I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: the most useful work in a bidding war does not happen on offer night. It happens the day before, when you fix three things in writing — a defensible value from recent comparable sales, the maximum premium you are willing to pay above it, and the conditions you will not give up. Fix those, and you can win without regret and lose without second-guessing. Leave them unfixed, and the atmosphere of offer night will make the decision for you — usually at a higher price.
First: what Ontario's rules actually guarantee you will know
Many buyers assume a bidding war is a complete black box. It is not. Under section 22.7 of O. Reg. 567/05, made under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA), when the seller's brokerage receives competing written offers, it must communicate the number of competing written offers to every person who has made one. The seller cannot suppress that count.
That is where the guarantee ends. The substance of the offers — price, closing date, conditions — is shared only if the seller directs the brokerage, in writing, to share it, and the seller may share only part of it. A buyer's identity, and anything that could identify them, may never be shared. A verbal expression of interest is not a written offer and does not enter the count.
So calibrate your expectations: you are entitled to know how many buyers are in, not what anyone else offered. Anyone who claims they can find out the other side's price is either breaking the rules or bluffing. A pre-emptive ("bully") offer runs under the same framework: a seller who receives an offer before the stated offer date may accept it, reject it, or hold to the original date. Whether you, as another interested buyer, hear about it in time depends on your agent having registered your interest clearly and staying in contact — there is no legal backstop that automatically notifies every casual viewer, so do not assume the system will warn you.
Second: when entering is worth it, and when walking away is the win
There is really one sound reason to enter a bidding war: scarcity. If you have been waiting for a specific school zone, lot, or floor plan that surfaces only every few years, missing it has a real cost, and paying a measured premium has a logic to it.
The more common trap is the deliberately underpriced listing, set low to manufacture competition. Your measuring stick must always be recent comparable sales — never the asking price. Paying $100,000 over asking is not overpaying if the comparables support it; paying $100,000 over what comparable homes sold for is overpaying, whatever the asking price was.
An invented example to show the arithmetic (illustrative figures only, not market data): a home is listed at $999,000, and recent comparable sales on the street sit between $1,120,000 and $1,160,000. You win at $1,150,000 and feel you paid "$150,000 over asking" — in fact you landed inside the supported range. Reverse it: a home fairly listed at $1,150,000 gets pushed by the room to $1,240,000. That extra amount has no sales data behind it, and if the lender's appraisal comes in low, you cover the gap yourself.
Then there is the hidden bill: conditions waived to win. Dropping inspection and financing conditions feels decisive on the night; the risk lands later. A major defect found after closing, or a mortgage that falls through, puts your deposit and more at stake. Conditions are not weakness — they are your exit routes. Before waiving one, ask plainly whether this property is worth the risk you are taking on.
Third: how to play a pre-emptive offer without hurting yourself
Before you fire a pre-emptive offer, confirm three things: you have viewed the home properly and done your homework; your financing pre-approval is real and covers your price; and the property is genuinely scarce enough to justify breaking the seller's timetable. Missing any one of the three, a pre-emptive offer just moves the bidding war to the moment you are least prepared.
The usual shape of a pre-emptive offer is a price clearly above asking, a short window for the seller to respond, and a healthy deposit. The aim is to make waiting look unattractive. But understand the downside: the seller can simply refuse and wait for the original date — and now your hand has been shown. Decide in advance that if it is refused and a full bidding round follows, your ceiling is still the number you set yesterday, not a higher one invented because you have "already made a move."
If you are on the receiving end — notified that someone else has gone pre-emptive — you have exactly three options: compete, stick to the original plan, or walk away. There is no fourth option called panic. The ceiling you set yesterday is still today's ceiling.
Common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The agent says there are five offers — that's just pressure to make me bid more." The number of written offers is information the seller's brokerage is legally required to communicate accurately; fabricating it is a rule violation. You do not have to trust the atmosphere, but the count itself is regulated.
Misunderstanding 2: "Offer contents eventually come out, so I'll learn what others bid." Disclosure happens only on the seller's written direction, and the seller may share nothing at all. The normal state of affairs is that you learn the count and nothing else.
Misunderstanding 3: "Winning the bidding war means I won." Winning the right home at or under your ceiling is a win. Winning above your ceiling spends years of future appreciation in one evening. Losing to someone willing to pay more often means the home was never in your budget — that is information, not failure.
If you are heading into a bidding war, work in this order
- The day before, build a value range from recent comparable sales with your agent, then write down your absolute ceiling separately. On paper. It does not change on offer night.
- Confirm with your mortgage professional that your approval covers the ceiling price — and what you would use to cover a gap if the appraisal comes in below the purchase price.
- Have the deposit ready: amount, delivery deadline, and who it is payable to, all confirmed against the contract terms. Pre-emptive offers especially reward speed of delivery.
- Go through the conditions one by one — inspection, financing, status certificate review for a condo — and decide which can be shortened and which are untouchable before you enter.
- Agree on the walk-away point in advance and let your agent enforce it. No new numbers get invented on the phone mid-evening.
I am Ming Ren. Facing a bidding war, put the ceiling and the conditions on the table first, and we will work from the sold data, line by line — not from the temperature of the room.
This article is general information, not legal advice. The consequences of any offer term depend on your contract; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and O. Reg. 567/05, s.22.7 (communication of the number of competing written offers; sharing of substance only on the seller's direction), Ontario e-Laws; RECO's published guidance on competing offers (checked November 2026). The $999,000 and $1,120,000–$1,160,000 figures are illustrative examples, not real sales.
Frequently asked questions
The agent says there are five offers — is that just pressure to bid more?
The number of written offers is information the seller's brokerage is legally required to communicate accurately; fabricating it is a rule violation.
Will offer contents eventually come out, so I will learn what others bid?
Disclosure happens only on the seller's written direction, and the seller may share nothing at all; the normal state is that you learn the count and nothing else.
Does winning the bidding war mean I won?
Winning the right home at or under your ceiling is a win; winning above your ceiling spends years of future appreciation in one evening.


