Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Law & Policy

Your Dog Bit Someone at Home: How Ontario Sets the Owner's Liability

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Law & Policy · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, Broker at RE/MAX Realtron.

The short answer: in Ontario, whether you pay after a dog bite turns first on whether you are an "owner" under the Dog Owners' Liability Act — not on whether the dog was gentle before, and not on whether you were careless. Section 2 puts liability directly on the owner, and the injured person does not have to prove you knew the dog might bite. The one statutory factor that can reduce an award is the injured person's own fault. Money is only one track: a court can also make orders about the dog itself, from leashing, muzzling and confinement on your own property up to destruction, and pit bulls are governed by a separate, stricter ban. Here is the order in which a homeowner should think about it.

1. Who counts as an owner, and why liability is strict

Section 1 defines "owner" inclusively: it includes a person who possesses or harbours the dog, and where the owner is a minor, the person responsible for the minor's custody. An owner is therefore not necessarily the person who bought or registered the dog, and there can be more than one. Under section 2(2), where there is more than one owner, they are jointly and severally liable — the injured person can claim the full amount from any one of them.

Section 2(1) is the source of liability: the owner is liable for damages resulting from a bite or attack by the dog on another person or a domestic animal. The protected side includes other people's pets, not only people. Section 2(3) is the key sentence in the Act: the owner's liability does not depend upon knowledge of the dog's propensity, or on fault or negligence on the owner's part. That is strict liability — "it never bit anyone before," "it is normally gentle," and "it was on a leash" do not make liability disappear.

The same subsection contains the reduction: the court shall reduce the damages awarded in proportion to the degree to which the plaintiff's own fault or negligence caused or contributed to the damages. An illustrative example only (not a statistic and not a case): if a court assessed total damages at $12,000 (illustrative figure) and found the injured person one-quarter at fault, the award would be reduced proportionately to $9,000 (illustrative figure). Under section 2(4), an owner who has paid can also recover contribution and indemnity from any other person whose fault or negligence contributed, in proportion to that fault.

One detail matters specifically to homeowners. Under section 3(1), where the bite or attack happens on the owner's own premises, liability is determined under this Act and not under the Occupiers' Liability Act. A visitor or a tradesperson bitten in your yard is therefore dealt with under this strict-liability scheme. Section 3(2) adds an exception: a person who is on the premises intending to commit, or in the commission of, a criminal act has no claim under section 2 — unless keeping the dog on the premises for the protection of persons or property was unreasonable.

2. Beyond money: orders a court can make about the dog and the owner

Section 5.1 sets a standing duty for every owner: exercise reasonable precautions to prevent the dog from biting or attacking a person or domestic animal, or behaving in a manner that poses a menace to their safety. It is easy to overlook day to day, and it is one of the things a court looks at after an incident.

Section 4 is a separate proceeding, distinct from a civil claim for money. It may be started in the Ontario Court of Justice against an owner where it is alleged that the dog has bitten or attacked a person or domestic animal, that the dog's behaviour poses a menace to safety, or that the owner failed to exercise reasonable precautions. Part IX of the Provincial Offences Act applies, and findings of fact are made on the balance of probabilities (s.4(1.2), (1.3)). While the proceeding is under way, the court can make an interim order requiring specified measures for more effective control of the dog.

If the court finds a bite, attack or menace and is satisfied an order is necessary for the protection of the public, section 4(3) gives two directions: an order that the dog be destroyed in the manner specified, or an order that the owner take specified measures for more effective control or public safety. Examples in section 4(4) include confining the dog to its owner's property, restraining it by leash or by muzzle, and posting warning signs. In deciding, the court may consider the circumstances listed in section 4(6), including the dog's past and present temperament and behaviour, the seriousness of the injuries, unusual contributing circumstances, the improbability of a repeat attack, the dog's physical potential for inflicting harm, and precautions the owner has taken to prevent a repeat. A dog under a control order under s.4(3)(b) must also be neutered or spayed within 30 days of the order, or within a different period the court specifies (s.4(7)). Under section 5, the court may also prohibit the owner from owning another dog for a specified period.

