Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Bully Offers in Toronto: Know the Rules Before You Jump the Offer Date

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: a bully offer is not a secret weapon. It is an ordinary written offer delivered before the seller's scheduled offer date, usually with a short deadline to push the seller to decide early. Whether it is even looked at is decided neither by the buyer nor by the agents — it is decided by the written direction the seller gave their brokerage in advance. So before you work on price, ask one question first: will this seller consider early offers at all? Get that wrong, and no price will save you.

First: whether it goes anywhere depends on the seller's written direction

Ontario's default rule is simple: when a registrant receives a written offer, they must convey it to their client as soon as possible (O. Reg. 567/05, s. 22.10). Holding offers to a set date is the exception, and it only works if the seller has given clear, specific, detailed written direction. RECO's guidance (Bulletins 4.2 and 4.3) is explicit that this direction must say, specifically, how pre-emptive offers will be handled. Sellers typically choose one of a few options: do not tell me about them at all; tell me one arrived but show me no details; show me only offers that meet a price or terms threshold I set; or show me every one.

Two details are widely missed. First, a vague listing note such as "seller reserves the right to view pre-emptive offers without notice" is not enough — RECO says wording like that cannot replace specific direction and may even be misleading. Second, if the seller changes their mind and decides to look at a bully offer early, that takes a new written direction, and the brokerage must notify in writing everyone who has shown interest — people who viewed the home, booked a showing, said they would offer, or already submitted an offer — and update the listing information with the new offer time. In other words, the moment a seller seriously considers your early offer, other interested buyers will normally be told and given a chance to submit before the new deadline. Jumping the queue does not mean nobody else gets to run.

If you are the seller, my advice runs the other way: settle this before you list, and put it in the written direction. Trying to decide while a short-deadline offer sits on the table is where mistakes — and complaints — happen.

Second: for the buyer, the real risk sits in conditions and the deadline

What makes a bully offer look "strong" is usually three things: price, a short irrevocable period, and few or no conditions. None of the three is a legal requirement. No rule says a pre-emptive offer must beat the list price by a set percentage, or carry a deposit of a set size. Those are negotiated terms, set offer by offer. The problems I see usually come from buyers treating "looks strong" as "must be done this way."

Take an illustrative example with numbers I made up: a home listed at $1,000,000, and you offer $1,080,000 early, with no inspection or financing condition and a deposit larger than is commonly written (illustrative figures only — not market data and not a standard). Once that offer is accepted, you have a binding agreement. If the roof then turns out to be a problem, or your financing falls through, you can face losing the deposit and a claim for the seller's loss on a resale. RECO's own buyer guidance on competing offers makes the same point: a pre-approval is not a substitute for a financing condition, and skipping an inspection is a real risk. Conditions are not your agent's boilerplate — they are your insurance. Before you remove one, do the homework early: inspection done, status certificate reviewed for a condo, lawyer has seen the documents. If the homework is not done, do not strip the condition.

The deadline works the same way. During the irrevocable period you cannot unilaterally withdraw your offer. A very short deadline pressures the seller, but for that window you are bound too, at that price and on those terms. Set the length by how certain you actually are, not by copying someone else's playbook.

Third: once offers compete, what are you entitled to know?

If an early look turns into competing offers, Ontario law (O. Reg. 567/05, s. 22.7) gives everyone who has made a written offer one guaranteed piece of information: the seller's brokerage must tell you the number of competing written offers. Only written offers count — a verbal indication is not a competing offer.

That is where the guarantee ends. The price and terms of other offers are not shared by default. They are shared only if the seller directs the brokerage in writing to share them, then only with every person who made an offer, and the seller can direct that only part of the content be shared. In no case may a buyer's personal or identifying information be disclosed. So do not plan around "let me see what others offered first" — the rules guarantee you the count, not the contents.

A seller who receives a pre-emptive offer has the usual options: accept it, sign it back with changes, reject it, or set it aside and wait for the original offer date. A sign-back is a counter-offer, not a rejection, and the buyer can accept it or counter again. The seller's caution is the notification duty described above: once you decide to deal with an offer early, the change of process goes out in writing to everyone interested — you cannot quietly close with one offer.

Common misunderstandings

1. "If my bully offer is high enough, the seller has to look at it." No. A seller can direct in writing, in advance, that pre-emptive offers are not to be considered, and the brokerage follows that direction. A higher price does not override the seller's process; changing the process requires a new written direction and notice to everyone interested.

2. "Nobody will know about my bully offer, so I avoid competition." Usually the opposite. Once a seller decides to consider an early offer, interested buyers are notified in writing, the listing information is updated, and a new offer time is set. Your head start can turn into an earlier race, with several offers compared side by side anyway.

3. "No conditions is the standard bully format — with conditions I have no chance." There is no standard format. Keeping or waiving a condition is your own risk decision. If the homework is done and the risk is understood, waiving may be a choice. Waiving blind, just to look aggressive, can mean you have bought a problem instead of a house.

If you are considering a bully offer, work through this order

  1. Have your agent ask the listing brokerage directly: what does the seller's written direction say about pre-emptive offers — are they considered, and on what basis? Confirm the process before you talk price.
  2. Value the home from recent comparable sales, not from the list price. List prices are sometimes set low on purpose to attract competition, and "list plus a percentage" is the most common way buyers misprice.
  3. Do the homework that can be done early: confirm with your lender how firm your financing really is (a pre-approval is not an approval), inspect before you offer if you can, and have a lawyer review the status certificate on a condo.
  4. Decide each term — conditions, deadline length, deposit — by your own tolerance for risk, and think through the worst case first: the offer is accepted, and then financing or the property itself turns into a problem.
  5. Sellers: before listing, put the offer date and the treatment of pre-emptive offers into your written direction. If you change your mind, give a new written direction first, then have your brokerage notify everyone interested in writing and update the listing.
  6. Either side: keep the paper trail — directions, notices, and the times offers were delivered and answered. If there is ever a dispute, those records are what it is decided on.

Do things honestly, and do the work properly. — Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information, not legal advice. A seller's direction, the listing arrangements and the terms of a specific agreement can change the result; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and O. Reg. 567/05, s. 22.7 (number and content of competing offers) and s. 22.10 (conveying offers; client's written directions), Ontario e-Laws; RECO Bulletins 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3 and RECO's competing-offer guides for buyers and sellers (checked November 2026). The $1,000,000 and $1,080,000 figures are an illustrative example, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

If my bully offer is high enough, does the seller have to look at it?

No. A seller can direct in writing, in advance, that pre-emptive offers are not to be considered, and the brokerage follows that direction. A higher price does not override the seller's process; changing the process requires a new written direction and notice to everyone interested.

Will nobody know about my bully offer, so I avoid competition?

Usually the opposite. Once a seller decides to consider an early offer, interested buyers are notified in writing, the listing information is updated, and a new offer time is set. Your head start can turn into an earlier race, with several offers compared side by side anyway.

Is no conditions the standard bully format?

There is no standard format. Keeping or waiving a condition is your own risk decision. If the homework is done and the risk is understood, waiving may be a choice; waiving blind, just to look aggressive, can mean you have bought a problem instead of a house.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation