Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

You Signed Through Your Company — Why Does the Landlord Still Want You Personally? Guarantee vs. Indemnity

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: signing a lease through your company does not end your personal risk at the company. If you also sign a personal guarantee or an indemnity, the landlord may pursue you directly when the company cannot pay. Before you sign, settle three things — which form you are signing, how much you could owe at worst, and how you get released. After signing, those points are very hard to reopen.

1. Why the landlord wants a second name

A new or small company usually has a short trading history and few assets a landlord can rely on — a weak covenant, in leasing language. The landlord is committing a unit for three or five years against your ability to pay rent every month. If the company closes, the landlord is left with an empty unit and an empty company. A shareholder's or operator's personal covenant is therefore a standard request in commercial leasing.

Standard does not mean take-it-or-leave-it. The landlord wants credit support; you need a boundary on personal risk. A larger deposit, prepaid rent or a letter of credit can sometimes substitute for, or narrow, a personal covenant. That trade belongs in the negotiation before signing, not as an afterthought.

2. A guarantee and an indemnity are not the same thing

These two words are often treated as synonyms. Their legal effect is materially different, and this is the most important part of the article.

Form Nature of the obligation When the company fails
Guarantee Secondary: the guarantor answers when the company defaults, and the guarantor's liability generally does not exceed the company's If the company's liability is reduced or extinguished, the guarantee may change with it; amendments to the lease can also affect it, depending on the wording
Indemnity Primary and independent: your own direct promise to the landlord, not dependent on the company's obligation continuing to exist Even if the tenant company goes bankrupt and a trustee disclaims the lease, the landlord can often still pursue you on the indemnity — stronger for the landlord, harder for you to escape

On bankruptcy: under the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, a trustee may disclaim a bankrupt tenant's lease, and the landlord's claim against the company for the unexpired term is sharply limited, with a separate preferred claim for accelerated rent. Case law confirms, however, that a disclaimer protects the bankrupt tenant itself; it does not automatically release third-party guarantors or indemnifiers. The company's line can end while your personal line continues. That is exactly why landlords prefer an indemnity, and why you must read which word the document actually uses.

Do not rely on a verbal explanation. Have a lawyer walk through, sentence by sentence: what triggers your liability, whether the landlord must pursue the company first, and whether your obligation survives a renewal, assignment or amendment of the lease.

3. How large it can be — and what can be negotiated

Many tenants assume a guarantee means covering a month or two of arrears. Broad wording can reach rent and additional rent for the balance of the term, plus the landlord's reasonable enforcement and re-letting costs. An invented example: a five-year lease fails in year two, with basic and additional rent totalling $8,000 a month and three years left. Rent alone is more than $288,000, before costs. Run that worst case before you sign and ask honestly whether you could carry it personally.

Four points are commonly negotiable:

  • A cap: limit personal liability to a fixed amount or a set number of months' rent, instead of the entire remaining term.
  • A burn-off: the covenant reduces or falls away after a set period of on-time payment.
  • Release on assignment: when the business is assigned to a transferee the landlord reasonably accepts, the outgoing operator is released — or, at minimum, remains responsible only for arrears from before the transfer.
  • Defined scope: state whether the covenant covers renewals, expansions and lease amendments, or only the original term as signed.

All of it must be in writing. A verbal assurance that 'we would never actually pursue you' protects no one. And if spouses or several shareholders sign together, check whether liability is joint and several — which lets the landlord pursue any one signer for the full amount — or limited to each signer's share.

Common misunderstandings

1. "My company has limited liability, so nothing can reach me." Only if you signed nothing personally. A signed guarantee or indemnity is a personal promise, and that promise is what the landlord enforces.

2. "Guarantee and indemnity are just two names for one thing." No. One is secondary, the other primary and independent. After a bankruptcy and a disclaimed lease, they can leave you in very different positions.

3. "Once I sell the business, my covenant ends automatically." Not unless the documents say so. Without a release on assignment, you may remain liable for a successor's arrears.

4. "A large landlord will never change its form." Often untrue. Caps, burn-offs and release conditions are ordinary negotiation points, especially when you offer a deposit, prepaid rent or other credit support in exchange.

If a guarantee document is in front of you now, do this in order

  1. Identify the form — guarantee, indemnity, or both — and have a commercial leasing lawyer review it together with the full lease, never in isolation.
  2. Calculate your worst case: remaining-term rent, additional rent and likely costs, in one total.
  3. Propose written amendments: a dollar or months cap, a burn-off for on-time payment, release on a qualified assignment, and a clear answer on renewals and amendments.
  4. Negotiate substitute credit support — a larger deposit, prepaid rent or a letter of credit — in exchange for a narrower personal covenant.
  5. Confirm with every co-signer whether liability is joint and several or by share. Do not sign to meet an opening date before the wording is settled and understood.

— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The effect of a guarantee or indemnity depends on its exact wording and the facts; consult an Ontario lawyer before you sign.

Primary sources: Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3, ss.30(1)(k) and 136(1)(f) (reviewed November 2026), and the standard Ontario commercial leasing distinction between a guarantee as a secondary obligation and an indemnity as a primary, independent obligation. The $8,000 monthly figure is invented for illustration.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation