I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
My conclusion up front: a bidding contest is a choice before it is a competition. However much you like a home, if competing means paying more, or giving up more protection, than the home is actually worth to you, the right move is to walk away. A pre-emptive offer — often called a bully offer — is the same kind of decision. It is not a shortcut; it is showing your hand early. It may let you avoid the scheduled contest, or it may simply expose your position and your risk sooner. Decide whether to enter the game first, and only then talk about how to play it.
First: what competing gives you, and what it costs
The benefits are real. You get a chance at a home that is genuinely scarce, in the right location with the right layout. Competition also tells you the market wants this home, which usually means resale interest later. And if you win, the search ends — no more weekends of showings.
The costs are just as real. First, price: you cannot see the other offers, so it is easy to keep adding “just a little more” until you pass what recent comparable sales support. Second, protection: to look competitive, buyers get pushed toward shorter conditions, or waiving financing and inspection altogether — the risk lands on you before you ever move in. Third, mindset: lose once, and the next home gets a rushed, emotional bid meant to make up for it.
My test is simple. Use recent comparable sales to work out what the home is worth, then set your maximum price and write it down. If the contest can be won at or under that number, compete. If winning requires crossing it, leave. Illustrative numbers only: if comparable sales support $1,000,000 (illustrative) and that is also your maximum, bid to that line — do not let the heat of the evening rewrite it to $1,050,000 (illustrative). The maximum is set with data before you offer, not with emotion during it.
Know the information rule before you start, so you expect the right things. Under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and O. Reg. 567/05, s. 22.7, the seller's brokerage must tell every person who has made a written offer how many competing written offers there are. The substance of those offers — price, closing date, conditions — is shared only if the seller directs it in writing, and the seller may direct that only part of it be shared. Who the other buyers are, and anything that could identify them, can never be shared. Only written offers count; a verbal indication does not. If you later doubt the count, a person who made a written offer, or their agent, can ask RECO's registrar to confirm how many written offers were received. The seller may accept, sign back, or reject any offer — bidding at or above the asking price does not guarantee acceptance.
Second: when a pre-emptive offer is worth trying
A pre-emptive offer is submitted before the seller's scheduled offer date, aiming to settle the deal before the formal contest begins. In my view it is worth trying only when three things are true at once: you have confirmed with sold data that your price holds up, rather than guessing; the home is genuinely scarce, with few comparable alternatives that could replace it soon; and your financing confidence and inspection preparation are already done, so you can carry the risk if the terms end up clean. If any one of the three is missing, I usually advise waiting for the scheduled date and competing through the normal process — or not competing at all.
Understand the other side of it. Whether a seller will even look at a pre-emptive offer is not the buyer's call. It depends on the seller's written direction to their brokerage: it may say none will be considered, only offers meeting a set threshold will be shown, or every one will be brought to the seller. And if the seller decides to consider yours early, it does not happen quietly. Under RECO Bulletin 4.3, the seller's brokerage must notify, in writing, everyone who has shown interest — people who booked or completed a showing, said they would offer, or already submitted an offer — of the new offer date and time. Your early move can pull the competition forward instead of avoiding it. Ontario law also sets no fixed notification window; do not treat “24 hours” as a rule — that is only the length of an irrevocability period in a given offer.
There is a price for asking a seller to stop waiting: the offer usually has to be clearly attractive on price, deposit and closing flexibility, and it is often expected to be clean, with a short irrevocability. You pay a premium for certainty and accept less protection. The seller can still refuse and return to the original date — by which point your pricing thinking has already been shown once.
Third: two situations where I advise walking away
First, when the numbers no longer work. The sold data cannot support the price you would need, or at that price the payments, down payment and coming repairs strain your cash flow. A home is for living in, not for servicing. Second, when the protection is gone but you are not actually ready: no solid mortgage pre-approval and no pre-inspection, yet the offer would go in firm. If financing falls through or the home has a major defect, the deposit and liability are real money.
Walking away is not losing. In my experience, missing a home at the right price costs far less than winning one at the wrong price. There is always a next listing; your maximum price and your condition floor are what keep you able to wait for it.
Common misunderstandings
One: “The agent says there are several offers — it must be a bluff.” The count is information the brokerage is legally required to give, and a registrant cannot invent a written offer that does not exist. After you submit a written offer, the RECO registrar route exists to check the number. But a true count does not oblige you to bid higher.
Two: “I can find out what the others bid, then top it.” By default, no. Substance is shared only on the seller's written direction, and possibly only in part; buyer identity is never shared. Make your decision assuming you will know the count and nothing more.
Three: “A pre-emptive offer is a quiet, private move.” It is not. If the seller considers it early, the brokerage must notify all interested parties in writing and update the date and time. It can turn into an early formal contest.
Four: “The highest price always wins.” It does not. The seller weighs the whole offer — price, conditions, closing date and deposit — and may reject every offer. Losing with the highest price is not unusual.
Action checklist
- Before offering, build a recent comparable-sales analysis, set your value line, and write down your maximum price — do not change it that evening.
- Set your condition floor in advance: which conditions must stay, and no firm offer without a pre-inspection and solid financing.
- After submitting a written offer, confirm your brokerage has told you the number of competing offers; if you doubt it, ask about the RECO registrar confirmation route.
- Before trying a pre-emptive offer, ask whether the seller's written direction allows offers to be considered early, and prepare for the notice to trigger competition sooner.
- Make the pre-emptive package — price, deposit, closing flexibility — strong enough to justify the seller ending the wait, but never stronger than your maximum.
- If any line is crossed — price over the maximum, conditions all removed, cash flow unsustainable — follow the decision you made in advance and withdraw, instead of renegotiating with yourself on the spot.
— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron
This article is general information, not legal or mortgage advice. A seller's direction, disclosure arrangements and the condition of an individual home affect any case; consult an Ontario lawyer and your mortgage professional before acting.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and O. Reg. 567/05, s. 22.7; RECO Bulletin 4.1 (competing offers), Bulletin 4.3 (pre-emptive offers) and RECO consumer guidance on competing offers (reviewed November 2026). All dollar figures are illustrative, not real transactions.
Frequently asked questions
The agent says there are several offers — is that a bluff?
The count is information the brokerage is legally required to give, and a registrant cannot invent a written offer that does not exist. After you submit a written offer, the RECO registrar route exists to check the number, but a true count does not oblige you to bid higher.
Can I find out what the others bid and then top it?
By default, no. Substance is shared only on the seller's written direction, and possibly only in part; buyer identity is never shared. Decide assuming you will know the count and nothing more.
Is a pre-emptive offer a quiet, private move?
No. If the seller considers it early, the brokerage must notify all interested parties in writing and update the date and time. It can turn into an early formal contest.
Does the highest price always win?
No. The seller weighs the whole offer — price, conditions, closing date and deposit — and may reject every offer. Losing with the highest price is not unusual.