Seizure is a third layer. Under section 13, a justice of the peace who is satisfied there are reasonable grounds may issue a warrant authorizing a peace officer to enter a building, including a dwelling house, to search for and seize the dog. Section 14 addresses exigent circumstances where obtaining a warrant is impracticable, section 15 allows seizure in a public place in the statutory circumstances, and section 17 requires a seized dog to be promptly delivered to a pound operated by or on behalf of a municipality, Ontario or a designated body. Penalties are in section 18: an individual who contravenes the Act, the regulations or a court order is liable on conviction to a fine of not more than $10,000 or imprisonment for not more than six months, or both; a corporation faces a fine of not more than $60,000; and the court may also order compensation or restitution.

3. Pit bulls: a separate ban with narrow exceptions

Section 6 is the ban itself: except as permitted by the Act or the regulations, no person shall own, breed or transfer a pit bull, abandon a pit bull other than to a pound operated by or on behalf of a municipality, Ontario or a designated body, allow a pit bull in their possession to stray, import a pit bull into Ontario, or train a pit bull for fighting. Section 1 defines "pit bull" both by listed breeds and by a dog whose appearance and physical characteristics are substantially similar to those breeds.

The exceptions sit mainly in sections 7 and 8. A "restricted pit bull" under section 7 is a pit bull owned by a resident of Ontario on the day the ban provisions came into force — August 29, 2005 — or born in Ontario within 90 days after that day. A restricted pit bull may continue to be owned, but the owner must comply with the requirements the Act and regulations set for restricted pit bulls. Section 8 covers pounds and registered research facilities holding non-restricted pit bulls for their statutory purposes. Section 9 permits transfer of a restricted pit bull by gift or bequest, subject to numerical limits — check the section itself for the details.

Two consequences are harsher in a section 4 proceeding. If the court finds the dog is a pit bull and that it has bitten, attacked or behaved as a menace, section 4(8) requires the court to order destruction — there is no control-measures option. And under section 4(10), where it is alleged the dog is a pit bull, the onus of proving it is not a pit bull lies on the owner. Finally, section 11 provides that where this Act and a municipal by-law conflict on pit bull controls, the most restrictive provision prevails, so checking the provincial Act alone is not enough — check your own city's by-law too.

Common misunderstandings

"My dog never bit anyone before, so a first bite doesn't count." It does. Section 2(3) makes liability independent of knowledge of the dog's propensity and of the owner's fault; a clean history is not a condition of liability.

"It happened in my own yard, so it follows the visitor-injury rules." No. Section 3(1) says liability for a bite on the owner's premises is determined under this Act, not the Occupiers' Liability Act.

"Once I pay, the matter is over." Not necessarily. A civil claim and a section 4 proceeding about the dog are two tracks; paying does not by itself stop a destruction or control order, and vice versa.

"I was only minding a friend's dog for a few days, so it has nothing to do with me." Do not assume that. Section 1 includes a person who possesses or harbours the dog within "owner"; whether a given arrangement qualifies is for a court on the facts.

"The pit bull ban is ancient history." It is not. The section 6 ban remains in the current text, and the restricted pit bull exception is still anchored to August 29, 2005 — check before buying a home or moving a dog into Ontario.

Action checklist

  1. When visitors, tradespeople or delivery drivers are expected, put the dog in a closed room or secured enclosure first — the most direct form of the reasonable precautions section 5.1 requires.
  2. Inspect gates, side doors and fencing regularly and keep a record; the precautions an owner has taken are among the circumstances section 4(6) lists.
  3. Be clear about who in the household actually possesses and looks after the dog — there may be more than one owner, and liability is joint and several.
  4. Before buying, adopting or bringing a dog into Ontario from elsewhere, confirm whether it falls within the pit bull definition and check the municipal by-law; on a conflict, the more restrictive rule prevails.
  5. If a bite happens, get the person medical help, report it, and preserve the scene record, medical documents and witnesses' contact details rather than relying on an apology alone.
  6. If you receive court papers or a seizure notice, see an Ontario lawyer promptly — the proceeding about the dog and the civil claim must each be answered.
  7. Whether home or tenant insurance covers dog-bite liability depends on the personal liability terms of your own policy; confirm with your insurer instead of assuming.

Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


General information only, not legal advice. Who counts as an owner, fault proportions and damage amounts depend on the facts of each case. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Dog Owners' Liability Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. D.16, ss.1-18 (Ontario e-Laws, checked November 2026).

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation