I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the conclusion first: losing a competing-offer contest is not the problem. The problem is raising a ceiling you set in advance, in the heat of offer night, and then finding that your financing, the appraisal, and your cash on closing do not follow. Before you compete, fix three things — the most you will pay, which conditions you are willing to adjust, and which ones you will not touch — and on the night, simply follow that plan.
First: turn your ceiling into a number that can actually close
A ceiling is not just "the most I feel like paying." It has to pass three tests at once: the lender will approve it, the appraisal will broadly support it, and on closing you will have enough cash for the balance of the down payment and closing costs. Fail any one of the three, and a higher price only creates trouble for yourself.
I ask buyers to fill in this table after the showing and before any offer is written. On offer night, we do not redo it:
| What to fix | What to decide | Why decide it early |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum total price | One number, written down | On the night, you only check whether you are over it — you do not debate "just a little more" |
| Deposit plan | The amount, and how you will deliver it within the time the agreement requires after acceptance | The deposit is a term of the offer; scrambling for it after acceptance puts your performance at risk |
| Conditions | Which of financing, inspection and other conditions stay, and for how long | A condition protects you; before removing one, be clear who carries the risk |
An example I made up, with numbers for illustration only: suppose your ceiling is $880,000 (illustrative figure) and comparable sales broadly support $850,000 to $870,000 (illustrative figures). You need to think through the gap in advance — if the lender's appraisal comes in at $860,000 (illustrative figure), where does the difference come from? If you cannot answer that, do not set the ceiling at $880,000.
One more plain point: a pre-approval is not a final approval. It helps you set a range, but the lender still reviews this specific property at this specific price. Treating a pre-approval as money already in hand is a common misjudgment in a contest.
Second: know what you are guaranteed to be told — and what not to expect
Ontario's rules here have run under phase two of the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) since December 1, 2023. As a buyer who has submitted a written offer, your position is clear, and it is limited:
First, you must be told the number of written offers. When the seller's brokerage receives competing written offers, it must communicate the number of competing written offers to every person making one of the offers. This is not at the seller's discretion — the seller cannot switch it off. Note that only written offers already submitted count; saying out loud "I intend to offer" does not count.
Second, the content of the other offers is shared only if the seller directs it. Only on the seller's direction may the brokerage share the substance of competing written offers with every person making one of the offers. The seller may direct that only parts be shared, and may change the direction. Whatever is shared must go to every offeror, not just to one or two favoured buyers.
Third, identity is never shared. Even where the seller directs sharing, the information shared must not include the personal information of the person making the offer, or anything else that would identify them.
So set your expectations accordingly: the one fact you can reliably count on is usually how many written offers there are in total. Do not expect the highest price to be placed in front of you so you can top it by a small step. RECO's guidance to consumers makes the same point — buyers should not expect the content of other offers to be shared, or that any content shared will include the price.
The seller also decides which offer to accept. A higher price helps, but it is not the only factor: the deposit, the number of conditions, and whether the closing date fits the seller's plans are all weighed together. That is simply the seller's right to choose among the offers in front of them.
Third: to improve your chances, make the offer clean — not just higher
Within your ceiling, what you can adjust is mostly how easy your offer is for the seller to accept, not whether you break the ceiling.
The closing date is one example. If the seller has already bought their next home and their dates are tight, matching the closing date they want can matter more than a small price increase. On the other hand, if your own sale, financing or move cannot shift, do not promise a date you cannot meet just to win — a promise you cannot keep becomes a dispute later.
Conditions work the same way. Look at the home carefully at the showing and ask what needs asking, so you actually understand what you are buying; only then are you in a position to discuss shortening a condition period. Removing every condition without doing that work may win the home, but it will not give you peace of mind. My view is simple: a condition can be negotiated, but for each one you remove, you should be able to say how you will carry the risk if something goes wrong. If you cannot say it, keep the condition.
The deposit is similar: write an amount your funds can actually support. Its purpose is to show the seller you can and will perform. An amount you cannot deliver within the time your agreement requires does you no good at all.
In the end, there should be very few decisions left on offer night itself. If you have done the first two parts, the night comes down to one action: offer at the ceiling and on the conditions you fixed in advance, and stop if it goes above that ceiling. Losing to a higher price is not a failure of judgment. Winning above your own ceiling is what turns into months of pressure afterwards.
Common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The seller won't tell me the highest price, so the agent must be hiding it." No. Whether content is shared is the seller's direction to give. Without that direction, it cannot be shared. What must be told to you is the number of written offers, not anyone else's price.
Misunderstanding 2: "It is open bidding now, so we all take turns raising the price." No. Ontario has not become an auction room. The seller may direct that all or part of the content be shared, or may direct that nothing be shared; that is not the same as a single, standardized live auction process.
Misunderstanding 3: "The highest price always wins." Not necessarily. The seller looks at the whole offer — deposit, conditions and closing date included. Within the same ceiling, an offer with clear terms and a closing date that fits is often easier to accept than a slightly higher offer with drawn-out conditions.
When offer day is close, work in this order
- Check your pre-approval and the total price you can carry with your lender, set it against recent comparable sales, and write down your maximum price. Once set, do not change it on offer night.
- Arrange in advance how the deposit will be paid and when, under the terms you are about to sign. Do not wait until acceptance to assemble the funds.
- Ask early whether the seller will direct that offer content be shared, and prepare to work with only the total number of offers and no one else's price.
- Go through your conditions one by one: which stay, for how long, which could be removed, and who carries the risk if one is removed. Settle this with your agent and build it into your offer plan.
- Ask what closing date the seller wants, and match it as far as you genuinely can. Do not promise a date you cannot meet.
- On offer night, execute the plan you fixed in advance. If it goes above your ceiling, stop — do not change the number because you were "almost there."
Honest in character, diligent in work — that is how I try to do this job. I am Ming Ren. In a competing-offer situation, the first step I take with a client is never to raise the price. It is to fix the ceiling and the conditions clearly: compete fully within the ceiling, and if it goes above it, walk away cleanly and look at the next home.
This article is general information only, not legal advice and not mortgage or financial advice. Your financing approval, the terms of your agreement and your own circumstances will affect the result. Before signing, consult an Ontario lawyer and your lender.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c.30, Sched. C (Ontario e-Laws); O. Reg. 567/05, s.22.7 on communicating the number and sharing the substance of competing written offers; RECO Bulletin 4.1, Number and content of competing offers, and RECO consumer guidance (consulted November 2026). The figures $880,000, $850,000–$870,000 and $860,000 are illustrative figures only, not real transactions or market statistics.
Frequently asked questions
The seller won't tell me the highest price, so is the agent hiding it?
No. Whether content is shared is the seller's direction to give, and without that direction it cannot be shared; what must be told to you is the number of written offers, not anyone else's price.
Is it open bidding now, so we all take turns raising the price?
No. Ontario has not become an auction room; the seller may direct that all or part of the content be shared, or that nothing be shared, which is not the same as a single standardized live auction process.
Does the highest price always win?
Not necessarily. The seller looks at the whole offer, deposit, conditions and closing date included, and an offer with clear terms and a closing date that fits is often easier to accept than a slightly higher offer with drawn-out conditions.


