Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

You Bought the Business and the Building. What Stops the Seller From Reopening Next Door in Ontario?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: your deed controls only your own parcel. It does nothing if the seller rents a unit next door, across the street, or in the same plaza and reopens. The only thing that can stop that is a contract — the non-compete clause in your purchase agreement — and only if it is drafted so an Ontario court will enforce it. Too wide, too long, or too vague, and the clause itself is at risk.

Three things matter: why courts treat sale-of-business covenants more generously than employment covenants, the three elements a defensible clause must get right, and the supporting terms that stop the seller from going around it.

1. A covenant sold with a business is judged differently from one in a job contract

Restrictive covenants start under suspicion in Canadian law because they restrain someone's ability to earn a living. But the Supreme Court of Canada draws a clear line between two settings.

In employment, bargaining power is unequal and courts scrutinize covenants strictly. In the sale of a business, both sides are commercial parties, usually advised by lawyers and accountants, and the price already includes payment for goodwill. The principle from Elsley, reaffirmed in Payette v. Guay inc., 2013 SCC 45, is that a non-compete given on the sale of a business will generally be enforced if its scope is reasonable — and the party attacking it bears the burden of proving it is unreasonable.

Payette itself shows how far that can go: the sellers of a crane rental business were held to a five-year covenant covering the whole province of Quebec, because the business itself operated wherever construction sites were. The logic is simple — if a seller could take the money and immediately take the customers back, no one could safely buy goodwill at all.

The practical lesson: do not draft timidly out of fear, and do not draft greedily either. The court's question is always the same — is this restriction no broader than necessary to protect the goodwill you actually bought?

2. Three elements decide whether the clause holds

Element Question to answer Risk if overdone
Geography Where do the customers actually come from? Where does the business really trade? Sweeping in territory the business never served looks unnecessary
Duration How long does it take for customer loyalty and reputation to transfer to you? A term far beyond that transfer period invites a reasonableness challenge
Activity Is the ban limited to the same kind of business, or anything remotely related? A ban on "any commercial activity" is the classic overreach

The three have to fit each other and fit the business. A neighbourhood restaurant drawing customers from a few kilometres cannot easily justify a province-wide, ten-year ban on all food businesses. A province-wide equipment rental operation may justify a wide territory — that is exactly what carried the day in Payette.

Two drafting points are routinely missed. First, state expressly that the covenant is given as part of the consideration for the sale and tie it to the goodwill being purchased; if the seller stays on for a transition period, keep the covenant in the purchase agreement rather than only in the employment or consulting paperwork, so it is characterized as a commercial covenant. Second, pair the non-compete with a non-solicitation clause covering customers and key employees. They do different work: one governs whether the seller can open, the other whether the seller can come and poach. Leaving out either leaves a hole on that side.

Note also that allocating a separate amount of the price to the restrictive covenant has tax consequences under section 68 of the Income Tax Act. Have your tax adviser settle that figure before the agreement is final, not at the closing table.

3. Plan for the workarounds

A determined seller rarely reopens under his own name next door. The usual routes are a spouse's or relative's name on the new business, a quiet equity stake or "consulting" role with a competitor, or a shop just outside the restricted area that markets hard to the old customer list. A single clause cannot close all of that; supporting terms do:

  • Define who is restricted — the seller personally, companies the seller controls, and affiliates — and say so in the document.
  • List the carriers of goodwill as closing deliverables: customer lists, supplier terms, the phone number, domain names, and social media accounts transfer to you and are actually handed over.
  • Agree on the remedy in advance — injunctive relief to stop a competing operation, or an agreed damages approach — so you are not proving loss from zero if a breach happens. Ontario courts do grant injunctions for breached sale-of-business covenants, but only where the covenant itself is reasonable.

An invented example, for illustration only: you pay $1.8 million for an auto repair business with its property, $400,000 of it expressly for goodwill, with a covenant barring the seller for three years from operating or holding an interest in an auto repair business within 8 kilometres, plus a non-solicitation clause. Two years later a new shop opens 3 kilometres away in a family member's name and texts the old customer list. With a clearly commercial covenant, a stated goodwill price, and evidence of solicitation, your lawyer's injunction application is in a completely different position than if all you held was a deed.

Three common misunderstandings

"I bought the property, so he can't set up beside me." He can. Title governs your lot line and stops there. The contract, not the deed, is what restrains the seller.

"Wider and longer is safer." The opposite. A covenant broader than protecting the purchased goodwill reasonably requires risks being held unreasonable and unenforced. Safety comes from a scope you can justify, not from the biggest numbers.

"The seller is staying on to help, so the covenant can go in his work contract." Risky. In an employment document it may be judged by the stricter employment standard. Its reason for existing is the sale, so put it in the purchase agreement and say that is what it is for.

If you are signing soon, do these five things in order

  1. Establish how much of the price is goodwill. A covenant with no goodwill consideration behind it starts out weak.
  2. Draw the territory from the business's real customer base, then set duration — every number should come with a one-sentence reason.
  3. Write the non-compete and the non-solicitation together, and close the affiliate, shareholding, and consulting loopholes expressly.
  4. Make the goodwill carriers — lists, numbers, domains, accounts — a closing checklist and verify each one at closing.
  5. Have an Ontario business lawyer review the clause's characterization and remedies, and your tax adviser confirm the treatment of any amount allocated to the covenant.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. On a business-plus-property purchase, split the price first and draft the clause properly — we will go through the documents item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. Whether a non-compete is enforceable depends on its territory, duration, activity scope, and the negotiation behind it. Consult an Ontario lawyer before signing.

Primary sources: Payette v. Guay inc., 2013 SCC 45; Elsley v. J.G. Collins Insurance Agencies Ltd., [1978] 2 SCR 916 (Supreme Court of Canada, via CanLII, consulted November 2026). The $1.8 million, $400,000, three-year and 8-kilometre figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation