I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: in Ontario, when the listing agent says how many offers there are, that number itself is regulated. The brokerage must disclose the number of competing written offers to every person who makes an offer — it cannot inflate the count, and it cannot pad it with verbal interest. But the number is all you get by default: the contents of competing offers (price, conditions, closing date) stay confidential unless the seller directs an open offer process, and the identity of competing buyers is never disclosed. Your job is to understand exactly what the number counts, then price your offer from evidence.
First: what counts as "an offer"
Counting starts with a written offer. Section 35.1 of TRESA requires offers to be in writing, and prohibits a registrant from representing that a written offer exists when it does not. So:
- A written APS still within its irrevocable period counts. The seller can still accept it; it is live competition.
- An expired offer does not count. Once the irrevocable time passes, the buyer is no longer bound and the seller can no longer accept it. It has left the competition, and keeping it in the number is misleading.
- A withdrawn offer does not count. A buyer who formally withdrew before the deadline has exited as well.
- Verbal interest and "an offer is coming" never count. A phone call promising an offer tonight is the future tense, not an existing competing offer.
So when you hear a number, you are entitled to ask: "Are all of those currently valid written offers?" That is not confrontation; it is the scope of information the rules give an offeror. Timing matters too. An offer presentation is a moving process — offers expire and new ones arrive — so the count at 7 p.m. may differ from the count at 9 p.m. Ask "as of right now," because the definition matters more than the digit.
Second: the number must be disclosed, contents are confidential by default, identity never
TRESA and sections 22.7 to 22.8 of O. Reg. 567/05 divide competing-offer disclosure into three layers.
Layer one is the number. Whenever there are competing offers, the listing brokerage must disclose the number of written offers to every person making one. This layer needs no seller permission, and the seller cannot instruct the brokerage to hide the count.
Layer two is substance. Prices, conditions, and other content of competing offers are not disclosed by default. Only where the seller directs the brokerage in writing to run an open offer process may the directed parts be shared — equally with every offeror. The seller may direct disclosure of only part of the substance, for example closing dates only. The large majority of Ontario transactions still use the traditional closed process: you know how many rivals you have, not what they offered.
Layer three is identity. Who the competing buyers are is never disclosed, in any circumstances.
One related disclosure: if the listing brokerage also represents one of the competing buyers as its client, that fact must be disclosed to the other offerors as soon as possible. You are entitled to know "one of your rivals is the listing brokerage's own client" — though never who, or at what price.
Third: what the number should — and should not — do to your price
The number is information, not an instruction. Three offers does not mean you must bid to some level, and five does not prove the home is worth more. Your price anchor must always be comparable sold data: same community, same property type, recent actual sale prices. The count only tells you how competitive the room is; how much extra you are willing to pay to win should be decided from the data before you hear the number, and not revised in a panic at the table.
An illustrative example I made up: on offer night the agent says there are four offers. From the sold data, your reasoned price is $980,000 and your ceiling is $1,000,000. The correct move is to offer within that pre-set range — not to hear "four" and jump to $1,030,000. And if it later emerges that one of the four had expired that afternoon, that is exactly why the definition of the count matters more than the count itself.
If you suspect the number is padded, your agent can ask the listing brokerage to confirm the count of currently valid written offers. Misrepresenting offers exposes a registrant to discipline under TRESA and RECO. If you believe you were misled and harmed, keep the communications from that night; a complaint to RECO is a documented, available route.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The agent said five offers, so five people are definitely competing with me." Ask about the definition: are all five unexpired, unwithdrawn written offers? Verbal interest and expired offers do not count, and blending them into the number is misleading.
Misunderstanding 2: "If the seller says don't tell, the agent can withhold the number." Disclosing the number is a legal duty, not a courtesy the seller controls. What the seller controls is whether contents are shared — not whether the count is disclosed.
Misunderstanding 3: "An open offer process means I get to see everyone's cards." An open process shares only the parts the seller directed, equally with all offerors. Identities are never shared, and the scope is the seller's choice, not the buyers' menu.
On offer night, do these in order
- Set your price and your ceiling from comparable sold data first, write them down, and only then enter the offer process — never the reverse order.
- Have your agent confirm with the listing brokerage: how many currently valid written offers are there, as of what time?
- Ask whether this is a closed or an open process; if open, ask exactly what the seller has directed to be disclosed.
- Ask whether the listing brokerage also represents one of the competing buyers — that fact carries a disclosure duty.
- At the table, act only within your pre-set ceiling. If you want to break it, stop for five minutes and run the sold data again first.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. On offer night, the most expensive thing is not the house — it is a decision pushed around by a number.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Competing-offer disclosure details follow the regulation text and the seller's direction in each trade; verify specifics with RECO or an Ontario lawyer.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, s.35.1; O. Reg. 567/05, ss.22.7–22.8 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $980,000 to $1,030,000 figures are illustrative, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
The agent said five offers, so are five people definitely competing with me?
Ask about the definition: are all five unexpired, unwithdrawn written offers? Verbal interest and expired offers do not count, and blending them into the number is misleading.
If the seller says do not tell, can the agent withhold the number?
Disclosing the number is a legal duty, not a courtesy the seller controls. What the seller controls is whether contents are shared — not whether the count is disclosed.
Does an open offer process mean I get to see everyone's cards?
An open process shares only the parts the seller directed, equally with all offerors. Identities are never shared, and the scope is the seller's choice, not the buyers' menu.


