Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Buying a Retail Plaza? The Rent Roll Is Only Half the Story — Check Co-Tenancy First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion: when you buy a retail plaza, you are not buying the numbers printed on the rent roll. You are buying numbers with conditions attached. Many smaller tenants agreed to pay their current rent on the understanding that named anchor stores would keep operating, or that overall occupancy would stay above an agreed level. If that understanding fails, their leases may already give them a right to pay less, close their doors while keeping the lease, or leave altogether. The rent roll will not tell you this. The leases will.

First: what co-tenancy is actually protecting

Much of a small shop's trade comes from traffic the anchors bring in. A supermarket or pharmacy takes a lot of space, often at a lower rent per foot, but it draws the customers. The small units around it are where much of the rent per foot is earned. So a small tenant asks for protection at signing: if the stores that bring the traffic are gone, my rent should change too.

That protection usually works at two moments. Before opening, if a promised anchor has not opened, the tenant may delay opening or open at a lower rent. During the term, if an anchor leaves or stops operating after the tenant is already trading, the tenant can use whatever remedy its lease provides. Buyers of an existing plaza should focus on the second kind, because the risk is already sitting inside leases that are in force today.

Also check how the trigger is written. Some leases name specific stores, so you can simply count them. Others use anchor area or a percentage of the plaza that must be open, which you have to calculate from leasable area — and buyer and seller may calculate it differently. The same departure can produce opposite answers under the two styles.

Second: after a trigger, how much does the landlord actually lose?

The trigger decides when trouble starts. The remedy decides how big it is. Common remedies include a lower rent fixed in advance, rent reduced to a percentage of the original, a temporary switch to rent based on sales, a right to close while keeping the lease, and a right to terminate if the problem lasts for an agreed period. Every lease combines these differently, so never project one lease onto another.

Watch one word in particular: many leases require the anchor to be open and operating, not merely to still hold a lease. A store that keeps paying rent behind closed doors brings in no customers, yet it may already have triggered a neighbour's right to pay less. When you read a lease, note whether it says operating, or only in occupation.

Do not measure the loss as a few months of rent either. Here is an invented example, only to show the arithmetic: if several small tenants together pay $80,000 a year less after an anchor leaves, then at a 6% capitalization rate the rough value effect is $80,000 divided by 6%, about $1.33 million. A real deal needs the real leases and a real rate, but the point stands — an annual shortfall is multiplied into value. That is why this belongs in pricing, seller warranties or due-diligence conditions before you firm up, not in a surprise after closing.

Third: a clause on paper is not automatically enforceable

Ontario courts have tested these clauses. In Old Navy (Canada) Inc. v. Eglinton Town Centre Inc., 2019 ONSC 3740, the tenant's lease named several key stores, one of which later went bankrupt and stopped trading, and the tenant claimed the right to pay a reduced rent. The court did not simply adopt the tenant's reading. It examined differences between the letter of intent and the formal lease and whether the result made commercial sense, found for the landlord, and the appeal was dismissed.

For a buyer the lesson is practical: a co-tenancy clause is not an insurance policy that pays out automatically. Ambiguous wording, a mismatch between the letter of intent and the lease, or a reduction so deep it defies commercial sense can all make the outcome uncertain. In due diligence, do not pretend the clauses are not there, and do not assume the worst case is certain either. List each lease's trigger, remedy, notice steps and time limits, and have counsel sort the firm rights from the arguable ones.

Item to list Question to answer
Named anchors Which stores? Still operating? How much term is left?
Percentage test By area or by store count? How close is current occupancy to the line?
Remedy Reduced to what? Can the tenant go dark? When can it terminate?
Procedure Is written notice required? Can the landlord cure or substitute a store?

Common misunderstandings

1. "Everyone pays full rent on the rent roll, so the income is solid." The rent roll is a snapshot of today. Co-tenancy governs tomorrow. One cannot stand in for the other.

2. "The anchor's lease is still alive, so it has not left." Many clauses turn on being open for business. A dark store that still pays rent can still trigger other tenants' rights.

3. "A rent cut only costs a few months of money." Capitalized, a lasting annual shortfall becomes a much larger value gap. If you do not price it, you buy the risk yourself.

4. "Once triggered, the tenant is sure to win the reduction." The Old Navy case shows a court will read the whole file and test commercial reasonableness. Ambiguous clauses give uncertain results.

If you are looking at a retail plaza, I suggest this order

  1. Do not accept only a rent roll and lease summaries. Ask for the complete text of every lease, including amendments and side agreements.
  2. Pull the co-tenancy clause out of each lease and build one master table: named stores, percentage tests, remedies and notice steps.
  3. Verify each anchor's real position: trading or dark, expiry date, renewal rights, and any known closing or insolvency news.
  4. Run one stress test: assume the largest anchor stops operating tomorrow, and rebuild annual income and value using each lease's remedy.
  5. Put the result into the deal — a price adjustment, a seller warranty, tenant estoppel certificates or a due-diligence exit right. Pick at least one; do not leave it verbal.
  6. Where wording is ambiguous or the letter of intent and lease do not match, get an Ontario commercial leasing lawyer involved early, not at the financing stage.

I am Ming Ren. On a retail plaza, read the leases one by one first — then we talk price on the income that survives the worst case.


This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a co-tenancy clause can be enforced depends on the exact wording of each lease and the facts. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary source: Old Navy (Canada) Inc. v. Eglinton Town Centre Inc., 2019 ONSC 3740 (CanLII), affirmed on appeal. The $80,000 and 6% figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction or market data.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation