I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion: on an older commercial or industrial redevelopment, the cost most often missing from the budget is not digging or trucking. It is the regulatory machinery that attaches the moment soil leaves the site. Ontario's O. Reg. 406/19 defines soil excavated and moved off the project area as 'excess soil,' and until it qualifies for reuse it sits, by default, in the waste side of the framework. How much of that machinery applies to you turns on three questions about your site.
First: what was this site used for before?
The regulation defines an 'enhanced investigation project area': a project area that was ever used for an industrial use, a garage, a bulk liquid dispensing facility (which includes a gas station), or the operation of dry-cleaning equipment. A history in that list can trigger the filing rule in section 8 on its own — before volume is even considered.
There is a carve-out where the site already has a record of site condition, no outstanding risk-assessment issue, and has not resumed that use since. For a buyer of older land the working rule is direct: research past uses at the feasibility stage — prior planning records, directories and tenancy history — and treat a former garage or fuel site as a different cost animal from day one.
Second: how much soil leaves, and where does the site sit?
The second trigger pairs volume with location. Under section 8(1.1), a project is generally caught where any part of the project area is within an 'area of settlement' in the Planning Act sense and the excess soil removed is 2,000 cubic metres or more. The same paragraph excepts project areas used wholly for residential, institutional, parkland or agricultural purposes as defined in O. Reg. 153/04.
Read together: a commercial or industrial redevelopment inside an urban boundary hauling out 2,000 m³ or more generally lands inside the rule, and a separate branch addresses excavation to remediate contamination. At the small end, the regulation's schedules list situations where the filing rule does not apply, including removals of 100 m³ or less. These are thresholds, not estimates — get the expected volume calculated to threshold accuracy at feasibility, not after working drawings.
Third: where does the soil finally go?
The regime lands on destination: soil must go to a place permitted to receive it, its quality must match the receiving site's use and standards, hauling and handover must be documented, and projects caught by the filing rule must complete the prescribed registry filings before work begins, with project-leader responsibilities for assessment and tracking. Verify a receiver's eligibility and acceptable quality before the earthworks contract is signed, and write the division of duties — who tests, who files, who keeps the tracking records — into that contract.
One scoping point prevents a lot of confusion: the removal machinery targets soil that leaves the project area. Soil excavated and reused within the same project area is not excess soil. So the first draft of every earthworks plan should maximize on-site balance — every cubic metre reused in place is testing, filing and hauling cost avoided. Answer history, volume-and-location, and destination, and the 'earthworks' line in the pro forma finally reflects obligations, not just trucking.
Three common misunderstandings
Myth 1: "Soil is soil — digging it out is the contractor's problem." Soil that leaves the site is a defined, regulated object: testing, destination, records and possible filing duties travel with it.
Myth 2: "Our volume is small, so we are automatically fine." Past use is an independent trigger. A former industrial, garage, gas-station or dry-cleaning site can be caught on history alone.
Myth 3: "Soil reused on site needs the full filing treatment too." Excess soil is defined by leaving the project area. On-site reuse is outside the removal machinery — plan for on-site balance first.
If this landed on your desk today, work through it in this order
- Research the site's history at the viewing stage: any industrial, garage, bulk-liquid (gas station) or dry-cleaning use, in writing.
- Have a consultant estimate removal volumes early and test them against the 2,000 m³ threshold and the 100 m³ small-removal situations.
- Confirm whether the site is within an area of settlement and whether the whole-use exception (residential, institutional, parkland, agricultural) applies.
- Fix the receiving site before earthworks: verify its eligibility and quality standards, and assign testing, filing and tracking duties in the contract.
- Design for on-site balance first: soil reused within the project area is not excess soil.
- If a record of site condition exists, verify its status and later uses to see whether the history trigger is carved out.
I'm Ming Ren. If you are facing a commercial real estate question like this one, bring the documents first — we will go through them clause by clause, number by number.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. The documents, timing and facts of a specific transaction affect the answer; consult an Ontario lawyer or accountant before acting.
Primary sources: O. Reg. 406/19, On-Site and Excess Soil Management, under the Environmental Protection Act, Ontario e-Laws (note: live web search for this item returned a rate-limit error during production; regulation text as cited in source research) (reviewed November 2026). Any specific dollar figures used as examples were invented by the author to illustrate a method and are not real transactions.


