I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion: section 142 of Ontario's Municipal Act, 2001 does not itself require anyone to get a permit. It authorizes a municipality to pass a by-law that does. So there is no province-wide answer to 'do I need a site alteration permit?' — the answer lives in the by-law of the municipality where your land sits. Read that first, then schedule the earthworks.
First: the statute gives municipalities three activities to regulate
Section 142(2) is a short toolbox. A local municipality may prohibit or regulate the placing or dumping of fill, the removal of topsoil, and the alteration of the grade of land. On top of those three, it may require a permit for any of them and attach conditions, including an acceptable plan for grading, filling, topsoil removal and site rehabilitation.
One definition deserves a pause: 'topsoil' in section 142(1) is not the loose idea of dirt on top. It means the O and A horizons of a soil profile — the layers containing organic material — and expressly includes deposits of partially decomposed organic matter such as peat. 'Fill,' by contrast, is not defined in the section at all; each by-law defines it for itself. The local wording is the wording that governs you.
Second: an enabling power is not a by-law — check what your municipality actually did
Because section 142 only authorizes, three situations exist on the ground: a municipality may have no site alteration by-law at all; it may regulate only some of the three activities; and in a two-tier structure a lower-tier may, with the upper tier's agreement, delegate the power upward. The same earthworks can face different rules across a municipal boundary.
The working habit is always the same: pull the current local by-law and test your project against it item by item — coverage, thresholds, required drawings, conditions. An invented example: clearing topsoil and then regrading one site sounds like a single job, but under a by-law it can be two separately regulated activities, and a permit application that covers only one invites a stop-work conversation later.
Third: some earthworks sit outside the by-law entirely
Section 142(5) lists exemptions. The one that matters most commercially is the planning seam: fill, topsoil removal or grade alteration carried out after December 31, 2002 as a condition of a site plan (Planning Act s.41), a plan of subdivision (s.51) or a consent (s.53), or as a requirement of the related agreements, is outside the site alteration by-law. The approval channel the work travels under decides which rulebook applies.
The list also covers the municipality's own activities and certain transmitter/distributor work, and topsoil removal has an agricultural exception — incidental to normal farming practice, but not removal for sale. Work in this order: exemptions first, coverage second, permit application last. Reversing the order wastes weeks on permits nobody required, or starts work that needed one.
Three common misunderstandings
Myth 1: "Section 142 requires a permit before moving dirt." Section 142 lets a municipality require a permit; it does not impose one itself. The local by-law decides.
Myth 2: "Topsoil is just the surface layer, so stripping it is minor." The statute defines topsoil by soil horizons (O and A, including peat). Ordinary-looking excavation can be regulated topsoil removal.
Myth 3: "With site plan approval, I automatically need a site alteration permit too." The opposite: work done as a condition or requirement of site plan, subdivision or consent approvals is exempted by section 142(5). Confirm which channel your work is under.
If this landed on your desk today, work through it in this order
- Pull the current site alteration by-law for the municipality where the land sits; do not rely on the statute or a neighbouring municipality's rules.
- Break the work into fill, topsoil removal and grade alteration, and test each against the by-law's coverage and thresholds.
- Check exemptions first — especially work required by site plan, subdivision or consent approvals under section 142(5).
- Confirm whether a two-tier delegation applies, so you are reading the right level's by-law.
- Prepare the application as the by-law requires: grading, filling, topsoil and rehabilitation plans in one package.
- Put permit timing into the construction schedule, and do not mobilize earthworks before the requirement is confirmed.
I'm Ming Ren. If you are facing a commercial real estate question like this one, bring the documents first — we will go through them clause by clause, number by number.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. The documents, timing and facts of a specific transaction affect the answer; consult an Ontario lawyer or accountant before acting.
Primary sources: Municipal Act, 2001, S.O. 2001, c. 25, s.142, Ontario e-Laws (reviewed November 2026). Any specific dollar figures used as examples were invented by the author to illustrate a method and are not real transactions.


