I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The short answer: in Ontario, the main duty to repair sits with the landlord. That is not a matter of good service — it is a legal obligation written into the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (RTA). The tenant's side of the ledger is small: ordinary cleanliness, and damage caused by the tenant's own side. Keep that main line straight and most "who pays" arguments end on the spot.
First: the landlord's repair duty cannot be signed away
Section 20 of the RTA requires a landlord to provide and maintain the residential complex, including every rental unit in it, in a good state of repair and fit for habitation, and to comply with health, safety, housing and maintenance standards. Everything the landlord provides — the structure, plumbing, electrical and heating systems, through to landlord-supplied appliances, windows, doors and locks — must be kept in working order. When something breaks or wears out, the landlord repairs it, and if it cannot be repaired, replaces it. The replacement does not have to be a newer or better model; a properly working used appliance is acceptable. The duty is to restore working order, not to upgrade.
Section 20(2) closes off the most common excuse: the duty applies even if the tenant knew about the state of non-repair before signing and agreed to rent anyway. "It was like that when they took it, and they accepted it" does not transfer the repair duty to the tenant. And because section 16 of the RTA prohibits contracting out of the Act, a lease clause saying "rented as-is, tenant responsible for all repairs" will not hold up when it is tested.
Which detailed standards apply? Where a municipality has a property standards bylaw, the municipal standards govern; where it does not, the provincial maintenance standards in O. Reg. 517/06 apply. Enforcement and the exact standard vary by municipality, so landlords need to work to the rules of the city where the property sits.
Second: the tenant is responsible for two things — and cause decides everything
The first is ordinary cleanliness. Section 33 of the RTA makes the tenant responsible for the ordinary cleanliness of the unit, unless the tenancy agreement requires the landlord to clean it. The unit does not have to be spotless, but filth that attracts pests or creates a health or safety hazard is beyond "ordinary."
The second is damage caused by the tenant's side. Section 34 makes the tenant responsible for repairing undue damage caused by the wilful or negligent conduct of the tenant, another occupant of the unit, or a person the tenant permitted into the complex. Normal wear and tear is not undue damage: carpet that ages after years of ordinary use is the landlord's cost; a large red-wine stain, or a door kicked in by a guest, is the tenant's.
Appliance disputes follow the same two questions: who supplied it, and how did it break? A landlord-supplied fridge that dies of old age is repaired or replaced by the landlord. A landlord's dishwasher wrecked because a tenant jammed foreign objects into it is tenant-caused damage. An appliance the tenant brought in is the tenant's own problem. In any dispute, ask "how did it break" before asking "what does a new one cost."
Third: vital services are untouchable, and disputes follow a process — not rent withholding
Some areas leave a landlord almost no room. Under section 21 of the RTA, a landlord must not withhold the reasonable supply of a vital service: hot and cold water, fuel, electricity, gas, and heat between September 1 and June 15 — and that holds even if the rent is in arrears. Cutting water, power or heat to pressure a tenant is plainly unlawful. Common areas and pests are also on the landlord's side: the LTB's maintenance guidance states that landlords must keep common areas such as lobbies, halls and laundry rooms clean, and take steps to control pests such as cockroaches and mice. Unless a specific tenant's conduct is shown to have caused an infestation, pest control is generally the landlord's responsibility.
When a landlord enters to do repairs, section 27 generally requires at least 24 hours' written notice stating the reason, with entry between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., emergencies excepted.
A word to tenants, plainly: when a landlord drags out a repair, the worst response is withholding rent. The LTB is explicit that a tenant should not withhold any part of the rent even if maintenance is poor — unpaid rent hands the landlord grounds for a non-payment notice and puts the tenant at risk of eviction. The correct sequence is: notify the landlord in writing and keep the record; if the problem is not fixed within a reasonable time, complain to the municipal property standards office; if it is still unresolved, file Form T6 (Tenant Application about Maintenance) with the LTB within one year of the problem arising. The Board can order the landlord to complete the work by a set date, award a rent abatement, or compensate reasonable losses caused by the disrepair. The same logic protects landlords who respond promptly and document everything: in a hearing, the side with the paper trail wins.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The tenant knew about the defect before renting and agreed, so it's theirs to fix now." No. Section 20(2) states the repair duty applies even where the tenant knew of the non-repair and agreed to rent anyway. Knowledge is not a transfer of responsibility.
Misunderstanding 2: "If the landlord won't fix it, the tenant can hold back rent until it's done." No. Withholding rent is not recognized in Ontario and can trigger a non-payment notice and eviction proceedings. The remedies are a written repair request, a municipal complaint and a Form T6 application — rent keeps being paid while the claim proceeds separately.
Misunderstanding 3: "If the tenant is the one using it, a broken appliance is the tenant's bill." Wrong test. Ask who supplied the appliance and how it failed. Natural failure or wear of a landlord-supplied appliance is the landlord's repair or replacement; only wilful or negligent damage by the tenant's side shifts the cost to the tenant.
When a repair dispute lands, do these five things in order
- Put requests and responses in writing. Landlords should keep one fixed channel (email or text) for repair requests, and log every report, work order and completion with timestamps and photos.
- Establish the cause before discussing money. Attend, look, and record whether it is ordinary wear or human-caused damage — and write down the basis for the conclusion.
- Give proper notice before entry: at least 24 hours' written notice for non-emergency repairs. For genuine emergencies such as flooding or loss of heat, act first and document after.
- Rule out the illegal options on both sides: never cut off a vital service, and never treat rent withholding as self-help.
- If you cannot agree, use the process: tenants file Form T6; landlords can require the tenant to repair tenant-caused damage or seek the cost through the LTB. Both sides should arrive at the hearing with the written record and receipts.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Nine out of ten repair disputes are lost on missing records and missing writing, not on the law. Establish the facts and the cause first, and we will match them to the sections, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The cause of the damage, your municipality's standards and the evidence in your case can all change who is responsible. Consult an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal, or contact the LTB, before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.16, 20, 21, 27, 29, 33, 34 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); O. Reg. 517/06, Maintenance Standards; Landlord and Tenant Board brochure "Maintenance and Repairs" and the Form T6 instructions.
Frequently asked questions
The tenant knew about the defect before renting and agreed — is it theirs to fix now?
No. Section 20(2) states the repair duty applies even where the tenant knew of the non-repair and agreed to rent anyway. Knowledge is not a transfer of responsibility.
If the landlord will not fix it, can the tenant hold back rent until it is done?
No. Withholding rent is not recognized in Ontario and can trigger a non-payment notice and eviction proceedings. The remedies are a written repair request, a municipal complaint and a Form T6 application — rent keeps being paid while the claim proceeds separately.
If the tenant is the one using it, is a broken appliance the tenant's bill?
Wrong test. Ask who supplied the appliance and how it failed. Natural failure or wear of a landlord-supplied appliance is the landlord's repair or replacement; only wilful or negligent damage by the tenant's side shifts the cost to the tenant.


