Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Law & Policy

Someone Slipped on the Sidewalk in Front of Your House. Is That Your Bill?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Law & Policy · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion: the sidewalk in front of your house usually belongs to the city, but two different sets of rules sit on you at the same time, and they should not be merged. One is the municipal snow-clearing bylaw: in Toronto, within 12 hours after snow, rain or hail stops, you must clear the sidewalk in front of, alongside and at the rear of your building. That duty is owed to the City, and breaching it can bring a fine. The other set of rules decides who pays an injured person. Repair responsibility for the sidewalk itself rests with the municipality, and for snow or ice injuries the municipality is liable only for gross negligence, with the claimant required to give written notice within 10 days. Whether a homeowner also pays the injured person cannot be decided from shovelling alone; it depends on the facts. But the safety of your own yard, steps and driveway is squarely your responsibility as an occupier.

First: divide the ground into three parts; the responsibility differs

When I show homes, I often divide the ground in front of a house into three parts. The first is your own land: the front walk, the porch steps and your driveway. Section 3 of the Occupiers' Liability Act applies there: an occupier must take the care that is reasonable in all the circumstances to see that people entering the premises are reasonably safe. Icy steps left untreated, or a driveway packed down into sheet ice, point back at you. For snow and ice claims, note also the 60-day written notice rule in section 6.1 of that Act. It is the injured person's deadline, but it tells homeowners something too: these matters move quickly, so preserve the scene early.

The second part is the municipal sidewalk. Its repair duty rests with the municipality: section 44 of the Municipal Act, 2001 elsewhere in Ontario, and section 42 of the City of Toronto Act, 2006 in Toronto, both built on keeping highways in a reasonable state of repair. Snow and ice sit in an exception lane: for personal injury caused by snow or ice on a sidewalk, the municipality is liable only in case of gross negligence. Ordinary imperfect clearing does not reach that threshold.

The third part is easily missed: where the City has taken on mechanical sidewalk clearing under its own policy, the City clears that sidewalk itself, and Chapter 719 of Toronto's Municipal Code says the owner's clearing duty does not apply at those locations. Whether your address is covered must be confirmed with the City, not guessed.

Second: two clocks — the claimant's 10 days, and your 12 hours

Start with the deadline for suing the municipality. Under section 44(10) of the Municipal Act (and the parallel Toronto provision), a person injured by a highway in disrepair must give written notice of the claim and injury to the municipal clerk within 10 days, delivered personally or by registered mail. There are exceptions: the rule does not apply where the person died, and a judge may excuse late notice where there was a reasonable excuse and the municipality was not prejudiced. That clock binds the claimant, not you, but it explains why cities and insurers move fast after a fall — and why a homeowner may receive questions quickly too. Memories and photographs are worth most when they are fresh.

Then your own clock. Chapter 719 requires every owner or occupant of a building to clear away and completely remove snow and ice from sidewalks on a public highway in front of, alongside or at the rear of the building within 12 hours after any fall of snow, rain or hail has ceased. On a corner lot or a lot flanked by two streets, the long side stretch counts as well; do not clear only the few steps at the front door. This duty is owed to the City and enforced through provincial offences. Keep the two tracks separate: a fine for late clearing and compensation for an injured pedestrian are different proceedings with different tests. One does not automatically equal the other.

An illustrative example of my own, to show the division of labour: a homeowner clears the front before leaving in the morning but leaves the flanking side stretch untouched, and three days later someone slips on ice there. The City can pursue the bylaw failure for the side stretch. A claim against the City must pass the 10-day notice rule and the gross negligence threshold. Whether the injured person also has a claim against the homeowner, and whether it succeeds, is for a lawyer to assess on the evidence. What you control is clearing all three parts and recording when you did it.

Third: practical steps before and after an incident

Before anything happens, the core habit is documented clearing. After snow stops, deal promptly with the front, side and rear stretches, and salt low spots and eaves-drip lines that refreeze. If you hire the work out, keep the contract and each service record. In the spirit of section 6 of the Occupiers' Liability Act, when work is entrusted to an independent contractor, whether you reasonably chose a competent contractor and took steps to be satisfied the work was properly done can matter to liability. Do not rely on a voice message alone; keep contracts, invoices and service dates.

If someone does fall near your home, do not panic, and do not rush to admit or argue fault. First check whether the person needs medical help and call emergency services if needed. Then photograph the scene: which stretch of sidewalk, the snow and ice condition, when you last cleared, and save the weather record as well. If a letter arrives from the injured person, a lawyer, the City or an insurer, notify your own home insurer promptly and have a lawyer review it before you write a long explanatory reply. These cases are decided on contemporaneous evidence, not on who tells the better story afterwards.

Common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding one: "The sidewalk is city land, so a fall there can never involve me." Too absolute. Repair liability for the municipal sidewalk is not yours, but you carry a bylaw clearing duty that can be fined, and your own steps, driveway and walkways are within your occupier's responsibility.

Misunderstanding two: "I cleared late, so if someone fell, I automatically pay." That does not follow directly. A bylaw fine is City enforcement; civil compensation is assessed separately on the evidence and the law, including the gross negligence standard and 10-day notice on the municipal side. Do not concede liability yourself; hand it to your insurer and a lawyer.

Misunderstanding three: "The City's machines clear the sidewalk, so I need do nothing." It depends on the address. Streets the City has taken over are excepted, but coverage follows City policy. Assuming you are covered without confirming it risks a fine that lands on you.

If your home fronts a sidewalk, I suggest this order

  1. Confirm with the City whether sidewalk clearing at your address has been taken over by the City. If not, work to the 12-hour rule, counting the corner side stretch as well.
  2. Clear snow and ice and apply salt promptly after each event, note the date and time in your phone, and keep contracts and service records if you hire the work out.
  3. Watch repeat freeze points — eaves drip, and the ridge pushed back at the driveway mouth by plows — and deal with those first.
  4. If someone falls, help first, then photograph and record the time and weather. Do not make statements about fault on the spot.
  5. On receiving any claim, inquiry or lawyer's letter, notify your home insurer at once and consult a lawyer; do not reply with a long letter of your own.

I am Ming Ren. A winter home is not just about how the front looks. Clearing snow properly and keeping a simple record is a small habit that can spare you a very large problem.


This article is general information, not legal advice. Liability in an individual case depends on the location, the evidence and the timeline. If you have received a claim, consult an Ontario lawyer promptly and notify your insurer.

Primary sources: Occupiers' Liability Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.2, ss.3, 6 and 6.1; Municipal Act, 2001, s.44; City of Toronto Act, 2006, s.42; City of Toronto Municipal Code Chapter 719, Snow and Ice Removal (reviewed November 2026). The flanking-sidewalk example is illustrative only, not a real case.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation