I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: when you buy a business together with its real estate, you are never buying one thing. You are buying a basket — land, a building, equipment, inventory, and the invisible item, goodwill. The total price is the number everyone argues about. The allocation schedule inside the agreement — how that total is divided among the asset classes — is what actually decides how much the buyer can deduct in future years and how much tax the seller pays now.
The same total, split two different ways, can leave both sides with materially different after-tax results. Three things explain why: each asset class has a different tax fate, buyer and seller are pulled in opposite directions, and the CRA has a statutory power to redo an unreasonable split.
1. Five asset classes, five different tax fates
Under the Income Tax Act and the capital cost allowance (CCA) classes in the Income Tax Regulations, the broad picture is:
| Asset | Buyer after closing | Seller on the sale (outline) |
|---|---|---|
| Land | Not depreciable — no CCA, no annual deduction while held | Generally a capital gain |
| Building (Class 1) | CCA at 4% per year on a declining balance | Recapture of past CCA first, then a capital gain above original cost |
| Equipment (commonly Class 8) | CCA at 20% per year — much faster than the building | Recapture first, then a capital gain above original cost |
| Inventory | Deducted as cost of goods sold as it is sold | Taxed as business income |
| Goodwill (Class 14.1) | In Class 14.1 since 2017, CCA at 5% per year | Taxed under the Class 14.1 disposition rules |
Once that table is clear, the allocation explains itself. Every extra dollar allocated to equipment gives the buyer faster deductions; every extra dollar allocated to land gives the buyer nothing annually. For the seller it runs the other way: amounts allocated to heavily depreciated equipment and buildings tend to trigger recapture, taxed in full, while amounts allocated to land and goodwill fall more on the capital side. So the buyer pushes value toward fast-write-off assets and the seller pushes toward lightly taxed ones. Neither side is cheating — the tax system itself sets them against each other.
An invented example, numbers only to show the arithmetic: on a $3 million business-plus-property deal, Split A puts $1.2 million to the building and $600,000 to equipment; Split B puts $800,000 to the building and $200,000 to equipment, with the difference going to land and goodwill. Under Split A the buyer has $400,000 more in the 20% class, so early-year CCA is noticeably thicker — and the seller faces correspondingly more recapture today. The total price never changed. The after-tax outcome did.
2. Section 68: the CRA can substitute a reasonable allocation
Many people assume an allocation is pure contract freedom. That is only half true.
Section 68 of the Income Tax Act provides that where an amount is partly consideration for a property and partly for something else, the portion that can reasonably be regarded as consideration for that property is deemed to be its proceeds of disposition and the buyer's cost — regardless of what the contract says on its face. In plain terms, if your split is unreasonable, the CRA can reallocate on a reasonable basis, and the substituted figures apply to both sides. One party cannot report one set of numbers while the other reports a different set.
"Reasonable" in practice means anchored to fair market value. What defends an allocation is not negotiating volume but evidence: an appraisal of the real estate, an equipment list with values, an inventory count, and a supportable goodwill calculation. An arm's-length split, advised on both sides and matching the appraisals, is generally respected. A split engineered to suit one party's tax bill by stuffing value into the wrong class is exactly what section 68 exists for.
Two related points not to confuse with allocation: a separate amount paid for a restrictive covenant such as a non-compete has its own tax treatment and needs separate advice; and GST/HST on an asset sale — including whether an election is available — is a separate question that should be settled in the same negotiation, not discovered at closing.
3. Negotiate the split at signing, not at tax time
The allocation must live in the agreement, which is signed when everyone's attention is on the total price and the conditions. Three habits protect you.
First, have your accountant model the after-tax outcome before you offer: the seller should know his net under different splits, the buyer should know the CCA pattern over the first several years. A $20,000 difference in total price and a $200,000 difference in allocation are not equally painful — run the numbers before you negotiate either. Second, attach a formal allocation schedule to the agreement, listing land, building, equipment, inventory, goodwill and any restrictive covenant separately, with a covenant that both parties will file consistently with it and neither will take an inconsistent position. Third, support the numbers with appraisals — especially the land-versus-building split, which drives both the buyer's CCA base and the seller's division between capital gain and recapture, and is the split most often questioned.
Sellers should also note that a building sold for less than its undepreciated balance can engage special rules reallocating proceeds between building and land (for example, subsection 13(21.1)). That is case-specific — have your tax adviser check it rather than relying on the outline table above.
Three common misunderstandings
"Same total price, so the allocation is just paperwork." The total is the same; the tax is not. The allocation sets the buyer's deductions for years and the composition of the seller's tax bill today. That is real money.
"Whatever the contract says, the CRA has to accept." Section 68 exists precisely for unreasonable allocations. A split that departs materially from fair market value can be replaced on a reasonable basis — for both parties at once.
"Goodwill is just the leftover — dump the balance there." Goodwill is commonly the residual after identifiable assets are valued, but it is now a Class 14.1 asset with its own CCA rate and disposition rules, not a dustbin. Its amount still needs a supportable calculation.
Before you sign, do these five things in order
- Have your accountant model the after-tax result before you offer, treating price and allocation as two separate negotiating variables.
- Get the evidence: a real estate appraisal, plus an equipment list, valuation, and inventory count behind every large figure.
- Attach a formal allocation schedule to the agreement, with a promise that both sides will file on the same basis.
- Deal separately with any restrictive-covenant amount, the GST/HST treatment, and any available elections.
- Have your tax adviser test the final split against section 68's reasonableness standard. Do not save money on this step.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. On these deals, split the total open first — we will work through the schedule and the tax result line by line.
This article is general information only, not tax or legal advice. CCA classes and rates, and the treatment of recapture and capital gains, vary with when assets were acquired and the facts of the case. Consult an Ontario lawyer and a chartered professional accountant before acting.
Primary sources: Income Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c.1 (5th Supp.), s.68 and s.13(21.1); Income Tax Regulations, Schedule II, Class 1 (4%), Class 8 (20%), Class 14.1 (5%, including goodwill since 2017) (Justice Laws / CRA, consulted November 2026). The $3 million figures and both splits are illustrative only, not a real transaction.


