I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
My conclusion up front: offer night is not won by whoever shouts loudest or raises fastest. It is won by whoever fixed their price, conditions and paperwork before the evening started. People who improvise mid-evening usually lose on pacing, not on money. This article covers only the night itself — how to submit, how to trade conditions, what to say, and what to keep in writing. Setting your budget ceiling is a separate topic; here I assume you already have one.
First: pacing — submit one clean offer, and do not count on a second round
Many buyers walk in planning to "start a bit low, see the reaction, then raise." On a multiple-offer night that plan mostly fails. The seller typically accepts one offer, or signs one back, and the offers set aside rarely get a genuine second chance to improve. What you think of as holding something back, the seller reads as a price that was not serious.
In practice I suggest this order. One: put your price at the position you decided in advance, in a single step — do not split it into two. Two: set the irrevocability period — how long your offer stays open for the seller — sensibly: too short and it expires before the seller finishes reviewing; too long and you are tied up while the seller shops around. Give a reasonable point after the seller's review that evening; fix the exact time with your agent based on the night's schedule, not by reflex. Three: after submitting, do one thing — wait, and stay reachable. A sign-back often comes with a short reply deadline, and if you cannot be reached, the chance moves to the next offer. Four: if a sign-back arrives, compare exactly what changed — price, closing date and condition deadlines are the three most commonly altered items — before you decide. Never agree to a number verbally on the phone; a verbal promise binds no one. Only the amended, signed document counts.
Second: condition trade-offs — you can trade inconvenience, not unverified risk
Clean conditions are real competitive strength in a bidding situation, but be clear about what you are trading. My rule: homework that can be finished in advance should not be left as a condition. If you can do a pre-offer inspection before offer day, do it — then submitting without an inspection condition is a decision with a floor under it. Financing is the same: with a proper pre-approval, with the amount, rate and expiry confirmed, removing the financing condition carries a controllable risk. Closing dates and included items are "inconvenience" concessions — giving on them costs you comfort, not safety, so be generous there.
What you cannot trade is risk you have not verified. Dropping the inspection condition without a pre-inspection, or the financing condition on the strength of a verbal estimate, is not decisiveness — it is exposure. The deposit is also an offer-night action, not an afterthought: once your offer is accepted, the deposit is usually due within the agreed time — commonly within 24 hours — by bank draft or certified cheque to the specified trust account. Have the money ready before you win, not after. Illustrative numbers only: on a $1,000,000 offer (illustrative), a 5% deposit (illustrative) is $50,000 (illustrative) — and it should be sitting in an account you can draw a draft from before the evening begins.
Third: communication and paper trail — written only, and only the information the rules allow
Get the rules straight first, so nobody can steer you during the evening. Under TRESA and section 22.7 of O. Reg. 567/05, the seller's brokerage must tell every person who made a written offer the number of competing written offers. The contents — price, conditions and other terms — are not shared by default. They may be shared only if the seller directs it in writing, and then only with everyone who submitted an offer, never selectively, and a buyer's personal information can never be disclosed. A verbal offer does not count as a competing offer. So on the night, the one fact you are normally entitled to is "there are this many offers in total." If someone tells you what the highest offer supposedly is, ask one question first: did the seller authorize disclosure in writing? If not, that number is neither reliable nor a basis for raising yours.
Keeping the trail is simple, but it has to happen that night. One: put key communications in writing — your decisions on price and conditions with your agent should leave a text record; after any phone call, confirm it by text or email. Two: after submitting, confirm two things with your agent — that the offer was formally registered and submitted, and that the seller's brokerage received it — and note the time and method. Three: keep the complete file: every version you submitted, every sign-back, every confirmation, saved version by version. The seller's brokerage is required to retain each unaccepted written offer, or a summary document of it — in practice often OREA Form 801, the Offer Summary Document — for at least one year. If you later doubt the offer count you were given, you or your agent can ask RECO to confirm how many offers were actually received, under section 35.1 of TRESA. You will rarely need that route, but its existence is exactly why your own file has to withstand comparison.
Common misunderstandings
One: “Submit low first to test the water, then raise.” On a multiple-offer night there is usually no testing round. The seller negotiates with one offer; the rest are out.
Two: “The seller's agent won't tell me the top price — they're making it hard for me.” No. Non-disclosure of contents is the default rule. Disclosure requires the seller's written direction, and it must be given equally to everyone who submitted an offer.
Three: “Waive every condition and you are guaranteed to win.” Clean conditions are only one plus. Sellers weigh price, closing and certainty together — and carrying unverified risk to strip conditions can make a win the start of a problem.
Four: “We agreed the raise and the new date verbally; we'll paper it later.” No. Real estate transactions run on writing. A verbal promise binds no one until the document is amended and signed.
Action checklist
- Before the evening, write your price, closing date and condition decisions on one page, and execute only from that page — invent nothing on the night.
- Finish the pre-offer inspection and a proper pre-approval in advance; for anything unfinished, honestly keep the matching condition.
- Keep the deposit in an account you can draw a bank draft from, ready to deliver within 24 hours of acceptance.
- Set the irrevocability to a reasonable point after the seller's review, and stay reachable and able to sign during that window.
- After submitting, confirm registration and delivery with your agent, and record the time and method.
- Decide only on information the rules allow: you may ask the number of offers; contents not disclosed under the seller's written direction should not be believed or chased.
- On a sign-back, compare every change line by line before replying, and file every version that same night.
— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron
This article is general information, not legal advice. Submission, conditions and disclosure rules vary with the individual case and the seller's directions; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and O. Reg. 567/05, s. 22.7, and TRESA s. 35.1; RECO competing-offers guidance and TRESA FAQs; OREA Form 801 (Offer Summary Document) (reviewed November 2026). All dollar figures are illustrative, not real transactions.
Frequently asked questions
Can I submit low first to test the water, then raise?
On a multiple-offer night there is usually no testing round. The seller negotiates with one offer and the rest are out.
Is the seller's agent making it hard for me by not telling me the top price?
No. Non-disclosure of contents is the default rule; disclosure requires the seller's written direction and must be given equally to everyone who submitted an offer.
If I waive every condition, am I guaranteed to win?
Clean conditions are only one plus. Sellers weigh price, closing and certainty together, and carrying unverified risk to strip conditions can make a win the start of a problem.
We agreed a raise and a new date verbally — can we paper it later?
No. Real estate transactions run on writing, and a verbal promise binds no one until the document is amended and signed.


