for the brokerage.
Second: when the buyer defaults, the Supreme Court decided this forty years ago
The leading case is the Supreme Court of Canada's 1986 decision in Liebig (H.W. Liebig Co. v. Leading Investments Ltd., [1986] 1 S.C.R. 70). The skeleton of the facts is simple: the brokerage produced a buyer, an agreement was signed, the buyer then refused to close and abandoned the deposit, and the brokerage claimed its commission from the seller.
The majority held that "sale" in that listing agreement, in its ordinary meaning, meant a completed sale. The buyer had defaulted, no completed sale had occurred, so the event on which commission depended never happened: the seller owed no commission, and the deposit went to the seller. The Court also made a point sellers should remember: a vendor hires an agent to sell a property, not to end up in a lawsuit. Unless the contract contains clear and unequivocal wording — brought to the seller's attention — saying commission is payable even on a buyer's default, "the agent found a buyer" is not enough to treat the fee as earned.
Put the two pieces together and the rule is clear:
- Seller defaults: the standard clause expressly makes commission payable. There is little room to argue.
- Buyer defaults: the standard form is silent, and under Liebig's approach commission generally is not payable — unless your agreement or a schedule to it contains a clear special term saying otherwise.
- The parties sign a mutual release: when a deal ends by negotiated release, deal with commission inside that negotiation. Do not assume "everyone walked away, so nothing is owed," and do not assume the opposite either.
Third: the deposit is not the brokerage's money to take
One more point that gets confused constantly: the defaulting buyer's deposit. A deposit is trust money held under the agreement of purchase and sale. It is not brokerage revenue. Who keeps it, and whether any of it can be applied to commission, follows the wording of the agreements and how the parties (or a court) resolve the default. A brokerage cannot simply help itself to the deposit and call the commission settled. Even Form 200's deposit language assumes a completed transaction and a commission that is actually payable. When the deposit and the claimed commission do not match, or fault is disputed, that is the moment a real estate lawyer has to be involved — it is not settled by a phone call between agents.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The house never sold, so obviously no commission is owed." Wrong. If you, the seller, changed your mind or refused to complete, the standard clause says commission is payable anyway, on the date that was set for completion. A brokerage that pursues it has the contract on its side.
"The agent found a buyer, so the commission was earned." That imports an idea from other jurisdictions into Canada. Liebig rejected exactly that assumption: producing a buyer is not the same as completing a sale, and the words of the contract govern.
"The buyer ran, so just take the commission out of the deposit — it evens out." The deposit and the commission are two separate accounts. The deposit is about the buyer's breach; the commission is about the seller's contract with the brokerage. Whether one can offset the other depends on the documents and the outcome, not on mental arithmetic.
If your deal is falling apart, do these things in order
- Find the listing agreement you signed and read the commission clause — plus every schedule that touches commission — word by word.
- Pin down why the deal failed: who defaulted, was a condition unfulfilled, did both sides sign a release? Each answer leads to a different conclusion.
- If a commission invoice arrives, neither pay it nor refuse it on the spot. Send the agreement and the invoice to your real estate lawyer for an opinion against the actual wording.
- While the deposit sits in trust, nobody should push the brokerage to "just take its share now." Move trust money only after liability and amounts are settled.
- Before you sign your next listing, treat the commission clause as required reading: what happens on a failed closing, and how long the holdover period runs, are both negotiable at signing — not after.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Reading the commission clause before you sign costs ten minutes; sorting it out after a deal collapses costs a great deal more.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The version of the agreement you signed, any schedule amendments, and who actually defaulted in your case will affect the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: OREA Form 200 Listing Agreement, clause 2 (commission); H.W. Liebig Co. v. Leading Investments Ltd., [1986] 1 S.C.R. 70 (Supreme Court of Canada); Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, s.36, and RECO consumer guidance (consulted November 2026).
Frequently asked questions
The house never sold, so is no commission owed?
No. If the seller changed their mind or refused to complete, the standard clause says commission is payable anyway, on the date that was set for completion, and a brokerage that pursues it has the contract on its side.
The agent found a buyer, so was the commission earned?
No. The Supreme Court's Liebig decision rejected that assumption: producing a buyer is not the same as completing a sale, and the words of the contract govern.
Can the seller just take the commission out of the buyer's deposit?
No. The deposit and the commission are two separate accounts: the deposit concerns the buyer's breach, while the commission concerns the seller's contract with the brokerage, and any offset depends on the documents and the outcome.


