I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The conclusion first: not necessarily. When a buyer and seller in Ontario cannot agree on a title requisition, a claim for compensation, or another specific question arising from their contract, section 3(1) of the Vendors and Purchasers Act gives either side a direct route: apply to the Superior Court of Justice and ask the court to make the order it considers just on that one question. That is not the same as starting a full action — an application asks a judge to decide a defined question, while an action litigates the whole dispute. But the route has one hard boundary written into it: a question affecting the existence or validity of the contract itself is outside its scope.
1. What this application route can decide
Section 3(1) breaks into four points. Who: a vendor or purchaser of a real or leasehold estate, or their representative — both sides qualify; it is not a buyer-only tool. When: at any time, and from time to time, so a new requisition arising as a transaction progresses is not barred by a "one application only" limit. What: any requisition or objection, any claim for compensation, and any other question arising out of or connected with the contract. The court's power: to make such order on the application as it considers just.
What does this look like in practice? The buyer's lawyer, within the requisition period, objects — for example, to an old undischarged encumbrance on title, or a break in the title chain — and requires the seller to deal with it before closing; the seller takes the position that the objection is unfounded or that the contract does not oblige them to fix it. Or the parties disagree on whether compensation is owed, and how much. These are "the contract is valid, but its performance is stuck" disputes — exactly what section 3 exists for. If instead the fight is over whether a contract was ever formed or is valid at all, that crosses the exclusion, and the route must be chosen differently, with a lawyer's advice on the proper proceeding.
2. Before applying, run the requisition process correctly
A court application is the exit from a deadlock, not the first step. The normal sequence: the buyer completes title investigation before the contract's requisition date and delivers objections in writing, on time; the seller responds, resolving what can be resolved and explaining the basis for what cannot or will not be accepted. Why does this matter? Because whether an objection was made on time and in the proper way itself affects the parties' rights — an objection raised after the deadline may be one the seller has no obligation to answer at all. The title-search clause and deadlines in the standard OREA agreement of purchase and sale are the working rules for this step, read together with the Act.
In my experience, most requisition deadlocks are stuck on facts and documents, not law — whether an old registration was ever discharged, whether a document exists. Have both lawyers put the documents on the table and exchange positions in writing, and many disputes loosen at that stage. What should reach a section 3 application is what remains after the documents are complete and the positions are clear. Narrowing the dispute to one question a judge can answer is what makes the application efficient.
3. After the order, there is an appeal level
Under section 3(2), an appeal lies to the Divisional Court from an order made under section 3. The route is therefore not one-level-final: the Superior Court of Justice decides the specific question first, and a dissatisfied party can take it one level up. For the parties, that means two practical considerations. First, an application is more focused than a full action, but it still takes time and money, and an appeal is possible — whether to bring one, and whether it is worth it, is a calculation your lawyer should make against the amount in dispute and the closing timeline. Second, while the question is being decided, the closing date, the deposit, and any agreement to extend must be dealt with in parallel; do not stare at the application while the transaction itself develops a problem in the waiting period.
A final point of orientation: the Vendors and Purchasers Act is a short statute, and section 3 is its core mechanism, but it does not replace the contract. The deadlines, notice methods, and obligations written into your agreement remain the first measure of whether each step was done properly; what the Act adds is a statutory doorway to a court's answer when performance of the contract gets stuck.
Add one more layer, from the cost side, to help you judge whether this route is worth taking. A section 3 application is more focused than a full action, but it is still a formal court proceeding: application materials and evidence must be prepared, there will be a hearing, the other side will respond, and the judge may deal with who bears the costs as part of the order. So before deciding to apply, have your lawyer run three calculations. First, what the dispute itself is worth — for example, the repair cost or compensation amount the requisition actually involves. Second, the application's expected cost and time, including the risk of bearing the other side's costs if you lose. Third, the transaction-level price of waiting — interest, insurance, and carrying costs during any closing delay, and the state of the relationship between the parties. Very often, laying those three numbers on the table is what produces a settlement before any application is filed: the seller agrees to deal with a requisition they had refused, the buyer accepts reasonable compensation, and the application never needs to be brought. In other words, section 3's value lies not only in the order itself but in the clear fallback it gives both sides in negotiation — knowing the deadlock has an exit makes it easier for the talks to return to numbers and documents.
Three common misunderstandings
"If we cannot agree on title, the only options are suing or walking away." No. Section 3(1) lets either side apply directly to the court for a decision on the specific requisition, compensation claim, or contract question, without litigating the entire dispute as a full action — and abandoning the transaction is not the first option.
"Any contract dispute can be brought under this application." No. Questions affecting the existence or validity of the contract are expressly excluded. Have your lawyer determine which side of that line your dispute falls on before choosing the proceeding.
"A requisition can be raised whenever — the court application will sort it out." No. Requisitions must be made in writing by the requisition date in the contract; a late objection may be one the seller need not answer. A court application cannot repair a step already lost on procedure.
Action checklist
- The buyer's lawyer should complete the title investigation within the contract's requisition period, deliver every objection in writing and on time, and keep proof of delivery.
- The seller should respond to each objection in writing: for those that can be resolved, give the fix and the timing; for those that cannot, state the basis — do not stall verbally.
- Both sides should put the relevant registrations and correspondence on the table and narrow the dispute to one defined question before assessing a court application.
- Once it is confirmed the dispute does not touch the contract's existence or validity, have your lawyer apply under section 3(1) to the Superior Court of Justice, and settle the closing and deposit arrangements for the waiting period in parallel.
- If the order goes against you, note the appeal route in section 3(2) to the Divisional Court and its timing, and have your lawyer calculate the deadlines immediately.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. When a transaction sticks, get the documents and the deadlines right first, then talk about whether the court route is needed — in the right order, many deadlocks never reach an application at all.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Requisition deadlines and application strategy depend on your contract wording and case facts. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary source: Vendors and Purchasers Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. V.2, s.3 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026).


