I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 has no section written specifically for frozen pipes. When a pipe bursts, repair starts as the landlord's responsibility. The cost can shift to the tenant only where the damage is shown to be undue damage caused wilfully or negligently by the tenant's side. Who touched the thermostat is one fact, not an automatic verdict.
First: the starting point is the landlord's duty to repair
Section 20(1) requires a landlord to provide and maintain the residential complex and its rental units in a good state of repair and fit for habitation, and to comply with health, safety, housing and maintenance standards. Plumbing and heating are part of the home itself. A freeze caused by age, poor insulation, or a heating system in disrepair goes back to this section first.
Heating has two more layers. Section 21 bars a landlord from withholding a vital service the landlord is required to supply under the tenancy agreement, and heat is a vital service from September 1 to June 15. Under s.15 of O. Reg. 517/06, the provincial maintenance standards, habitable space must reach at least 20°C, measured 1.5 metres above the floor and one metre from exterior walls. Section 15(2) creates an exception: that minimum does not apply to a unit where the tenant can regulate the temperature and the primary heat source can maintain 20°C.
So ask the practical questions: who controls the thermostat, who pays for heat, and was the system capable of doing its job? If the landlord controlled and paid for heat and the temperature was not maintained, shifting blame to the tenant is difficult. If the tenant controlled and paid for heat, there is room to examine the tenant's conduct.
Second: shifting cost to the tenant must pass section 34
A tenant's duties are narrower than many owners assume. Section 33 requires only ordinary cleanliness — it is not a repair duty. Section 34 is the core provision here: the tenant is responsible for repairing undue damage to the rental unit or residential complex caused by the wilful or negligent conduct of the tenant, another occupant, or a person the tenant permitted into the complex.
A landlord therefore needs to show that the damage reached the level of undue damage, that the conduct was wilful or negligent rather than bad luck, and that the conduct caused the freeze. Whether turning heat off is negligent is not defined in the Act. It turns on the facts: how long the tenant was away, how cold it was, whether there was a written winter warning, who controlled the thermostat, whether the pipe already ran through an uninsulated exterior wall, and whether the furnace had reported problems that went unrepaired.
Two clearly illustrative examples, not real cases. Example one: a tenant leaves for two weeks, fully shuts off heat the tenant controls and pays for, despite a written warning at move-in not to shut heat off in winter, and the burst soaks the ceiling below — s.34 will be hard for that tenant. Example two: the tenant kept heat on normally, but the pipe sat against a poorly insulated exterior wall and a faulty furnace was reported and ignored — that looks like the landlord's own s.20 problem. Many real cases mix both sides, and the Landlord and Tenant Board decides on the evidence.
Third: how money is claimed, and why the unit below is separate
Stop the loss first. Section 16 requires a person entitled to claim to take reasonable steps to minimize the loss. Shut the main valve, repair, photograph, and build a timeline. Leaving water running and then claiming the full enlarged bill does not help the claimant. Both sides should notify each other in writing and notify their own insurers promptly.
Where a landlord alleges negligent undue damage, there are two routes. Under s.62, the landlord may give a notice of termination (Form N5) with a termination date no earlier than the 20th day after notice, stating the grounds and requiring the tenant within seven days to repair or pay the reasonable cost of repair — or replace or pay replacement cost where repair is not reasonable. If the tenant complies within seven days or makes arrangements satisfactory to the landlord, the notice is void. Under s.89, the landlord may apply to the Board for the reasonable repair or replacement costs the landlord has incurred or will incur; after the tenant has moved out, that application must be made no later than one year after the tenant ceased to be in possession. Section 63's shorter 10-day notice is for wilful damage and similar grounds — do not use it for a negligence freeze case.
Keep the downstairs money separate. Sections 34 and 89 speak of the rental unit and the residential complex, so repairing a ceiling below in the same complex may fall within the landlord's reasonable costs. The downstairs occupant's own soaked furniture and electronics are not the landlord's costs and are not claimed for them under s.89; insurance or another legal route is needed. If the unit below belongs to a different condominium owner, involve insurers and a lawyer early and do not admit full liability casually.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The tenant was using the pipe, so the tenant pays." No. Use is not negligence. Without wilful or negligent undue damage under s.34, the starting point remains the landlord's s.20 duty.
Misunderstanding 2: "The lease says all winter damage is the tenant's, so the lease governs." Not necessarily. A lease term inconsistent with the RTA is void. A clause transferring the landlord's statutory repair duty wholesale to the tenant is risky; a clause recording who controls the thermostat, who pays for heat, and who must be told about an absence is far more useful.
Misunderstanding 3: "Turning heat off is wilful damage, so the 10-day notice applies." Turning heat off is usually argued as negligence, not wilfulness. Section 63 sets a wilfulness threshold; negligence belongs under s.62, with a different timeline and a seven-day chance to fix the problem.
If a pipe bursts, I suggest you work in this order
- Shut the main valve, arrange emergency repair and drying, photograph and video the damage, and record the exact times for discovery, shut-off, notice and attendance.
- Notify the other side and your own insurer in writing, and keep texts, emails and repair requests — do not rely on phone calls alone.
- Establish three facts: who controlled the thermostat, who paid for heat, and what written winter warnings and furnace repair records exist.
- As landlord, keep quotes, invoices and proof of payment, claim only reasonable costs, and keep meeting the s.16 duty to minimize loss.
- Negotiate against the s.34 test first — negligence, causation and reasonableness of cost — and only then consider a s.62 notice or an s.89 application, watching the one-year deadline after a tenant moves out.
- Where a downstairs occupant's property, another owner's unit, or a large amount is involved, confirm the route with an Ontario lawyer and your insurer before signing any admission or settlement.
I am Ming Ren. Before a winter absence, confirm the heat will stay on; after a burst, stop the water and preserve the evidence, and we will work through the statute and the facts one item at a time.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Who controlled and paid for heating, the condition of the plumbing, and the evidence in an individual case will affect the result. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.16, 20, 21, 33, 34, 62, 63, 89; O. Reg. 517/06 (Maintenance Standards), s.15 (Ontario e-Laws, checked November 2026). The two examples are illustrative scenarios, not real cases.
Frequently asked questions
The tenant was using the pipe when it froze — does the tenant pay?
No. Use is not negligence. Without wilful or negligent undue damage under s.34, the starting point remains the landlord's s.20 duty.
If the lease says all winter damage is the tenant's, does the lease govern?
Not necessarily. A lease term inconsistent with the RTA is void. A clause transferring the landlord's statutory repair duty wholesale to the tenant is risky; a clause recording who controls the thermostat, who pays for heat, and who must be told about an absence is far more useful.
Is turning the heat off wilful damage that supports a 10-day notice?
Turning heat off is usually argued as negligence, not wilfulness. Section 63 sets a wilfulness threshold; negligence belongs under s.62, with a different timeline and a seven-day chance to fix the problem.


