I am Ming Ren, Broker at RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain answer first: I will not give you a single number at our first meeting and tell you that is what your home is worth. An honest answer is never one point. It is a range supported by real sales, plus a clear statement of what we should list at and why. Market value, asking price, and assessed value are three different things, and this question is only answered once those three are separated.
Most sellers already have a number in mind when they ask. It may come from a neighbour's sale, an estimate on a website, or what they paid plus what they spent on renovations. I understand the hope behind that number. My job is not to nod along with it. My job is to open it up, line by line, and show you what supports it and what does not.
First: keep the three prices separate
| Term | What it means | Who sets it |
|---|---|---|
| Market value | What a ready buyer will most likely pay and a seller will accept today | The market, proven by real sales |
| Asking price | The price we put on MLS and advertise to buyers | You and I, as a strategy |
| MPAC assessed value | The value placed on the property by Ontario's Municipal Property Assessment Corporation | MPAC, for property tax purposes |
These three are often different, and that is normal.
Market value has no official price tag. It can only be inferred from homes that have actually sold. The asking price is a choice: we can set it at market value, or deliberately a little below or above it, but it is a starting point, not a result. The MPAC value is the one most often misunderstood. It exists so municipalities can levy property tax. As MPAC explains, its assessments provide the basis for municipal taxation and reflect value at a set valuation date, taking into account factors such as location, size, age, construction quality, and layout. It was not prepared for your sale, and no buyer is obliged to pay it. Using the number on a tax bill as a sale price starts the whole conversation in the wrong place.
An illustrative example, with invented figures only: suppose your MPAC assessment is $950,000, recent sales on your street point to a market range of $1,080,000 to $1,150,000, and together we decide to list at $1,099,000. All three numbers are doing different jobs. None of them is "wrong."
Second: how a market range is actually built
I price homes with a comparative market analysis, or CMA. In plain terms, it has four steps.
First, I look at what sold, not what is listed. An asking price is a wish; a sale price is a fact. I pull recent sold records from the TRREB MLS for the same community and the same type of home, favouring the sales closest to yours in floor plan, lot, and size. Homes still listed, or listings that expired, tell me about competition and about what the market refused. I do not use them as proof of value.
Second, I adjust each sale, item by item. No two homes are identical, so a neighbour's sale price cannot simply be copied over. Living space, lot size and frontage, bedrooms and bathrooms, garage and parking, a finished or unfinished basement, the age of the kitchen and bathrooms, exposure, and the street itself all get added or subtracted. One adjustment is missed most often: time. A sale from several months ago has to be carried forward to today using how the market has moved since then. It cannot be used as-is.
Third, I deal with condition honestly, including whether I have seen the home. If I have walked through it, condition goes into the adjustments. If I have not, I will give you a preliminary range only, tell you plainly that I have not been inside, and narrow it after I have. What a renovation cost is not the same as what it adds. Whether buyers will pay more for it depends on whether comparable sales reward it.
Fourth, I give a range, not a point. You get a low end that should hold, a most likely middle, and a high end that is reachable when everything lines up, together with a recommended asking price. Behind every figure, you can see which sales support it.
Third: the asking price is a strategy, not a prediction
Finding market value does not settle the list price. The list price has to answer one more question: what matters most in this sale?
If you have already bought your next home and your dates are tight, the asking price should sit close to market value and favour pace. A clean, early offer is worth more than weeks of waiting to gamble on a higher one. If you have time and your home is genuinely scarce, we can test the upper part of the range — but we agree in advance how long we wait before adjusting, and to what, so the listing does not sit and invite buyers to wonder what is wrong with it.
There is also the deliberate low list with a set offer date, meant to draw competing offers. That only works when similar homes are few and buyers are many. In a flat market, the offers that come back may simply cluster around that low number. I will explain the condition behind any strategy before I recommend it. If the condition is not there, I will not recommend the strategy.
Finally, we calculate what you keep. The sale price is not the money in your pocket. Commission and the HST on it, legal fees, any mortgage discharge or portability costs, and necessary repairs or preparation all come off first. Illustrative figures only: on a $1,120,000 sale, those costs can remove tens of thousands of dollars before the money is available for your next purchase. If we skip this step at pricing time, the budget for your next home will be wrong.
Three common misunderstandings
1. "A website estimates my home at this much, so let's list there." A website estimate is produced in bulk by an algorithm working from public data. It has never been inside your home. It does not know your kitchen was redone, or what your backyard faces. It is a fine starting point for a conversation and a poor basis for a price. Pricing rests on real sales, adjusted for your home.
2. "My neighbour listed at that price, so mine is worth at least that." Listed is not sold. That home may still be sitting, may sell only after a reduction, or may differ from yours in plan and lot more than it appears to from the street. First we check whether it sold, and for how much. Then we compare it, item by item.
3. "I spent $200,000 on renovations, so the price should be $200,000 higher." Not necessarily. Buyers pay for some improvements, ignore others, and may plan to remove very personal ones. What you spent is a cost. What it is worth is a market question. They are two different accounts, and I will tell you honestly what the sales suggest each major project adds — even when that answer is not the one you hoped for.
Before you ask me what it is worth, do these five things
- Find your tax bill and MPAC assessment notice, but keep that figure in the tax column of your mind, not the sale column.
- List the major projects you have done, with the year, what was done, and roughly what it cost. Keep invoices where you have them.
- Get your timeline clear: have you bought next, what is the latest you can move, and can you sell first or must you buy first?
- Decide what your bottom line really is: the highest price, or the firmest sale, the cleanest conditions, or the right closing date.
- Bring me every number you have heard — the neighbour's price, the website estimate — and I will check each one against the real record, sale by sale.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. If you are thinking of selling, do not start by chasing a single number. Bring the sales, the assessment, and your renovation list, and we will build the range from the documents first, then decide together what to ask.
This article is general information only. It is not an appraisal, and it is not legal or tax advice. Pricing for an actual listing should rest on a comparative market analysis prepared for that property. Consult an accountant for tax questions and an Ontario lawyer for legal questions.
Primary sources: MPAC, official guidance that property assessments are prepared for municipal property tax purposes and consider factors including location, size, age, and construction quality (mpac.ca, consulted November 2026); pricing method based on sold records from the TRREB MLS® system in a comparative market analysis (CMA). The figures $950,000, $1,080,000–$1,150,000, $1,099,000, and $1,120,000 are illustrative figures only, not real transactions.
Frequently asked questions
A website estimates my home at this much, so should we list there?
A website estimate is produced in bulk by an algorithm working from public data and has never been inside your home. It is a fine starting point for a conversation and a poor basis for a price; pricing rests on real sales, adjusted for your home.
My neighbour listed at that price, so is mine worth at least that?
Listed is not sold. That home may still be sitting, may sell only after a reduction, or may differ from yours in plan and lot more than it appears; first check whether it sold and for how much, then compare it item by item.
I spent $200,000 on renovations, so should the price be $200,000 higher?
Not necessarily. Buyers pay for some improvements, ignore others, and may plan to remove very personal ones; what you spent is a cost and what it is worth is a market question — two different accounts.


